MINT 2023
Market Movers 200×60
Drip Banner
Triple Diamond Sports Breaks 200×60
Top 1990s Baseball Rookie Cards to Collect

Top 1990s Baseball Rookie Cards to Collect

The 1990s had its ups and its downs. The decade began with the hobby hotter than ever. But then came the inevitable crash, which was further fueled by the baseball strike that killed the 1994 World Series and carried into 1995. But the latter part of the decade saw memorable moments when Cal Ripken Jr. broke Lou Gehrig's consecutive games streak and Mark McGwire and Sammy Sosa chased 60 home runs.  For collectors, the 1990s brought tons of great rookie cards that remain must-haves today.

Compared to a lot of modern high-end cards, almost all 1990s rookie cards can be seen as a bargain (at least raw copies). But just because they may not bring future riches doesn't mean that these cards should be ignored or shunned like Jose Canseco at an official MLB function. Below are the top MLB rookie cards from the 1990s that every fan of the era should consider.

View the most popular 1990s rookie card auctions on eBay.

Only one rookie card is included for each player, although most have several. However, the featured card below is generally perceived as being the player's best rookie.

Did we miss one? Let us know in the comments.

Top 1990s Baseball Rookie Cards to Collect

Click on the card listing to shop on eBay or check current values. Bolded links go to detailed profiles. 

1990 Leaf Frank Thomas RC #300

One of the decade's most beloved players, the Frank Thomas rookie card in 1990 Leaf Baseball benefits from a clean design and premium card stock. Long one of the era's most popular cards, it now stands far above the 1990 Leaf Sammy Sosa rookie.

Top 1990s Baseball Rookie Cards to Collect 1

1991 O-Pee-Chee Chipper Jones #333

Other than a small line of text and white card stock, the 1991 O-Pee-Chee Chipper Jones looks rookie card almost exactly like its Topps MLB counterpart. Intended for the Canadian market, it's much rarer than his other rookie cards and has started to spike, particularly graded copies.

Top 1990s Baseball Rookie Cards to Collect 2

1991 Upper Deck Final Edition Jim Thome RC #17F

Like the Chipper Jones card, a ridiculous print run will forever keep the Jim Thome rookie 1991 Upper Deck Final Edition from ever gaining any significant value. There does seem to be something wrong with getting a member of the 600 Home Run Club's rookie for less than a cup of Starbucks coffee. This card won't give you bad breath either.

Top 1990s Baseball Rookie Cards to Collect 3

1992 Bowman Mariano Rivera RC #302

Mariano Rivera has but one rookie card. And until recently, it was largely ignored. Now that many recognize the Yankees great as the best closer to ever play the game, the Mariano Rivera rookie in 1992 Bowman Baseball has become hot in the hobby. It's also a great reminder of early-'90s fashion.

Top 1990s Baseball Rookie Cards to Collect 4

1992 Fleer Update Mike Piazza RC #U-92

It was a toss-up as to whether to include the 1992 Fleer Update rookie for Mike Piazza or the catcher's 1992 Bowman rookie card. The Bowman card looks better and is more iconic but the Fleer is less common. Ultimately, Piazza's 1992 Fleer Update rookie has long been the one that collectors chase. That said, both are reasonably priced cards for one of baseball's best-ever catchers.

Top 1990s Baseball Rookie Cards to Collect 5

1993 SP Derek Jeter RC #279

Does this card need justification? Next to the 1989 Upper Deck Ken Griffey Jr, the Derek Jeter rookie card in 1993 SP Baseball may be the hobby's most important and recognized baseball rookie of the past 40 years. The foil card stock makes it extremely condition-sensitive and high-grade versions go for big money.

Top 1990s Baseball Rookie Cards to Collect 6

1994 SP Alex Rodriguez RC #15

Admitted steroid usage, huge contracts and tabloid drama put Rodriguez out of favor with a lot of collectors. But the 1994 SP Baseball rookie card for Alex Rodriguez is still a standout from the decade thanks to his productive career. Like the 1993 SP Derek Jeter, foil edges wreak havoc with this card.

Top 1990s Baseball Rookie Cards to Collect 7

1995 Bowman's Best Vladimir Guerrero RC #2

Vladimir Guerrero's career did not end the same excitement as when it began. His 1995 Bowman's Best rookie card may be worth only a fraction of what it once was but it's still one of the decade's best.

Top 1990s Baseball Rookie Cards to Collect 8

1997 Bowman Chrome Roy Halladay RC #212

The Roy Halladay rookie card in 1997 Bowman Chrome Baseball took a while to emerge. That comes easy when you're playing in Toronto. Now in the Hall of Fame, Doc has taken up the mantel as the go-to card for the landmark 1997 Bowman Chrome set.

Top 1990s Baseball Rookie Cards to Collect 9

Top eBay Listings
Ryan is a former member of The Cardboard Connection Writing Staff.   His collecting origins began with winter bike rides to the corner store, tossing a couple of quarters onto the counter and peddling home with a couple packs of O-Pee-Chee hockey in his pocket. Today, he continues to build sets, go after inserts with cool technologies, chase Montreal Expos and finish off his John Jaha master collection.

User Comments


I like Derek Jeter’s other Upper Deck card — the Jeter #449 gold hologram variant — as his best card.

Looks much nicer in general because it features a lot of gold in addition to the gold hologram. But it’s also nicer because it has an actual picture instead of it being nothing but foil.

I find that covering the whole card in foil idea to be a bit gimmicky.

Leave a Comment:

will not be published