Top 10 Upper Deck Hockey Young Guns Rookie Cards

Top 10 Upper Deck Hockey Young Guns Rookie Cards

Other than Topps Baseball, few base sets are collected as religiously as Upper Deck Hockey. Every year, hockey card collectors rip packs, trade, track and buy the singles they need to complete their sets. Not surprisingly, rookie cards play a key part in Upper Deck Hockey's lasting popularity.

Although short printed, Upper Deck's Young Guns rookie cards are still attainable for the average collector. As a result, set builders, rookie card collectors, player collectors and fans of specific teams all compete for the cards. In catering to all segments of the collecting community, the laws of supply and demand kick in and prices hold extremely well over time.

Despite coming from a mid-range product and not carrying any serial numbering, Upper Deck's Young Guns often sell for more than their numbered counterparts from other brands. It demonstrates the loyalty the cards have among collectors.

Of course, there's several autographed and memorabilia rookie cards that trump the Young Guns as far as value go, but such Cadillac sets as The Cup and Panini Dominion aren't an option for a lot of collectors. Young Guns rookies are and that's why they're so important to the hobby.

Here's a list of the top 10 Upper Deck Hockey Young Guns through 2012-13. With 2013-14 Upper Deck Hockey coming out soon, expect a couple more benchmark cards that could be featured on the list in the future, including Tomas HertlNail Yakupov and Alex Galchenyuk.

Top 10 Upper Deck Hockey Young Guns Rookie Cards

Click on the links to shop for cards on eBay. 

*Prices referenced below are for ungraded cards.

1. 2005-06 Upper Deck Hockey Sidney Crosby #201

Finally overcoming his battle with concussion symptoms, Sidney Crosby's 2005-06 Upper Deck rookie card remains one of the hobby's icons with raw copies still commanding more than $170.

2. 2002-03 Upper Deck Hockey Rick Nash #232

If you're able to find one of these ungraded for under $100, snatch it up. Much of the supply has been absorbed into personal collections now, making this card fairly tough to find online.

3. 2002-03 Upper Deck Hockey Henrik Zetterberg #234

Similar to Nash, Henrik Zetterberg's rookie card is also difficult to find now. As a result, ungraded cards of the Red Wings leader regularly command over $100.

4. 2006-07 Upper Deck Hockey Evgeni Malkin #486

Like his Penguins teammate, Crosby, Evgeni Malkin is one of the NHL's greatest scorers. Also like Crosby, injuries have been a regular part of his career. That hasn't stopped collectors from consistently paying more than $60 for his first Upper Deck hockey card.

5. 2005-06 Upper Deck Hockey Alexander Ovechkin #443

Should Alexander Ovechkin finally get the Washington Capitals a Stanley Cup, expect to see the Russian's rookie to soar higher than the $60 it currently brings in. The flashy sniper is one of the game's biggest and most polarizing superstars.

6. 2001-02 Upper Deck Hockey Pavel Datsyuk #442

Hardly a Young Gun anymore, Pavel Datsyuk continues to excel for the Detroit Red Wings, the team that drafted him in 1998. One of the top Russian-born players, Datsyuk's rookie sells in the $45-65 range.

7. 2008-09 Upper Deck Hockey Steven Stamkos #245

As Steven Stamkos continues to heat up the ice in Tampa, collectors will continue to pursue this card. Currently moving in the $40-60 range, Stamkos is one of hockey's elite stars.

8. 2007-08 Upper Deck Hockey Jonathan Toews #462

Part of Chicago's core that brought them a Stanley Cup in 2010 and 2013, Jonathan Toews is continuing to develop. Although a leader in a big market team, he'll likely have to increase his offensive production for this card to go higher than the $50 it's currently moving at.

(Tie) 9. 2011-12 Upper Deck Hockey Ryan Nugent-Hopkins #214

As the first overall pick by the Edmonton Oilers in the 2011 NHL Draft, Ryan Nugent-Hopkins is among the young stars of the NHL. The high ceiling for Nugent-Hopkins makes the current $40-45 range for his rookie seem quite reasonable.

(Tie) 9. 2010-11 Upper Deck Hockey Tyler Seguin #456

No matter what happens in Tyler Seguin's career, he will forever be remembered as a key part of Boston's 2011 Stanley Cup victory. Entering just his second year, expectations are high on Seguin that he'll keep the Bruins in contention for years to come. As a result, his 2010-11 Upper Deck rookie card is moving in the $40-45 range.

(Tie) 10. 2010-11 Upper Deck Hockey Taylor Hall #219

With the Oilers' youth movement starting to click, collectors can look for big things to come out of the City of Champions very shortly. Taylor Hall is at the forefront of Edmonton's young core, displaying flashy moves and a knack for scoring. His Young Guns rookie is currently selling for $35.

(Tie) 10. 2003-04 Upper Deck Hockey Marc-Andre Fleury #234

The only goaltender on the list, Marc-Andre Fleury remains a top hobby option after a strong 2012-13 season for the Pittsburgh Penguins. If the Penguins can snag another title, it will likely be due to huge play from Fleury. While his rookie card sells for approximately $35, expect a considerable bump if that happens.

Honorable Mention

2009-10 Upper Deck Hockey John Tavares #201

The first overall pick in the 2009 draft, John Tavares looks to be taking his game to another level this season. Although he plays for an Islanders franchise that is largely ignored, lots of Canadian collectors still have fond memories of him with the national team. Tavares' Young Guns rookie card currently sells for about $35.

2007-08 Upper Deck Hockey Carey Price #227

Just missing the list, Carey Price has a huge hobby following. Should Montreal make a major push toward bringing the Stanley Cup back to Canada, the $25-30 this card is currently selling for will be a bargain.

Top eBay Listings
« Previous1234

Ryan Cracknell

E-Mail Author | 
Ryan is a former member of The Cardboard Connection Writing Staff.   His collecting origins began with winter bike rides to the corner store, tossing a couple of quarters onto the counter and peddling home with a couple packs of O-Pee-Chee hockey in his pocket. Today, he continues to build sets, go after inserts with cool technologies, chase Montreal Expos and finish off his John Jaha master collection.

User Comments

  1. MA Fleury’s YG RC sells pretty well also. I would have included it in this list.

  2. Wes (ID 32177) If there was a top 15, he would have definitely been on there. Limiting the list to 10 was very tough.

    Leave a Comment: