Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay

Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay

One of the top quarterbacks of this, or any, generation, Peyton Manning cards continue to generate interest. While he first made his name with the Indianapolis Colts and won a Super Bowl, Manning essentially reinvented himself with the Denver Broncos while notching his second Super Bowl win.

Many NFL records later, he has not only grown his already immense fanbase but earned even more respect from collectors worldwide.

Hottest Peyton Manning Football Cards

While the top Peyton Manning rookie cards will always be a sure thing, they came just before the boom in autographs and memorabilia. As a result, 1998 Playoff Contenders is the only set with a signed rookie card.

He does have other pricey autographs from 1998, but these are inserts and not rookies. So even with his career success, the majority of Manning's rookie cards are still relatively affordable.

Most-Watched Peyton Manning Cards Hot List

Here's a real-time hot list of the Peyton Manning card auctions generating the most interest on eBay right now. The list, which is based primarily on the number of people watching the listings, updates automatically. Check back often to see new Peyton Manning cards and trends.

Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 2
82 watchers
Bids: 31
Current Bid/Price (USD): $175.00
Time Left: 2021/09/26 23:00:53
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 3
77 watchers
Bids: 21
Current Bid/Price (USD): $560.00
Time Left: 2021/09/29 03:59:15
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 4
70 watchers
Bids: 34
Current Bid/Price (USD): $198.50
Time Left: 2021/09/27 01:21:45
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 5
56 watchers
Bids: 15
Current Bid/Price (USD): $1681.00
Time Left: 2021/09/29 00:23:10
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 6
49 watchers
Bids: 14
Current Bid/Price (USD): $229.50
Time Left: 2021/09/28 00:00:01
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 7
49 watchers
Bids: 30
Current Bid/Price (USD): $51.00
Time Left: 2021/09/27 00:07:16
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 8
44 watchers
Bids: 21
Current Bid/Price (USD): $232.50
Time Left: 2021/10/01 00:43:01
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 9
43 watchers
Bids: 8
Current Bid/Price (USD): $59.00
Time Left: 2021/09/29 16:53:24
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 10
43 watchers
Bids: 18
Current Bid/Price (USD): $186.00
Time Left: 2021/09/27 01:13:45
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 11
40 watchers
Bids: 20
Current Bid/Price (USD): $1125.00
Time Left: 2021/09/29 00:16:34
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 12
38 watchers
Bids: 7
Current Bid/Price (USD): $52.72
Time Left: 2021/09/27 01:18:00
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 13
38 watchers
Bids: 9
Current Bid/Price (USD): $89.00
Time Left: 2021/10/05 02:00:50
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 14
37 watchers
Bids: 13
Current Bid/Price (USD): $510.00
Time Left: 2021/10/02 00:13:35
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 15
37 watchers
Bids: 12
Current Bid/Price (USD): $64.00
Time Left: 2021/09/28 02:10:01
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 16
37 watchers
Bids: 10
Current Bid/Price (USD): $42.00
Time Left: 2021/09/28 01:09:36
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 17
36 watchers
Bids: 13
Current Bid/Price (USD): $24.50
Time Left: 2021/09/28 01:30:01
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 18
35 watchers
Bids: 19
Current Bid/Price (USD): $222.50
Time Left: 2021/09/28 01:04:12
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 19
34 watchers
Bids: 28
Current Bid/Price (USD): $295.00
Time Left: 2021/09/26 23:44:52
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 20
34 watchers
Bids: 20
Current Bid/Price (USD): $282.00
Time Left: 2021/09/27 17:37:42
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 21
34 watchers
Bids: 16
Current Bid/Price (USD): $152.50
Time Left: 2021/09/27 04:41:20
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 22
33 watchers
Bids: 8
Current Bid/Price (USD): $153.50
Time Left: 2021/09/27 00:57:48
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 23
32 watchers
Bids: 10
Current Bid/Price (USD): $217.50
Time Left: 2021/10/04 01:18:01
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 24
31 watchers
Bids: 7
Current Bid/Price (USD): $126.50
Time Left: 2021/09/27 01:47:37
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 25
31 watchers
Bids: 13
Current Bid/Price (USD): $148.05
Time Left: 2021/09/28 17:10:38
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 26
30 watchers
Bids: 8
Current Bid/Price (USD): $94.01
Time Left: 2021/10/04 02:15:43
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 27
29 watchers
Bids: 22
Current Bid/Price (USD): $255.00
Time Left: 2021/09/29 02:19:16
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 28
27 watchers
Bids: 8
Current Bid/Price (USD): $88.00
Time Left: 2021/10/01 00:53:01
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 29
26 watchers
Bids: 4
Current Bid/Price (USD): $51.00
Time Left: 2021/10/01 00:52:01
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 30
25 watchers
Bids: 8
Current Bid/Price (USD): $435.00
Time Left: 2021/09/29 00:38:49
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 31
25 watchers
Bids: 5
Current Bid/Price (USD): $41.00
Time Left: 2021/09/29 01:23:43
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 32
25 watchers
Bids: 10
Current Bid/Price (USD): $21.50
Time Left: 2021/09/27 01:52:44
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 33
25 watchers
Bids: 9
Current Bid/Price (USD): $6.70
Time Left: 2021/09/28 00:07:31
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 34
25 watchers
Bids: 11
Current Bid/Price (USD): $76.99
Time Left: 2021/09/30 01:38:48
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 35
24 watchers
Bids: 6
Current Bid/Price (USD): $13.49
Time Left: 2021/10/01 00:54:01
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 36
24 watchers
Bids: 10
Current Bid/Price (USD): $61.99
Time Left: 2021/09/27 02:26:40
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 37
24 watchers
Bids: 6
Current Bid/Price (USD): $26.00
Time Left: 2021/09/28 02:11:04
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 38
24 watchers
Bids: 10
Current Bid/Price (USD): $51.00
Time Left: 2021/09/28 03:06:40
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 39
24 watchers
Bids: 15
Current Bid/Price (USD): $255.00
Time Left: 2021/09/28 02:30:04
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 40
23 watchers
Bids: 8
Current Bid/Price (USD): $51.00
Time Left: 2021/10/01 00:55:01
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 41
23 watchers
Bids: 7
Current Bid/Price (USD): $66.00
Time Left: 2021/09/27 01:55:01
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 42
23 watchers
Bids: 17
Current Bid/Price (USD): $125.20
Time Left: 2021/09/26 04:35:04
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 43
22 watchers
Bids: 12
Current Bid/Price (USD): $29.00
Time Left: 2021/10/03 00:21:41
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 44
22 watchers
Bids: 7
Current Bid/Price (USD): $36.00
Time Left: 2021/10/03 00:44:50
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 45
22 watchers
Bids: 4
Current Bid/Price (USD): $142.50
Time Left: 2021/09/29 00:55:19
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 46
21 watchers
Bids: 11
Current Bid/Price (USD): $51.00
Time Left: 2021/09/27 03:41:47
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 47
21 watchers
Bids: 11
Current Bid/Price (USD): $246.50
Time Left: 2021/09/27 04:06:55
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 48
21 watchers
Bids: 10
Current Bid/Price (USD): $56.00
Time Left: 2021/09/27 23:29:19
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 49
20 watchers
Bids: 9
Current Bid/Price (USD): $10.00
Time Left: 2021/09/27 02:01:49
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 50
20 watchers
Bids: 18
Current Bid/Price (USD): $273.68
Time Left: 2021/09/27 01:00:32
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 51
20 watchers
Bids: 7
Current Bid/Price (USD): $22.50
Time Left: 2021/10/01 00:56:01
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 52
20 watchers
Bids: 9
Current Bid/Price (USD): $17.50
Time Left: 2021/09/27 00:24:01
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 53
20 watchers
Bids: 17
Current Bid/Price (USD): $255.01
Time Left: 2021/09/27 01:33:33
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 54
20 watchers
Bids: 19
Current Bid/Price (USD): $60.00
Time Left: 2021/09/26 11:43:43
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 55
20 watchers
Bids: 12
Current Bid/Price (USD): $799.00
Time Left: 2021/09/29 03:59:18
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 56
20 watchers
Bids: 10
Current Bid/Price (USD): $58.00
Time Left: 2021/09/29 00:13:37
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 57
20 watchers
Bids: 8
Current Bid/Price (USD): $320.00
Time Left: 2021/09/29 03:59:36
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 58
19 watchers
Bids: 7
Current Bid/Price (USD): $101.33
Time Left: 2021/09/29 03:00:14
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 59
19 watchers
Bids: 5
Current Bid/Price (USD): $113.50
Time Left: 2021/10/05 00:19:04
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 60
19 watchers
Bids: 5
Current Bid/Price (USD): $16.50
Time Left: 2021/09/26 22:22:59
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 61
19 watchers
Bids: 10
Current Bid/Price (USD): $17.50
Time Left: 2021/09/27 02:36:37
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 62
19 watchers
Bids: 14
Current Bid/Price (USD): $39.00
Time Left: 2021/09/26 05:16:04
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 63
18 watchers
Bids: 9
Current Bid/Price (USD): $104.50
Time Left: 2021/10/01 00:57:01
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 64
18 watchers
Bids: 10
Current Bid/Price (USD): $31.00
Time Left: 2021/09/26 22:28:23
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 65
18 watchers
Bids: 15
Current Bid/Price (USD): $122.59
Time Left: 2021/09/28 02:30:00
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 66
18 watchers
Bids: 5
Current Bid/Price (USD): $18.68
Time Left: 2021/10/04 04:10:08
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 67
17 watchers
Bids: 14
Current Bid/Price (USD): $89.00
Time Left: 2021/09/30 03:16:28
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 68
17 watchers
Bids: 1
Current Bid/Price (USD): $330.00
Time Left: 2021/09/29 01:00:39
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 69
17 watchers
Bids: 7
Current Bid/Price (USD): $5.50
Time Left: 2021/09/27 02:00:39
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 70
17 watchers
Bids: 14
Current Bid/Price (USD): $55.00
Time Left: 2021/09/27 01:00:32
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 71
17 watchers
Bids: 16
Current Bid/Price (USD): $49.00
Time Left: 2021/09/29 02:20:01
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 72
16 watchers
Bids: 6
Current Bid/Price (USD): $8.22
Time Left: 2021/09/27 01:51:04
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 73
16 watchers
Bids: 7
Current Bid/Price (USD): $23.50
Time Left: 2021/09/27 02:45:56
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 74
16 watchers
Bids: 26
Current Bid/Price (USD): $187.50
Time Left: 2021/10/01 00:46:01
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 75
16 watchers
Bids: 6
Current Bid/Price (USD): $5.50
Time Left: 2021/10/01 00:47:01
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 76
16 watchers
Bids: 4
Current Bid/Price (USD): $60.00
Time Left: 2021/09/27 01:16:42
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 77
16 watchers
Bids: 16
Current Bid/Price (USD): $365.00
Time Left: 2021/09/27 01:30:20
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 78
16 watchers
Bids: 25
Current Bid/Price (USD): $115.50
Time Left: 2021/09/28 02:00:56
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 79
16 watchers
Bids: 12
Current Bid/Price (USD): $147.50
Time Left: 2021/09/27 01:41:35
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 80
15 watchers
Bids: 3
Current Bid/Price (USD): $4.24
Time Left: 2021/10/04 02:15:46
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 81
15 watchers
Bids: 4
Current Bid/Price (USD): $21.50
Time Left: 2021/09/27 01:22:40
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 82
15 watchers
Bids: 7
Current Bid/Price (USD): $25.72
Time Left: 2021/09/27 16:04:03
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 83
15 watchers
Bids: 9
Current Bid/Price (USD): $46.51
Time Left: 2021/09/28 01:54:58
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 84
15 watchers
Bids: 16
Current Bid/Price (USD): $112.50
Time Left: 2021/09/30 01:28:39
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 85
15 watchers
Bids: 6
Current Bid/Price (USD): $9.50
Time Left: 2021/09/27 01:04:51
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 86
15 watchers
Bids: 0
Current Bid/Price (USD): $199.00
Time Left: 2021/09/26 23:30:10
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 87
15 watchers
Bids: 3
Current Bid/Price (USD): $20.50
Time Left: 2021/09/27 04:37:55
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 88
15 watchers
Bids: 8
Current Bid/Price (USD): $68.00
Time Left: 2021/09/28 23:29:00
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 89
15 watchers
Bids: 5
Current Bid/Price (USD): $20.50
Time Left: 2021/09/30 02:16:41
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 90
15 watchers
Bids: 5
Current Bid/Price (USD): $102.50
Time Left: 2021/10/01 01:42:50
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 91
15 watchers
Bids: 10
Current Bid/Price (USD): $12.50
Time Left: 2021/09/28 02:43:52
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 92
14 watchers
Bids: 4
Current Bid/Price (USD): $2.25
Time Left: 2021/09/29 18:47:28
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 93
14 watchers
Bids: 5
Current Bid/Price (USD): $23.05
Time Left: 2021/09/28 01:15:36
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 94
14 watchers
Bids: 4
Current Bid/Price (USD): $5.00
Time Left: 2021/09/27 02:03:53
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 95
14 watchers
Bids: 5
Current Bid/Price (USD): $8.00
Time Left: 2021/09/29 01:39:19
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 96
14 watchers
Bids: 4
Current Bid/Price (USD): $8.50
Time Left: 2021/09/30 03:16:16
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 97
14 watchers
Bids: 4
Current Bid/Price (USD): $51.00
Time Left: 2021/10/05 00:16:55
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 98
14 watchers
Bids: 10
Current Bid/Price (USD): $54.00
Time Left: 2021/10/01 00:42:01
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 99
14 watchers
Bids: 5
Current Bid/Price (USD): $20.50
Time Left: 2021/10/01 00:45:01
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 100
14 watchers
Bids: 9
Current Bid/Price (USD): $36.00
Time Left: 2021/10/01 02:50:53
Hottest Peyton Manning Cards on eBay 101
14 watchers
Bids: 1
Current Bid/Price (USD): $1299.00
Time Left: 2021/09/27 02:57:44


Ryan Cracknell

 |  E-Mail Author
Ryan is a former member of The Cardboard Connection Writing Staff.   His collecting origins began with winter bike rides to the corner store, tossing a couple of quarters onto the counter and peddling home with a couple packs of O-Pee-Chee hockey in his pocket. Today, he continues to build sets, go after inserts with cool technologies, chase Montreal Expos and finish off his John Jaha master collection.

    Leave a Comment: