Ultimate New York Mets Collector and Super Fan Gift Guide

Ultimate New York Mets Collector and Super Fan Gift Guide

Despite the perception that they are the less successful, "younger brother" to the New York Yankees, the New York Mets enjoy a strong fan base even with their limited recent success. The guide below offers gift suggestions specifically for fans and collectors of the Mets.

Fans and collectors looking for more detailed information about the team should check out or New York Mets Collecting Guide.

The following list includes 20 different gift ideas that are directly focused on the Mets. Various price points and items are featured so that most can find several items in their price range.

Top Gifts for Fans of the New York Mets

Click on the listings to shop for gifts online.

Mike Piazza New York Mets Signed Photo

While he played for multiple teams in his career, including several years at the beginning with the Dodgers, Mike Piazza is mostly remembered for his time with the New York Mets. The consistent All-Star is highly regarded by fans of the team and a signed photo is sure to be a top gift option.

Mike Piazza New York Mets Signed Photo

Tom Seaver New York Mets Signed Baseball

Arguably the top player of all-time for the Mets, Tom Seaver was a dominant pitcher who spent the first half of his Hall of Fame career with New York. "Tom Terrific" is very popular with collectors and a signed baseball offers a great gift option.

Tom Seaver New York Mets Signed Baseball

David Wright New York Mets Signed Photo 

The one consistent part of the current Mets for the past decade, David Wright is the most popular player and the team captain. Already the holder of most team records, Wright will surely go down as an all-time great for the Mets. Signed photos offer an ideal gift option for current fans.

David Wright New York Mets Signed Photo

Keith Hernandez New York Mets Signed Bat

"I'm Keith Hernandez!" Even without his acting stint on Seinfeld, Keith Hernandez was a popular player for the Mets and remembered fondly. Hernandez was part of the team's 1986 title, which remains the last championship for the Mets. A signed bat offers an appealing display piece that is not too rough on the wallet.

Keith Hernandez New York Mets Signed Bat

Dwight Gooden New York Mets Signed Photo 

Known by many as "Doc," Dwight Gooden was a terrific pitcher for the Mets and part of their 1986 World Series team. Gooden remains a fan favorite and his signed photo presents a great budget option.

Dwight Gooden New York Mets Signed Photo

Darryl Strawberry New York Mets Signed Baseball 

Another key piece of the 1986 championship team, Darryl Strawberry is remembered for his towering home runs and clutch hitting. A signed baseball, especially one that notes the 1986 title, is a fantastic gift option.

Darryl Strawberry New York Mets Signed Baseball

Dwight Gooden, Darryl Strawberry & Mike Tyson New York Mets Signed Photo

An expected trio of Gooden, Strawberry and Mike Tyson makes an unlikely, but very cool, signed Mets piece. A video from that details the events leading up to that picture can be seen here.

Dwight Gooden, Darryl Strawberry & Mike Tyson New York Mets Signed Photo

David Wright New York Mets Framed Wall Art 

Signed gear for David Wright might be too steep for some and this framed poster offers a nice alternative that is more affordable but still has a quality look.

David Wright New York Mets Framed Wall Art

Gary Carter New York Mets Framed Collage

While he might be more thought of as a member of the Expos, Gary Carter enjoyed a successful period with the Mets. The deceased Hall of Fame catcher remains a fan favorite and this framed collage is a great way to remember the former star. Also, view other plaques and collages for the Mets here.

Gary Carter New York Mets Framed Collage

New York Mets Framed Home Grown Aces

Honoring two pitchers that were drafted by the Mets, this framed photo features former great Dwight Gooden and current star Matt Harvey with an appealing design.

New York Mets Framed Home Grown Aces

New York Mets Framed Subway Sign

Another framed option, the Mets subway sign consists of headlines from team's history. Several sizes allow for multiple price points and the largest versions include capsules of game-used dirt.

New York Mets Framed Subway Sign

New York Mets Dynasty Banner

Great for a man cave or bedroom, the "Amazin' Mets" are on full display with this wool banner. A nice gift for any fan of the team, both of the World Series wins are noted.

New York Mets Dynasty Banner

New York Mets Baseball

Simplicity at its finest, a baseball can be the easiest gift for a young fan to connect with the sport and that is taken a step further with the Mets logo. The team ball is a great budget gift or stocking suffer.

New York Mets Baseball

New York Mets Team Card Sets

Baseball cards are a popular option for fans, but they are not as simple to buy because they are so specific. One option we recommend for budget gifts or stocking stuffers is New York Mets team sets. Some are sealed and some are hand-collated, but the result is the same. Make sure to verify the year of the card and the players included to make sure you are getting what you expect.

New York Mets Team Card Set

New York Mets Fatheads

(Shop Amazon | Shop Fathead.com)

There are a good variety of different Mets team Fatheads. In addition to team logo versions, players are some of the top Fatheads and two of the most popular New York Mets are noted below.

New York Mets Fathead David Wright

New York Mets Phone Case

Smartphones are the new norm and can make for an easy and inexpensive gift for a New York Mets fan. Just make sure to verify the exact make and model before you buy. We have included direct links to Amazon below for the most popular phone models.

New York Mets Phone Case

New York Mets Jerseys

(Shop Amazon | Shop MLB.com)

Jerseys remain the most common way for fans to display their love of the Mets. Replica versions offer cheaper prices and fans can also have them customized for added appeal. If you are overwhelmed by the many versions, check our detailed MLB jersey guide here.

NY Mets Authentic Jersey

New York Mets Outerwear

(Shop Amazon | Shop MLB.com)

New York Mets Jacket

New York Mets Hats

(Shop Amazon | Shop MLB.com)

NY Mets Cap

New York Mets T-Shirts

(Shop Amazon | Shop MLB.com)

NY Mets T-Shirt

Top eBay Listings
« Previous1234

Trey Treutel

E-Mail Author | 
Trey Treutel is an Ole Miss grad and a lifelong sports fanatic. He is a huge fan of the NBA and NFL, as well as soccer, college basketball and college football. As a kid, he collected football and basketball cards. In more recent years, he started collecting basketball cards again on a whim and has since expanded to other sports and entertainment options. Find Trey on Twitter at @datreute or Google+.

User Comments

  1. I am looking for baseball cards of the 1973, 1999 and 2006 Mets.

    Leave a Comment: