Pete Alonso Rookie Cards Guide and Top Prospects List

Pete Alonso Rookie Cards Guide and Top Prospects List

Pete Alonso rookie cards quickly caught on with collectors based on an impressive start to his MLB career. The rising slugger for the New York Mets has the Big Apple and the hobby in general taking notice.

After a few years of college ball with the Florida Gators, Pete (or Peter, or Pete the Polar Bear) was taken 64th overall by the Mets in the 2016 MLB Draft. His first baseball cards came that same year.

See also: Hottest Pete Alonso Card Auctions.

It took a few more years to work his way through the minors, but Alonso made his Major League Baseball debut on MLB Opening Day in 2019. That means the official Pete Alonso rookie cards are in 2019 baseball card boxes. Although he missed out on the first few sets of the year, his RC options should be plentiful during the summer and fall portion of the MLB card schedule.

Pete Alonso Rookie Card Checklist and Gallery

Click on the card listings below to shop for specific cards or track prices on eBay. Bolded sets go directly to detailed product profiles.

2019 Bowman Lucky Autograph Redemption Pete Alonso RC

Pete may have missed out on 2019 Bowman, but collectors were treated to a late surprise when Topps announced Alonso as the mystery signer for the Lucky Autograph Redemption.

Pete Alonso Rookie Cards Guide and Top Prospects List 1

2019 Bowman Platinum Pete Alonso RC #20 SP

Although officially a short print, the Alonso rookie in 2019 Bowman Platinum is very common, which keeps values low. Since it takes the place of Kolby Allard in the base set numbering, it is also considered a variation. If you are looking for the best Alonso option in the product, that would be the on-card Platinum Cut Autograph die-cut that is numbered to 50 copies.

Pete Alonso Rookie Cards Guide and Top Prospects List 2

2019 Bowman Sterling Pete Alonso RC #BSR-61

The expensive 2019 Bowman Sterling reboot offers a base rookie card for Alonso with quite a few Refractor parallels. Although his single-player autographs are issued as redemptions, he is featured on a multi-player Mets rookie autograph that is live in the release.

Pete Alonso Rookie Cards Guide and Top Prospects List 3

2019 Donruss Optic Pete Alonso RC #82

The Rated Rookie subset is home to the Pete Alonso rookie for 2019 Donruss Optic Baseball. Parallels give a little more life to the generic design, and drive higher prices.

Pete Alonso Rookie Cards Guide and Top Prospects List 4

2019 Panini Chronicles Pete Alonso RC (multiple)

2019 Chronicles Baseball has a ton of brands in the release and that means a ton of Pete Alonso rookies. This includes 18 different base rookies and three autographs.

Pete Alonso Rookie Cards Guide and Top Prospects List 5

Base

  • Base Chronicles
  • Ascension
  • Certified
  • Classics
  • Contenders Optic
  • Crusade
  • Donruss
  • Limited
  • Obsidian
  • Phoenix
  • Playoff
  • Rookies & Stars
  • Score
  • Spectra
  • Status
  • Timeless Treasures
  • Titan
  • Unparalleled
Autographs

  • America’s Pastime Boys of Summer
  • Contenders
  • Obsidian

Pete Alonso Rookie Cards Guide and Top Prospects List 6

2019 Panini Immaculate Collection Pete Alonso Autographs

While Alonso has rookie several autographs in 2019 Immaculate, he is surprisingly absent from the main RPA set. Another negative is that all the cards feature sticker autographs.

Pete Alonso Rookie Cards Guide and Top Prospects List 7

2019 Panini Leather & Lumber Pete Alonso RC #151 Autograph #/149

2019 Leather & Lumber Baseball is home to the first pack-pulled Pete Alonso rookie card autograph. Signed on a baseball-like surface, this trapped signature card is limited to 149 copies. More striking is the Rookie Signatures Black Gold version, numbered to 25, that features a black baseball and gold ink.

Many of the rookie players have three different options in the base rookie autograph set, but Pete has just this card.

Pete Alonso Rookie Cards Guide and Top Prospects List 8

2019 Topps Series 2 Pete Alonso RC #475

Pete's flagship rookie finally arrived in 2019 Topps Series 2 Baseball. An ongoing issue for Alonso is the Pete vs. Peter inconsistency on his cards. His hard-signed 1984 insert autograph in S2 opts for Peter.

Pete Alonso Rookie Cards Guide and Top Prospects List 9Pete Alonso Rookie Cards Guide and Top Prospects List 10

Alonso has exclusive variations in the Topps Baseball Compete Set lineup. This includes a normal image variation and a Chrome version.

Pete Alonso Rookie Cards Guide and Top Prospects List 11Pete Alonso Rookie Cards Guide and Top Prospects List 12

2019 Topps Allen & Ginter Pete Alonso RC #182

If you want a cheap option with mass appeal, A&G can be of service. 2019 Allen & Ginter offers a base Alonso rookie card with mini parallels. Those looking for something nicer can check out the on-card mini autograph that comes framed.

Pete Alonso Rookie Cards Guide and Top Prospects List 13

The online-exclusive 2019 Allen & Ginter X is virtually the same except the card stock is black and the autograph is signed in silver ink and numbered to just 25 copies.

Pete Alonso Rookie Cards Guide and Top Prospects List 14

2019 Topps Archives Pete Alonso RC #222

Alonso's rookie card in 2019 Archives features the 1993 flagship style. He is also in the high-number subset with the 1993 rookie design. Oddly, there are no autographs to be found for Pete in Archives.

Pete Alonso Rookie Cards Guide and Top Prospects List 15

2019 Topps Big League Pete Alonso RC #20 SP

The initial pack-pulled Pete Alonso rookie card arrived in 2019 Big League. The card is placed in the checklist as a variation to the main #20 card for Matt Carpenter.

While the low-cost brand is normally priced as such, the Alonso RC is a short print, so values are a bit higher but still not too bad.

Pete Alonso Rookie Cards Guide and Top Prospects List 16

2019 Topps Chrome Pete Alonso RC #204

A favorite of rainbow collectors thanks to the Refractor parallels, 2019 Topps Chrome also boasts on-card autographs for Alonso in addition to the base card. And the Pete/Peter battle is back.

Pete Alonso Rookie Cards Guide and Top Prospects List 17Pete Alonso Rookie Cards Guide and Top Prospects List 18

2019 Topps Definitive Collection Pete Alonso RC #DRA-PA Autograph (Redemption)

The high-end 2019 Definitive Collection offers one Pete Alonso autograph and it comes as a redemption. The end result should boast a premium design, on-card signature and print run of 50 or less once it's live.

2019 Topps Diamond Icons Pete Alonso RC #AC-PA Autograph #/25

Even tougher than Definitive, the super-premium 2019 Diamond Icons features Alonso in the main autograph set. Limited to just 25 copies, the hard-signed card can be difficult to locate.

Pete Alonso Rookie Cards Guide and Top Prospects List 19

2019 Topps Finest Pete Alonso RC #44

Alonso is not a short print in 2019 Finest Baseball, making this his first standard base rookie card. As is always the case for Finest, the Refractor parallels are popular. In addition, there is a hard-signed rookie autograph with a similar pose but a gray Mets uniform.

Pete Alonso Rookie Cards Guide and Top Prospects List 20Pete Alonso Rookie Cards Guide and Top Prospects List 21

2019 Topps Fire Pete Alonso RC #128

Collectors who appreciate loud designs can track down the Target-only 2019 Topps Fire MLB. Alonso has multiple foil parallels and a sticker autograph all showcasing the distinct Tyson Beck style.

Pete Alonso Rookie Cards Guide and Top Prospects List 22

2019 Topps Five Star Pete Alonso RC #FSA-PA Autograph

With just two cards per box, both being autographs, 2019 Topps Five Star is not the easiest place to find a Pete Alonso rookie card. As a result, his hard-signed base autographs cards are quite popular. Alonso also has on-card autographs in Golden Graphs and Five Tool Phenom.

Pete Alonso Rookie Cards Guide and Top Prospects List 23

Pete Alonso Rookie Cards Guide and Top Prospects List 24

2019 Topps Heritage High Number Pete Alonso RC #519

As far as Topps sets, not much can match the sheer number of Pete Alonso rookie cards found in 2019 Heritage High Number. Naturally, there is a standard base card, which is very inexpensive. He also has multiple Heritage variations, including a "Polar Bear" nickname card, plus a Chrome version. And there's a hard-signed Real One Autograph.

Pete Alonso Rookie Cards Guide and Top Prospects List 25Pete Alonso Rookie Cards Guide and Top Prospects List 26

2019 Topps Museum Collection Pete Alonso RC #79

2019 Museum Collection MLB offers a Pete Alonso rookie card in the base set and on-card autograph options. This includes Archival Autographs and the rare metal-framed autograph edition.

Pete Alonso Rookie Cards Guide and Top Prospects List 27

2019 Topps National Baseball Card Day Pete Alonso RC #18

Giving collectors a free shot at Pete, the 2019 NBCD promo features a base rookie and an autograph version limited to 300 copies.

Pete Alonso Rookie Cards Guide and Top Prospects List 28

2019 Topps Stadium Club Pete Alonso RC #272

While they aren't the most impressive images from 2019 Stadium Club Baseball, Alonso does have two different options. The base card features him tossing a ball while the short-printed image variation appears to show him admiring one of his many home runs. There is also a Chrome version of his base card and a hard-signed autograph.

Pete Alonso Rookie Cards Guide and Top Prospects List 29

Pete Alonso Rookie Cards Guide and Top Prospects List 30

2019 Topps Tier One Break Out Autograph Pete Alonso RC #BA-PA (Redemption)

Another signed option for Alonso is found in 2019 Tier One Baseball. In fact, this is his first pack-pulled rookie autograph, although it is issued in boxes as a redemption card. Once the redemptions are live, it should be hard-signed and numbered to 299 or less.

2019 Topps Tribute Pete Alonso RC #19R-15 #/435

At just two per case, the rookies in 2019 Tribute are not easy pulls. For some reason, Topps continues to number them as inserts rather than part of the base set. Alonso also has on-card autographs in the main TA set and League Inauguration.

Pete Alonso Rookie Cards Guide and Top Prospects List 31Pete Alonso Rookie Cards Guide and Top Prospects List 32

2019 Topps Now Pete Alonso RC #12 (PR=2,040)

Available right after his debut, Pete's earliest card with the RC logo came in 2019 Topps Now MLB. The on-demand card sold just over 2,000 copies in 24 hours. The card notes both his initial appearance and first hit with the Mets.

Issued a few days later in honor of his first MLB home run, Alonso's #32 card adds low-numbered autograph versions.

Pete Alonso Rookie Cards Guide and Top Prospects List 33

Alonso was also part of the 2019 Topps Now Home Run Derby set. This is notable since he won the event. Topps randomly awarded 50 bonus autographs to collectors who bought his HR Derby card.

Pete Alonso Rookie Cards Guide and Top Prospects List 34

2019 Topps Living Set Pete Alonso #176 RC (PR=8,695)

Another popular print-to-order option is found in 2019 Topps Living Set. The ongoing artistic set from Mayumi Seto brings the 1953 Topps design to modern stars like Alonso.

Pete Alonso Rookie Cards Guide and Top Prospects List 35

Top Pete Alonso Prospect Cards

2016 Bowman Draft Chrome Pete Alonso #BDC-92

After being selected in 2016, Pete Alonso's cardboard career got off to a fast start in 2016 Bowman Draft. Collectors can find his first paper prospect and Chrome prospect card. The chromium card naturally sees more attention, as do the many Refractor parallels.

Pete Alonso Rookie Cards Guide and Top Prospects List 36

2016 Bowman Draft Chrome Pete Alonso Draft Picks Autographs #CDA-PA

However, the clear favorite among Pete Alonso cards is his Chrome Draft Pick Autograph, also found in 2016 Bowman Draft. The hard-signed card is the preferred choice and has seen a meteoric rise in value and demand. An ungraded Orange Refractor parallel, numbered to 25, sold at auction for $4,550 in April 2019.

Pete Alonso Rookie Cards Guide and Top Prospects List 37

2016 Elite Extra Edition Pete Alonso #64 Autograph

Although no match for Bowman, 2016 Elite Extra Edition Baseball has a few of the top Pete Alonso cards, as well. His main autograph adds a signature to the base design along with numbered Status and Aspirations parallels like the red die-cut below.

Pete Alonso Rookie Cards Guide and Top Prospects List 38

Less common is the College Ticket card from 2016 Panini Contenders that is issued as an insert in EEE.

Pete Alonso Rookie Cards Guide and Top Prospects List 39

2017 Topps Heritage Minor League Real One Autograph Pete Alonso #ROA-PA

MiLB cards are rarely hot sellers, but 2017 Heritage Minor League offers an appealing on-card signature for Alonso. Documenting his time with the St. Lucie Mets, the rare parallels command considerable value, especially the Blue (#/75) and Gray (#/25) frame versions.

Pete Alonso Rookie Cards Guide and Top Prospects List 40

2018 Bowman Pete Alonso Paper Prospect Autographs #PA-PA

Still want a Bowman Pete Alonso prospect autograph but coming in a little too late in the game on his 2016 Bowman Chrome card? Check out 2018 Bowman. Alonso is part of the retail-only Paper Prospect Autograph set with several levels of numbered parallels.

Pete Alonso Rookie Cards Guide and Top Prospects List 41

2018 Leaf Pete Alonso Autographs

Collectors also have the various Leaf Baseball options for additional Pete Alonso autographs. While the cards carry no official licensing, the upside includes on-card signatures, set and design variety, more affordable pricing, and overall rarity, especially when compared to the Bowman releases.

Autograph choices include 2018 Leaf Flash Baseball2018 Leaf Metal Draft Baseball2018 Valiant Baseball and 2018 Ultimate Draft Baseball. He was not mentioned by name but it seems likely that he will have signed cards in 2018 Leaf Trinity Baseball.

Pete Alonso Rookie Cards Guide and Top Prospects List 42

Pete Alonso Rookie Cards Guide and Top Prospects List 43
« Previous1234

Author

Trey Treutel

E-Mail Author | 
Trey Treutel is an Ole Miss grad and a lifelong sports fanatic. He is a huge fan of the NBA and NFL, as well as soccer, college basketball and college football. As a kid, he collected football and basketball cards. In more recent years, he started collecting basketball cards again on a whim and has since expanded to other sports and entertainment options. Find Trey on Twitter at @datreute or Google+.

User Comments

  1. Author

    I pulled the 2017 Topps Heritage Minor League No first name auto of Pete Alonso. I cant find a value for it and Im trying to submit to PSA. I saw it had a POP of 1. Can you assist?

  2. Author

    I see four sales on eBay in 2019 for raw versions. The most recent two sold for $350 (August) and $297 (July).

    Leave a Comment: