Top 10 Willie Stargell Baseball Cards

Top 10 Willie Stargell Baseball Cards

Willie Stargell was one of the most beloved players of the 1970s, by both teammates and fans alike. He became "Pops," the home-run-hitting spiritual leader of one of the most admired World Series-winning teams ever, the 1979 Pittsburgh Pirates. His team dedication also made his baseball cards incredibly popular and this top list brings together his best appearances from his playing days and beyond.

Shop for Professionally Graded Willie Stargell Cards on eBay.

Stargell spent 21 seasons with the Pirates and over that time he led them to six division titles and World Series championships in 1971 and 1979, both over the Baltimore Orioles. He smacked 475 career home runs and probably would have been credited with a hundred more if he hadn't played in the unfriendly-to-hitters Forbes Field for much of his early career.

His role in leading the "We Are Family" Pirates to the World Series titles in 1979 forever bookended his wonderful career and made him a lock for the Hall of Fame. That year he became the first player to win his league's MVP award, the Championship Series MVP, and the World Series MVP all in the same season.

Collectors interested in some great Willie Stargell cards beyond this list can take a look at the statistical leaders cards from 1971 Topps and 1974 Topps which feature him on combo cards with Hank Aaron and Reggie Jackson, respectively.

Additionally, Donruss produced several memorable Stargell cards, including a card in 1981 Donruss honoring "Stargell Stars" which were Pirate team patches worn on the cap and given out by Willie to players who made a great play. Stargell was featured as a Diamond King in the 1983 Donruss set and in the 1991 set, to coincide with his induction to the Hall of Fame, Stargell was the subject of the Diamond King puzzle.

Two recent sets have notable Stargell base cards as well. In 2014 Topps Archives you can find a Stargell card in the 1989 Topps design and in 2015 Topps Stadium Club his card shows him celebrating the 1979 World Series title.

Based on his long and storied career, Willie Stargell has many in-demand cards with incredible values. In creating this list, card value was balanced with the desire to build a comprehensive collection covering Stargell's remarkable career.

Top 10 Willie Stargell Cards

Click on the images or listings to shop for cards on eBay.

10. 1966 Topps Willie Stargell #99

Some of my personal favorite cards from the 1960s Topps sets are the duo cards that often combine two great players together. Stargell was featured on two of these duo cards with teammate Donn Clendenon who was the Pirates first baseman for most of the 1960s. This "Bucs Belters" can be found in the 1966 Topps set and you can find a similar card titled "Pitt Power" in 1967 Topps as well.

1966 Topps Willie Stargell #99

9. 1976 Topps Willie Stargell #270

Willie Stargell began his career as a left fielder but moved to first base permanently beginning in the 1975 season. His 1976 Topps card features him with his first baseman mitt and a very serious look on his face.

1976 Topps Willie Stargell #270

8. 1975 Topps Willie Stargell #100

While most of the base cards in the 1975 Topps set feature two contrasting colors in the design, Stargell's card (along with several other Pirates) has just two slightly different shades of green in the design that you might not even notice at first. On his card, Willie swings directly at the camera demonstrating how wide his reach was with the bat (more about that at card #4 on the list).

1975 Topps Willie Stargell #100

7. 1973 Topps Willie Stargell #370

Topps really stepped up their in-game photography in the 1973 set offering several horizontal action shots of many great players. Here Stargell waits for the throw at first to try to get Philadelphia Phillies second baseman Terry Harmon out. The crowd behind them is almost as interesting as the action as you wonder if the person to the left of Willie is really wearing yellow cowboy boots to a baseball game.

1973 Topps Willie Stargell #370

6. 1967 Topps Willie Stargell #140

Although he was called "Willie" by fans, teammates, and just about everyone else, Stargell's first name was Wilver and he often signed as such on baseballs and cards. You'll also find that signature on many of his Topps cards including his 1967 Topps appearance.

1967 Topps Willie Stargell #140

5. 1965 Topps Willie Stargell #377

The 1965 Topps Willie Stargell card highlights the odd jerseys the Pirates wore in the early 1960s. Instead of having a jersey in one single piece, the middle section was like a vest and players were able to wear longer-sleeved undershirts of white or black underneath. While most teams typically had the city name on the front of their away jerseys, Pittsburgh only used "Pirates" on both their away and home uniforms.

1965 Topps Willie Stargell #377

4. 1968 Topps Willie Stargell #86

Stargell's swing on his 1968 Topps card demonstrates his unique style of holding the baseball bat. He would place his lower hand on the bat completely on the knob with his upper-hand immediately above it. This allowed him to extend the bat's reach beyond what it would be with a typical swing technique.

1968 Topps Willie Stargell #86

3. 2000 Upper Deck Legends Willie Stargell Autograph

Willie Stargell passed away in 2001 and so his pool of certified autographs is limited but collectors do have some great examples to choose from. Featuring a distinct look, Stargell batted and threw left handed and his memorable autograph is highly slanted to the left. Upper Deck's Legends set from 2000 offers a nice on-card autograph.

2000 Upper Deck Legends Willie Stargell Autograph

2. 1964 Topps Willie Stargell #342

While his first Topps card (see #1 on the list) fetches prices at auction that are far above what many collectors can afford, his second-year card from 1964 Topps offers an early Stargell appearance at a much more budget-friendly price point. Willie is a fresh-faced outfielder here making his first All-Star team during the 1964 season.

Willie Stargell

1. 1963 Topps Brock Davis, Jim Gosger, John Herrnstein, Willie Stargell RC #553

After Pete Rose's famous rookie from the 1963 Topps set, Stargell's rookie card, which he shares with Brock Davis, Jim Gosger, and John Herrnstein, is the most sought-after rookie from that year. Even though none of the other three players had much success in the majors, highly-graded copies of this card can reach nearly $1,000 at auction.

1963 Topps Willie Stargell RC

Top eBay Listings

1968 Venezuelan Topps # 86 WILLIE STARGELL Pittsburgh Pirates VINTAGE 1960S HTF
$75.00

1965 TOPPS #377 WILLIE STARGELL PIRATES
$18.00

1975 Topps Mini #100 Willie Stargell PSA 9
$99.75

1963 Topps #553 Willie Stargell RC PSA 8 Pirates Centered Rookie
$1,695.00

1964 Topps WILLIE STARGELL #342 Pittsburgh Pirates NM
$29.75

1963 TOPPS #553 WILLIE STARGELL PITTSBURGH PIRATES ROOKIE CARD SGC 80 EX NM 6
$350.00

1968 Pittsburgh Pirates Team Issue Card - Willie Stargell - PSA 8
$49.99

1967 TOPPS TEST STICKER #22 WILLIE STARGELL PITTSBURGH PIRATES SGC 88 NM MT 8
$250.00

1976 HOSTESS HAND CUT #49 WILLIE STARGELL PIRATES HOF PSA 8 B2483357-612
$31.99

1969 MLB PHOTOSTAMPS HAND CUT WILLIE STARGELL HOF PSA 10 B2422030-559
$69.99

Willie Stargell “Pops” 2017 Panini Donruss PSA Gem Mint 10 Pittsburgh Pirates
$19.99

1972 Topps Baseball #448 WILLIE STARGELL IA HOF PSA 7 NM
$19.99

1971 Topps #230 Willie Stargell - PSA 8 Near Mint-Mint - Pirates HOF Outfielder
$99.99

1966 Venezuela Topps Willie Stargell #255-99 plus 9 cards including Mazeroski
$75.00

1971 TOPPS BASEBALL CARD #230 WILLIE STARGELL
$75.00

1981 Donruss Willie Stargell (HOF) (#12) (Population of 1) BGS9.5 BGS
$89.97
« Previous1234

Matt Flaten

E-Mail Author | 

Matt has been collecting trading cards since 1987 and began writing about them in 2008 on his blog Heartbreaking Cards of Staggering Genius. He also created the pack-a-day blog A Pack To Be Named Later and is a co-host of the Trading Card Preservation Society Podcast. You can find Matt on Twitter @Cardthulhu.


Leave a Comment: