Mickey Mantle Rookie Cards and Memorabilia Buying Guide

Mickey Mantle

Date of Birth: October 20, 1931
Rookie Card Year: 1951
Investment Rating: 9.0


Overview

In terms of collectibility in the world of baseball cards and memorabilia, few can rival, Mickey Mantle. Despite being long since retired, as well as deceased, Mickey Mantle cards continue to break new records. The release of his 1952 Topps baseball card coincided with, what has long been considered, the birth of the modern baseball card.

As a result of his remarkable achievements on the field and larger than life personality, Mickey Mantle cards and memorabilia are still one of the top investments in the hobby today. His game-used memorabilia can reach the stratosphere, in terms of dollars, on the rare occasions when they become available at auction. Additionally, his iconic status as an American sports legends has made him the subject of numerous figures, pieces of artwork and photographs.

Mickey Mantle Rookie Cards Checklist Gallery

Mickey Mantle's rookie card is generally considered to be from 1951 Bowman Baseball. In that same year, Wheaties cereal issued a set of eight black and white premium photographs, one of which was Mantle. Despite not being his first card, the 1952 Topps Mickey Mantle deserves mention as well. Additionally, in 1952, the Tip-Top Bread Company issued a label bearing his likeness, which is quite collectible, as are his 1952 Star-Cal Decal and 1952 Berk Ross cards.

1951 Bowman Mickey Mantle RC #253

Mickey Mantle Rookie Cards and Memorabilia Buying Guide 1

As the Mickey Mantle rookie card,  this card commands huge dollars on the secondary market. The fact that there are very few in top condition also contributes to the high prices. The posed and painted card features subdued colors. Mantle's youth is unmistakable.

1952 Topps Mickey Mantle #311

Mickey Mantle Rookie Cards and Memorabilia Buying Guide 2

This is the grand-daddy of them all and, perhaps, the hobby's most iconic card. The 1952 Topps Mickey Mantle started the rookie card craze of the mid-1980s when collectors realized that vintage copies of the card were starting to command huge dollars. Many were seeing greater returns than traditional investment portfolios. Oddly enough, it's not a rookie card as Bowman released one a year earlier. But it is the landmark card of one of the hobby's most important sets. The legend has overtaken any labels that might be attached to it.

For years, baseball cards were produced in multiple series with the first being printed at the start of the season and later series closer to the end. Latter series were printed in smaller quantities as the focus of children turned to the start of football season and a return to school. Mantle's card #311 was printed in a later series and, legend has it, that then Topps CEO, Sy Berger, dumped hundreds of unsold Topps cases into the Hudson River, forever sealing countless 1952 Topps Mickey Mantle cards in a watery tomb.

Other Mickey Mantle Collecting Guides

Find out more about Mickey Mantle cards and memorabilia by browsing our featured guides and resources below:

Mickey Mantle Rookie Cards and Memorabilia Buying Guide 3
« Previous1234
Mickey Mantle Rookie Cards and Memorabilia Buying Guide 20

Memorabilia

Mickey Mantle Signed Memorabilia Guide

As a result of his investment value, collectibility and overall popularity, Mickey Mantle's autograph is one of the most forged in the entire sports memorabilia market. Contributing to this is the fact that Mantle's signature changed considerably from his playing days to the items signed post-retirement. When evaluating signature items, the age of the piece must be taken into account when matching items to autograph style.

Below you will find examples of what authentic Mickey Mantle autographs look like. This can be used as a first point of reference for determining the legitimacy of autograph memorabilia, but is not a substitute for having your items authenticated by a well-respected professional autograph authentication company. Some of the trusted sources within the sports memorabilia market for authenticated Mickey Mantle autographs include the following companies: PSA, JSA, Upper Deck and Steiner. Click on any of the images below to view full-size photos.

Cut Signature Exemplars

Mickey Mantle Rookie Cards and Memorabilia Buying Guide 21

Above is an early signature example of Mickey Mantle.

Mickey Mantle Rookie Cards and Memorabilia Buying Guide 22

Above is Mantle's later playing days and post-retirement signature.

Mickey Mantle Key Signature Attributes: Looking at the two authenticated Mickey Mantle signatures above, it's hard to believe they were penned by the same hand. Mantle was an extremely popular member of the autograph circuit in his retirement. Appealing at countless shows, legitimate samples of his penmanship are not in short supply. Unfortunately, they still do not meet demand. As such, it is important to know when an item was signed as his signature changed once a member of the circuit. Because the majority of his autographs came during this time frame, here are the signature characteristics of the later example.

  1. The flamboyant and matching styles of the letter's "M" are very consistent.
  2. The dotted letter "i" is almost always present.
  3. The half "y" in Mickey is common.
  4. The letter "t" in Mantle sometimes consists of a crossed loop resembling an "l", but not always.
  5. The letters "e" in both first and last name are typical cursive.
  6. The letter "l" in Mantle is always a loop.

Signed Baseball Pricing

Active Listings for Mickey Mantle Signed Baseballs

Mickey Mantle Rookie Cards and Memorabilia Buying Guide 23

Signed Bat Pricing

Active Listings for Mickey Mantle Signed Baseball Bats

Mickey Mantle Rookie Cards and Memorabilia Buying Guide 24

Signed 8x10 Photo Pricing

Active Listings for Mickey Mantle Signed Photographs

     Mickey Mantle Rookie Cards and Memorabilia Buying Guide 25   

Mickey Mantle Rookie Cards and Memorabilia Buying Guide 3
« Previous1234

Fan Shop

Despite being absent from the diamond for over 40 years, Mickey Mantle's popularity remains intact. A testament to his larger than life personality and baseball prowess that endeared him to Yankee fans of his generation and those of future ones. As a result, Mantle has no shortage of fan items available on the market. From jerseys and store model bats, figures and photographs, there are plenty of choices for fans and collectors. Provided here is an overview of some of Mantle's non-autographed collectibles and souvenirs, perfect for the Mickey Mantle fan on your shopping list.

Mickey Mantle Jerseys

Manufacturers: Mitchell & Ness, Mirage, Majestic

Purchasing a vintage or retro jersey of a long-retired player like Mickey Mantle, is different than purchasing one of a current player. While you can certainly customize a new Yankee's jersey with Mantle's name and number, it just isn't the same as purchasing an actual vintage or retro-styled jersey. Three primary companies currently manufacture retro-style jersey's: Mitchell & Ness, Mirage and Majestic. Majestic jerseys are retro but use current fabrics similar to modern professional jerseys.

For a jersey with the true look and feel of an authentic old-time jersey, Mitchell & Ness's Cooperstown Collection is going to be your best option. Flawlessly tailored to replicate the exact jersey Mantle wore in terms of look and feel. The Mitchell & Ness jerseys are crafted from a wool flannel blend with careful attention to period detail in terms of pinstripes, logos numbering, lettering and patches. These jerseys are currently available in home and road versions from three of Mantle's most legendary seasons: 1951, 1952, 1961.

Mickey Mantle Rookie Cards and Memorabilia Buying Guide 43  Mickey Mantle Rookie Cards and Memorabilia Buying Guide 44

Mickey Mantle Bats

Manufacturers: Louisville Slugger, Hillerich Bradsby, Worth, Wilson

When you swing the lumber as sweetly as "The Mick" did, no Mickey Mantle collection should be without a store model and commemorative bat. Store model bats from the 1950s and 1960s were very common for Major League Baseball's greatest players and they still are today. Sold at numerous five and dime and sporting goods stores, the player model bats were very popular with children of the era hoping to replicate Mantle's on-field talents in their own pick-up or Little League games. While several store models exist, and are authentic for the period, a couple stand out as true collectibles. This includes bate made by Lousiville Slugger or Hillerich Bradsby.

Mickey Mantle Rookie Cards and Memorabilia Buying Guide 45

Mickey Mantle Figures

Manufacturers: Salvino, McFarlane, Hartland, Danbury Mint, Starting Line-ups, Hamilton, Sports Illustrated, Sports Impressions

Whether they are statues, bobbleheads, busts or toys, Mickey Mantle has been immortalized in three dimensions by many companies over the years. Some of the figures originally produced during his playing days, particularly the Hartland figures can be quite valuable. When it comes to figures, aesthetic value and likeness are the two most important characteristics to look for when figure shopping. The listed manufacturers are some of the higher-profile companies that have produced Mickey Mantle figures through the years.

Mickey Mantle Rookie Cards and Memorabilia Buying Guide 46  Mickey Mantle Rookie Cards and Memorabilia Buying Guide 47  Mickey Mantle Rookie Cards and Memorabilia Buying Guide 48

Mickey Mantle Rookie Cards and Memorabilia Buying Guide 3
« Previous1234

More Info

To learn more about Mickey Mantle's playing career, statistics and post-retirement life, be sure to visit these sites:


 | 
Rob is a former member of The Cardboard Connection Writing Staff and co-host of Cardboard Connection Radio.He is an avid collector with over 20 years of active experience in the hobby.

User Comments

  1. I have a 1962 Mickey Mantle Post Cereal Baseball Star Card #5. This card is off the back of a Post Cereal Box are there any of these out there and how much would a card like this be worth

    Leave a Comment: