10 Best Peyton Manning Rookie Cards of All-Time
With more than 40 to choose from, we count down the ten best Peyton Manning rookie cards. Includes images, card analysis, a handy buying guide and more for the all-time great quarterback.
When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.
With more than 40 to choose from, we count down the ten best Peyton Manning rookie cards. Includes images, card analysis, a handy buying guide and more for the all-time great quarterback.

Featuring the most valuable card in existence, 1909-11 T206 Baseball is considered the greatest vintage set of all-time by many collectors. The famed T206 Honus Wagner card is the key card in the release but there is much more available to collectors in the massive set.
The Justice League of America has been protecting the Earth from super villains and rich guys from Metropolis for over 50 years. 2009 Rittenhouse Justice League Archives commemorates the first decade of Justice League comics with a detailed release.
Making the move from the hardcourt to the gridiron, 2015 Panini Luxe Football is a high-end release with on-card signatures, four hits per box and all cards numbered to 99 or less.
One of the key high-end releases each year, 2015 Panini National Treasures Football is back with another premium look at the NFL. Hobby boxes includes three autographs and three relic cards.
2015 Topps 60th Anniversary Retired Autograph Football is an online-exclusive product that promises one autograph per pack and features many Hall of Fame subjects like John Elway, Jerry Rice and Brett Favre.
2015 Topps Diamond Football marks the debut of a new premium line from the card maker. Each box has an autograph numbered to 10 or less, an autographed patch card and an additional autograph or signed patch card.
2015 Topps Field Access Football makes its mark with a heavy focus on action photographs and full-bleed images. Each box yields four autographs.
2015 Topps Strata Football drops the base set and basic inserts. Instead, hobby boxes opt for an all-autograph configuration that features two cards per box.
2015 Topps Supreme Football again utilizes a four-card format headlined by one low-numbered relic or autograph card per box
Featuring a deep base set and multiple inserts, 2015 Topps UFC Chronicles also delivers for hit collectors with five autographs or relics per box.
2015 Upper Deck Marvel Dossier combines entertainment cards and dog tags into one basic release. Each pack includes three cards and one collectible tag and necklace chain.
Proving you can never have too much gold, 2015-16 Panini Gold Standard Basketball again showcases the distinct color in an ornate release. Each hobby box includes one Rookie Jersey Autograph and two other hits.
A new choice for NBA collectors, 2015-16 Panini Revolution Basketball focuses on inserts and parallels based around a foil design. Limited autographs drop one per eight-box case.
Flashy and bold, 2015-16 Panini Select Basketball continues to operate as a Prizm 2.0 set. Each box includes three total hits and 12 Prizm refractor parallels.
2015-16 SPx Hockey brings the noise with one guaranteed autograph and two additional hits per box. This includes signed options for Connor McDavid.
Honoring the past while looking to the future, 2016 Donruss Baseball features many hobby staples in a familiar format. Boxes promise three autographs or memorabilia cards.
Get a complete look at the 2016 Donruss Baseball variations with this helpful guide. Includes full checklist, gallery and guide to each of the options.
Collect the many styles of Barbie with 2016 Funko Barbie Mystery Minis vinyl figures. Issued in a blind-box format, the mini figures cover multiple decades of Barbie releases in one collection.
2016 Funko Pop Mean Girls vinyl figures look back at the modern teen classic with several main characters. The lineup includes Lindsay Lohan as Cady and Rachel McAdams as Regina.
2016 Leaf Babe Ruth Collection Baseball celebrates The Great Bambino with a comprehensive product. In addition to base and inserts, collectors can find two relics per case, on average.
The retail version of Leaf’s football lineup, 2016 Leaf Draft Football features top names for the NFL Draft. Each box includes two autographs.
2016 Leaf Metal Draft Football focuses on top 2016 NFL Draft prospects with five on-card autographs per box. Collectors can also find limited Tom Brady autographs.
One of several pre-draft football options from Leaf, 2016 Leaf Ultimate Draft Football is an all-autograph release that looks back with early 1990s Leaf Baseball designs. Each box includes five autographs from a checklist of top prospects and even offers limited signed options for Tom Brady.
Featuring the debut figure for Jahlil Okafor and another figure for Steph Curry, McFarlane NBA 28 Sports Picks Figures add six new options to the deep roster of basketball collectibles.
2016 Onyx Authenticated Platinum Elite Baseball covers the top prospects with at least two on-card autographs per box. Highlights include top 2015 draft picks Dansby Swanson and Brendan Rodgers.
Honoring the iconic series, 2016 Rittenhouse Star Trek The Original Series 50th Anniversary takes a look back with a comprehensive release. Boxes include two autographs.
2016 Topps Anthology Series 1 Baseball celebrates the history of the flagship release with a retrospective look at the designs from 1951 to 2016. The release includes three different sets and limited posters.
2016 Topps Garbage Pail Kids Not-Scars Oscars cards offer a playful look at the Academy Awards. The online-only product includes top names like Christian Bale, Jennifer Lawrence, Kate Winslet, Leonardo DiCaprio, and Matt Damon.
Built around nostalgia, 2016 Topps Heritage Baseball focuses on the 1967 Topps design. Each hobby box promises one autograph or relic card.
Building on the nostalgia, the modern trend of variations continues in 2016 Topps Heritage Baseball. Spot all the differences using our detailed guide.
2016 Topps Marketside Pizza Baseball takes a bite out of collecting with an exclusive Walmart set. View full details and a checklist for the oddball baseball release found only in select pizza boxes.
Focusing on the simple side of collecting, 2016 Topps MLB Sticker Collection features team mascots and top players in a 301-card set.
Well known for their take on pop culture and consumer products, 2016 Topps MLB Wacky Packages takes square aim at professional baseball. Similar to the regular Wacky Packages, there are both hobby and hobby collector boxes.
Focusing on the simple side of collecting, 2016 Topps Opening Day Baseball includes a basic format and manageable base set. Inserts average one per pack.
Keep track of all the 2016 Topps Opening Day Baseball Variations in one place using our detailed guide. Includes full checklist, side-by-side comparisons with the base cards and much more.
Get full details and a checklist for the 2016 Topps Spring Fever Baseball promo set that is exclusive to hobby stores. The packs also include rare autographed versions.
Focusing more on the new movie, 2016 Topps Star Wars: The Force Awakens Series 2 continues the format of the Series 1 release. Hobby boxes promise two hits, along with multiple inserts and parallels.
COMC and eBay are two of the biggest websites when it comes to shopping for sports cards. Here’s a look at some of the pros and cons for each.
Card grading can add value and peace of mind to your collection. Use our practical guide to get the most out of your submissions and pick the best company to grade your cards.

1957 Topps Baseball card checklist, detailed set analysis, key cards, shopping guide & more. It is one of the most sought after post-war vintage baseball card sets thanks to the inclusion of rookie cards of Frank Robinson, Brooks Robinson, Don Drysdale, Bill Mazeroski, Jim Bunning, and Whitey Herzog. 1957 Topps also features a rock solid lineup of Hall of Famers, including Sandy Koufax, Mickey Mantle, Hank Aaron, Willie Mays, Roberto Clemente and many more.
Enter the world of Azeroth with Funko Pop Warcraft Movie vinyl figures. The line features a few characters from the film, including Lothar, Durotan and Garona.
Peyton Manning is one of the greatest quarterbacks of all-time. With a second Super Bowl win, his cards have been surging. Get a real-time list of the hottest Peyton Manning cards currently listed on eBay with this handy auction tracker.

Batman has been a fixture of pop culture since 1939 and with his popularity as powerful as ever, now is a great time to get into collecting all things Caped Crusader. This guide will help you get started with a detailed overview of his key comics, trading cards and figures.

The Flash is the fastest man on Earth but compiling a complete collection of Flash memorabilia is no quick project. This guide will give you the perfect launching pad for your Scarlet Speedster collection.
The NFL had never seen a pass rusher like Reggie White and he rewrote the record book when it came to sacking quarterbacks. It’s easy to see why his football cards are some of the most valuable for defensive players and this top list brings together his best trading card appearances.

The X-Men are the world’s most famous team of mutants and collectibles inspired by their television, movie, comics and cartoons are plentiful. This guide helps you start your collection with the key trading cards, figures and comic books.
Bob Feller’s amazing right arm did what LeBron James and Johnny Manziel have not — brought a championship to Cleveland! This top list brings together the best cards of the “Heater from Van Meter,” one of baseball’s greatest pitchers and a Hall of Fame legend for the Cleveland Indians.
Eddie Collins is considered to be the best contact-hitting second baseman ever and also baseball’s first base-stealing king. This top list chronicles some of the key Eddie Collins trading cards, including appearances in legendary tobacco card sets from the early 20th century.
Marcus Allen is the only player to have a Heisman Trophy, NFL MVP, and both a Super Bowl and NCAA championship during his time in football. This top list highlights the best cards from his legendary career spent with the Los Angeles Raiders and Kansas City Chiefs.
With the hundreds of options out there, what are the top 10 most iconic Mickey Mantle baseball cards?
After overcoming a mining accident and a slow start to his major league career, Red Ruffing became the ace of the New York Yankees staff and helped them win six World Series titles. This top list includes Ruffing’s best trading card appearances which drop in some of the hobby’s most iconic sets from the 1930s and 1940s.
Steve Carlton was the first pitcher to win four Cy Young Awards and his 1972 season gave fans an all-time great performance. This top list brings together his best baseball cards from his 24-year career.
Vintage basketball cards tend to get overlooked in the hobby, but 10 cards stand out from the rest. View a comprehensive guide to the top ten vintage basketball rookie cards of all-time, including cards images, info, shopping guide and more.
The Boston Celtics offer some of the greatest rookie cards of all-time. Check out our complete guide to both vintage and modern rookie card options for the Celtics.
Wilt Chamberlain is one of basketball’s biggest icons and a true legend of the game. Take a look at some of his most celebrated basketball cards with this top list.
Do you smell that? No, it’s not chimichangas, it’s our ultimate guide to collecting Deadpool. Appearing in several comics, dozens of figure lines, and multiple trading card releases, there’s a lot of Deadpool to go around.
The Green Arrow has been fighting crime alongside the biggest names in the DC Universe since 1941 but has largely struggled to attain the pop culture relevance his Justice League colleagues enjoy. With his profile now on the rise, this guide runs down the collectible market for the Emerald Archer.

If your Spidey senses are tingling it’s probably because you’re dying to learn more about collecting Spider-Man trading cards, comic books, statues, and action figures! You’re in luck because this guide will help you track down all the major options to pursue.
Many years after her introduction in comics, Wonder Woman is finally appearing in films like Batman vs. Superman and Justice League, as well as her own franchise. This guide will help you wade though all the memorabilia options for the Amazon Princess, including key comics, trading cards & figures.