Finding the Best Group Break Experience

Finding the Best Group Break Experience

Now that you’ve read the Group Breaking and Case Breaking Newcomer’s Guide, and found our list of Online Case Breakers, how do you know which group break to choose? This is more of a personal choice depending on your end-goal. Nonetheless, let’s look through the assortment of options to help find the best group break experience for you.

Which Group Break is for Me?

There are three common Team Break types: Pick Your Team (PYT), Random Team and Team Draft. Each of them gives an opportunity to collect a favorite team at various price points.

PYT Breaks

Best Group Break ExperienceIf your preference is team-specific, the PYT option is a safe route to take. This is a guaranteed way to get all your team’s cards from that break. Generally, this is the only break where teams are individually priced as opposed to the random breaks where each team is purchased at the same price.

That doesn’t seem fair! Why I am paying more for my New England Patriots than the Cleveland Browns fan? (Yes, they’re out there!) Basically, it boils down to the checklist. If the product contains a higher chance of the breaker pulling hits for Team X than for Team Y, then Team X is priced higher. Now, it should be noted that this is not how every case breaker prices their group breaks, this is just a basic way to explain it.

Random Team Breaks

For a completist, the team chosen has no bearing on your collection. In this case, Random Team or Division and Team or Division Draft breaks are right up your alley. Although each break type is slightly different, the end result is the same: you may or may not walk away with wanted cards. That said, these are also the breaks where each team is equally priced and they can be quite fun to participate in.

Generally, most hosts will conduct Random Team and Random Division group breaks the same way. Again, the product price is equally split among the spots available for purchase. When it’s time for the break, collectors head over to a forum-style room to see all the action and chat with fellow trading card enthusiasts. Here, you’ll see the breaker go to random.org (this is the preferred site of breakers) and input all of the team or division names for randomization. Each team is given a number, then the same procedure is used for those collectors who purchased a spot. Once numbers are determined, you will be the proud owner of corresponding team or division. Easy enough! But, the fun usually continues as some sites allow collectors to buy, trade and even sell within the chat forum.

Draft Breaks

2017 Topps Museum Collection BaseballDraft breaks work the same as Random group breaks with one slight difference: you get to pick the team or division! Of course, this is after each purchaser’s name(s) have been randomized. It’s as if you were a partial team owner! Another popular draft-style break is for heavy-hitters. If your personal collection is geared to big hits but you’d prefer not to pay thousands of dollars for a hobby box/case, I can almost guarantee you’ll enjoy the Hit Draft Break. This is the go-to method for premium products, as collectors pay the same price per slot. After the draft order is decided, every participant picks what they want.

Always Understand What Break You Are Buying Into

Now that you know the type of case break that best suits your wants and/or needs, it's time to read the fine print to help make your decision.

Read the Fine Print

As we mentioned in the Newcomer’s Guide, not all Case Breakers are alike. Yes, most break methods are similar, however, it’s in the small, and not-so-small details that can make or break (pun not intended) what you decide to spend your time and money on. If this is your first group break experience, I highly recommend making a list of what you want. I know it sounds silly, but truth be told, the experience is very exciting and you may forget to look for a few things before it’s too late.

For example, do you prefer to have all of the cards pulled from the break? If so, you will need to read the FAQ section as some breakers only ship hits, while others mail everything except base cards.

Make Sure Hits are Clearly Explained

This is a perfect lead into the next big question: does your definition of a hit and their definition of a hit mean the same thing? Naturally, cards such as autographs and relics are hits, but do you consider a parallel or any serial numbered card a hit? If so, you agree with most breakers. And what about shipping? I don’t know about you, but I’m quite particular on how my cards are handled. As a rule, autographs, relics, and sometimes those numbered parallels, are placed in top loaders, while the other cards are placed in a single team bag rather than individual sleeves.

Best Group Break ExperienceAnother thing to keep in mind, which is why I wanted to warn you about hits, is that there are plenty of case breakers who offer a return if you go hitless in a break. This isn’t always a given, but some sites will offer a certain dollar amount of credit, or if base cards are not normally shipped, then they’ll make an exception and send those to you.

Personality Counts

Lastly, and maybe most importantly, find a breaker whose personality is enjoyable. It might sound strange, but the last thing you want to happen is to purchase a spot, be excited about the break, and then tune in to find out you don't care for the host. Maybe it's the way the cards are handled, or perhaps the host opens and shows the cards too quickly (or the opposite!). No matter the reason, you don't want to find yourself miserable in what should be an enjoyable group break experience.

But how will you know before the break and before you buy your favorite team's spot? Easy. Every Case Breaking site uploads their live-streams, usually on YouTube, for those who couldn't watch the initial stream but still want to see their pulls before they arrive in the mail, giving you the perfect opportunity to review the breaker's style and personality.

What do you look for in a Case Breaker? Let us know in the comments below!

Top eBay Listings

BLAKE BORTLES 2014 TOPPS CHROME MINI GOLD REFR ROOKIE RC AUTO #D 2 10 BGS 9.5 10
$2,750.00

Xavier McDaniel Signed 1986-87 Fleer Card SGC 7.5 & Auto 10 Slabbed #AU136181
$64.99

Glen Doc Rivers Signed 1986-87 Fleer Card SGC 7 & Auto 8 Slabbed #AU128717
$64.99

Gerald Henderson Signed 1986 Fleer BGS 8 Auto 9 JSA Cert #X90752
$64.99

2013 Bowman Chrome #GP Gregory Polanco Auto RC (Pirates) PSA 10 Gem!
$119.99

BRAXTON GARRETT - 2017 BOWMAN CHROME BLUE WAVE REFRACTOR AUTO # 150 BGS 9.5 GEM
$69.95

Graded BGS 9 Mint!! 2015 Panini Spectra Tevin Coleman JSY AU 17 99!! Auto!!
$49.99

2014 Leaf Trinity Luis Severino PURE BLUE AUTO RC 17 25 BGS 9.5 10 AU YANKEES
$79.99

2017 Leaf Valiant COOPER KUPP TD MACHINES Rc Red Auto True 1 1 Bgs 9.5 10 RAMS
$300.00

2008-09 Upper Deck SP Kevin Love Rookie Threads Rookie Auto BGS 9.5 Gem Mint
$150.00

2008 Buster Posey Bowman Chrome Prospects Auto RC... BGS 9.5 w all 9.5
$479.99

2015-16 109 Autographed Ultimate Rookies Tier 2 Connor McDavid BGS 9.5 Auto Card
$6,530.99

2015-16 109 Autographed Ultimate Rookies Tier 2 Connor McDavid BGS 9.5 A
$6,530.99

2013 Adam Brett Walker Bowman Chrome On Card Auto Refractor BGS9.5 10 RC
$99.99

2007 U.D. Goudey Sport Royalty Ken Griffey Jr. Auto Issue #GG-KG – PSA 9! Reds!
$189.99

2015 Topps High Tek Roger Clemens #'d 10 15 Yankees BGS 9.5 Gem Mint 10 Auto
$125.00
« Previous1234

Related Topics:

Lisa Weatherall

E-Mail Author |  https://www.cardboardconnection.com
Lisa grew up in Arlington, Texas where she regularly attended Rangers games and fell in love with baseball. She began collecting her favorite players' cards when every pack came with a stick of gum. With almost every baseball release, Lisa continues to grow her collection. She is also an avid fan of WWE, MMA, comics and every genre of music.

Leave a Comment:

Sign Up For The Cardboard Connection Insider

Stay Up to Date on the Latest Sports Cards, Memorabilia, Fan Apparel and Entertainment Collectibles Product Information, Checklists, Articles and Coverage, as well as Newsletter Exclusive Content and Contests.

Rest assured we have the utmost respect for your privacy and will NEVER share your contact information with anyone under any circumstances.