Sammy Watkins Rookie Card Guide and Checklist

Sammy Watkins Rookie Card Guide and Checklist

Sammy Watkins is widely considered to be one of the most explosive players in the 2014 NFL Draft and Watkins has already shown glimpses of greatness in his rookie year. His early play has certainly caught the attention of collectors and Sammy Watkins rookie cards are starting to move.

Shop for Sammy Watkins cards on eBay.

A three-year starter at Clemson, Sammy Watkins began his college career impressively and finished even stronger. He was named a First-Team All-American in all three seasons and was the 2014 Orange Bowl MVP in his last collegiate game. Watkins chose to forgo his senior year and entered the 2014 NFL Draft.

Considered a virtual lock for a top ten selection, the Buffalo Bills traded up to make Sammy Watkins the fourth overall pick and the first wide receiver taken. Although he only has one season under his belt, Sammy Watkins has already produced several big games for the Bills and ended his rookie year just shy of 1,000 receiving yards.

The following guide looks at all the Sammy Watkins rookie cards currently available. Official rookie cards are shown as well as the main options for products without a true rookie card set.

Sammy Watkins Rookie Card Guide

Click on the listings or images to shop for cards on eBay. Rookie cards from Topps products are shown first and are followed by Panini rookie cards. 

Topps Rookie Cards

2014 Bowman Sammy Watkins RC #70

The image won't win any fans but the real appeal from Bowman is normally based on the early availability.  The long-term interest will not likely be strong for the 2014 Bowman rookie card.

2014 Bowman Sammy Watkins RC #70

2014 Bowman Chrome Sammy Watkins RC #155

Thankfully, the 2014 Bowman Chrome rookie card for Sammy Watkins used an updated photo for the exciting young receiver versus the airbrushed version above. This is one of several appealing budget rookie cards available for Watkins.

2014 Bowman Chrome Sammy Watkins RC #155

2014 Bowman Sterling Sammy Watkins RC #2

2014 Bowman Sterling has arguably the best quality in terms of base design and this Sammy Watkins rookie card brings a good amount of detail. Despite this, prices are inexpensive.

2014 Bowman Sterling Sammy Watkins RC #2

2014 Finest Sammy Watkins RC #141

More subtle than previous editions, Sammy Watkins' 2014 Finest rookie card has just enough color to keep it from being boring.  Refractors add more rarity and interest for these base cards.

2014 Finest Sammy Watkins RC #141

2014 Topps Sammy Watkins RC #434

The flagship product from Topps manages a budget price while not sacrificing much on the image or design. 2014 Topps continues the variation wave that is sweeping the hobby, and once again, the difference is very slight between the Sammy Watkins base rookie on the left and variation on the right.

2014 Topps FB 434 Sammy Watkins2014 Topps FB Variations 434 Sammy Watkins

2014 Topps Chrome Sammy Watkins RC #138

The chromium interpretation of flagship Topps football, Topps Chrome rookies for Sammy Watkins are a popular budget option for collectors. Just like the base version, Chrome also features a short print variation. A variety of Refractor parallels offer rarity and the rainbow chase.

2014 Topps Chrome 138 Sammy Watkins2014 Topps Chrome Football Variations 138 Sammy Watkins

2014 Topps Chrome Mini Sammy Watkins RC #138

The third time collectors will see the exact Sammy Watkins rookie card design from Topps, Chrome Mini is the smallest of the group. Like base Topps and Topps Chrome, there is also a short-printed image variation.

2014 Topps Chrome 138 Sammy Watkins2014 Topps Chrome Football Variations 138 Sammy Watkins

2014 Topps Fire Sammy Watkins RC #124

The wild design and vivid colors make this Topps Fire base rookie for Sammy Watkins one of the best overall options for set collectors. Various parallels feature different color combos.

2014 Topps Fire Sammy Watkins RC #124

2014 Topps Five Star Base Autograph Sammy Watkins #FSA-SW

Technically not a rookie card because 2014 Topps Five Star has no true base set, this is the Sammy Watkins card with the most likely claim to rookie status in the high-end set. The ornate design and on-card autographs make it one of the best of the year.

2014 Topps Five Star Base Autograph Sammy Watkins #FSA-SW

2014 Topps Inception Sammy Watkins RC Autograph #21

Easily one of the most distinct designs in the hobby, 2014 Topps Inception combines an art-like look, on card signature and limited print run. Although it was never confirmed by Topps, the Sammy Watkins card appears to be a short print, with the most common rookie numbered to only 50. The only slight against the card is the "00" jersey number.

2014 Topps Inception Sammy Watkins RC Autograph

2014 Topps Museum Collection Sammy Watkins RC #52

This simple Sammy Watkins base card is found in the high-end 2014 Museum Collection release. While pulling one from a box might not be the most exciting prospect, the rookie card is still a nice budget pickup.

2014 Topps Museum Collection Sammy Watkins RC #52

2014 Topps Platinum Sammy Watkins RC #119

A viable alternative to the Chrome or Finest options, 2014 Platinum adds another chromium budget rookie for collectors to add to their Sammy Watkins rookie collection.

2014 Topps Platinum Sammy Watkins RC #119

2014 Topps Prime Sammy Watkins #146

A full-bleed image and vivid green background make this 2014 Topps Prime rookie card for Sammy Watkins pop. The limited short print variation, shown on the right, is also available to collectors.

2014 Topps Prime 146 Sammy Watkins2014 Topps Prime FB Variation 146 Sammy Watkins

2014 Topps Strata Sammy Watkins RC #152

Featuring a simple look with a similar quality to Topps Prime, 2014 Topps Strata is more about the Clear Cut and Strata Signature Relics than the base rookies. The short print variation is also shown.

2014 Topps Strata Sammy Watkins RC #1522014 Topps Strata Variation 152 Sammy Watkins

2014 Topps Supreme Sammy Watkins RC #9 #/162

Even with the lower print run and quality design, the base 2014 Topps Supreme rookie card for Sammy Watkins remains a budget option. Because of this, the card is one of the best choices for collectors looking for an unsigned base rookie card.

2014 Topps Supreme Sammy Watkins RC #9

2014 Topps Triple Threads Sammy Watkins RC #155,159 Autographed Jersey #/99

Collectors of Triple Threads have come to expect certain things from the relic-heavy product and the 2014 edition is no different. The updated design is more aesthetically pleasing than previous years but the sticker autograph is still a huge negative. Limited to just 99, this is one of the rarest Sammy Watkins rookie card options. There is also another similar card for Watkins in the base rookie set.

2014 Topps Triple Threads Sammy Watkins RC #155 Autographed Jersey

2014 Topps Triple Threads Sammy Watkins RC #159 Autographed Jersey

2014 Topps Turkey Red Sammy Watkins #83

Exclusive to Target instead of online like previous years, the all-rookie release includes both inexpensive base cards and limited variations for Sammy Watkins.

2014 Topps Turkey Red Sammy Watkins #83

2014 Topps Valor Sammy Watkins RC #150

Another recycled image for Sammy Watkins is given a slight boost by the colorful and bold card design. The copper foil gives the card a touch of class and makes for one of the best base designs of the year.

2014 Topps Valor Sammy Watkins RC

Panini Rookie Cards

2014 Panini Absolute Sammy Watkins RC #145, #235 Autographed Jersey #/99

Showcasing a similar layout to many Panini base designs, 2014 Absolute has a zoomed image of Watkins along with a background that has been replaced with a large "X" design. There is also a second card for Watkins in the main set. Numbered to 99, it is decidedly more rare and includes a sticker autograph and quad jersey.

2014 Panini Absolute Sammy Watkins RC #1452014 Panini Absolute Sammy Watkins RC #235 Autographed Jersey

2014 Panini Black Gold Sammy Watkins RC #89 #/199

Featuring one of the nicest base designs of the year, the mashup product from Panini delivers on the black and gold in the brand name. The shadowbox design also includes a variety of parallels and is an appealing option for Sammy Watkins rookie card collectors.

2014 Panini Black Gold Sammy Watkins RC #89

2014 Panini Certified Freshmen Fabrics Mirror Signatures Sammy Watkins RC #235 #/199

Even with the sticker autograph, the medium jersey piece and limited print run makes this 2014 Certified rookie a solid option to collectors looking for an appealing budget Sammy Watkins autograph.

2014 Panini Certified Freshmen Fabrics Mirror Signatures Sammy Watkins RC

2014 Panini Contenders Sammy Watkins RC #237 Autograph

One of the top overall rookie cards for Sammy Watkins, Contenders Rookie Tickets includes a base version as well as two short print variations. The base print run was not revealed, but the middle version(Variation I) has 103 total copies and the third card (Variation II) is limited to just 25.

2014 Panini Contenders 237 Sammy Watkins2014 Panini Contenders RPS Variation 237 Sammy Watkins 2014 Panini Contenders Sammy Watkins RC #237 Autograph Variation II

2014 Panini Crown Royale Sammy Watkins RC #204 Autographed Jersey #/299

An on-card autograph and medium jersey patch makes this Crown Royale rookie card for Sammy Watkins a top pick for collectors. The larger print run keeps values from taking off and there is also an unsigned version that is more limited.

2014 Panini Crown Royale Sammy Watkins RC #204 Autographed Jersey

2014 Panini Elite Sammy Watkins RC #181 #/999

The 2014 Elite Sammy Watkins rookie card won't ever yield huge values, but it represents a strong low-end card. Serial numbered to 999, the supply will likely outnumber the demand, keeping prices low.

2014 Panini Elite Sammy Watkins RC #181

2014 Panini Flawless Sammy Watkins RC #103 Diamond #/20

Even without an autograph, the Sammy Watkins rookie in Flawless is easily one of his most valuable and rare cards among his first-year options.  The limited print run helps the value considerably, as does the embedded diamond.

2014 Panini Flawless Sammy Watkins RC #103 Diamond

2014 Panini Hot Rookies Sammy Watkins RC #418

Basically the premium version of Score, 2014 Hot Rookies is another early release that will be unlikely to maintain any sustained interest based on an undesirable image. Sporting a photoshopped college image of Watkins, collectors can find better options elsewhere.

2014 Panini Hot Rookies Sammy Watkins RC #418

2014 Panini Immaculate Collection Sammy Watkins RC #103 Autographed Jersey #/99

Immaculate Collection is still a newer brand, but is has already assumed a prominent place in the high-end collecting world. The appealing design, on-card signature and patch piece make this a collecting favorite among Sammy Watkins rookie cards.

2014 Panini Immaculate Collection Sammy Watkins RC #103 Autographed Jersey

2014 Panini Limited Sammy Watkins RC #194 Autographed Jersey #/99

While the print run of just 99 and the large patch is a great attribute for this Limited Sammy Watkins rookies, the overall appeal is hurt by the sticker autograph.

2014 Panini Limited Sammy Watkins RC #194 Autographed Jersey

2014 Panini National Treasures Sammy Watkins RC #285 Autographed Jersey #/99 

The top rookie card of the year for Sammy Watkins, National Treasures has long been the favorite for collectors. The large patch, low print run and on-card signature means that the NT rookie card for Watkins will top most lists in 2014.

2014 National Treasures RPA 285 Sammy Watkins

2014 Panini Playbook Rookies Booklet Signature SP Gold Sammy Watkins RC #174 Autographed Jersey #/99

Another card limited to just 99, Sammy Watkins was included with three other hobby favorites in the short-printed Gold subset. The booklet cards includes two different jersey pieces and an autograph.

2014 Panini Playbook Rookies Booklet Signature SP Gold Sammy Watkins RC #174 Autographed Jersey

2014 Panini Prestige Sammy Watkins RC #280

If the base Sammy Watkins rookie in 2014 Prestige looks familiar, it is because the exact same image is used on Score and Hot Rookies. If you prefer a little variety in your collection, a rare variation showing Watkins in his Buffalo Bills jersey is available.

2014 Panini Prestige Football 280 Sammy Watkins2014 Panini Prestige Football Variations 280 Sammy Watkins

2014 Panini Prizm Sammy Watkins RC #229

Taking variations to another level, 2014 Prizm offers collectors four different cards for Watkins, including subtly different images. The base rookie is shown first and is followed by the three variations for Sammy Watkins.

2014 Panini Prizm 229 Sammy Watkins2014 Panini Prizm Variation Sammy Watkins Reaching for Ball

2014 Panini Prizm Variation Sammy Watkins Ball in Right Hand2014 Panini Prizm Variation Sammy Watkins Crushing Ball

2014 Panini Rookies and Stars Sammy Watkins RC #180

Similar to Prestige, 2014 Rookies and Stars went the variation route with Sammy Watkins. However, both images show the dynamic receiver in his Bills gear, with only a subtle difference between the base card on the left and the variation on the right.

2014 Panini Rookies and Stars Football 180 Sammy Watkins2014 Panini Rookies and Stars Football Variations 180 Sammy Watkins

2014 Panini Select Sammy Watkins RC #230 Autographed Jersey #/99

The Prizm technology and low print run is not enough to save this 2014 Select rookie card for Sammy Watkins. The sticker autograph is a killer and dominates the look of the card.

2014 Panini Select Sammy Watkins RC #230 Autographed Jersey

2014 Panini Spectra Sammy Watkins RC #188 #/149,  #231 Autographed Jersey #/149

2014 Spectra includes two Sammy Watkins rookie cards in the main set, including a base rookie and an autographed jersey card. Despite having a similar overall look to Select, the signed rookie is much more desirable thanks to the on-card autograph.

2014 Panini Spectra Red Parallel Sammy Watkins RC #1882014 Panini Spectra Sammy Watkins RC #231 Autographed Jersey

2014 Panini Stickers Sammy Watkins RC #14

Basically a sticker version of the Score rookie card for Sammy Watkins, the 2014 Panini Stickers rookie is a bit tougher to find but still very inexpensive.

2014 Panini Stickers Sammy Watkins RC #14

2014 Panini Totally Certified Sammy Watkins RC #163

If foil and embossing is what you are looking for, a Sammy Watkins rookie card from Totally Certified presents an appealing budget option. Colorful parallels add increased rarity and value.

2014 Panini Totally Certified Sammy Watkins RC

2014 Score Sammy Watkins RC #418

A well-known budget option, Score is more about quantity versus quality. Similar to Hot Rookies, collectors can find better options for a Sammy Watkins rookie card than 2014 Score.

2014 Score Sammy Watkins RC #418

Notable College and Pre-Rookie Cards

2011 Leaf All-American Bowl Autographs Sammy Watkins #BA-SW1

Normally baseball products are the only place to find football stars before they make the move to the NFL. However, 2011 Leaf included Watkins in their set which honored high school participants in the U.S. Army All-American Bowl. Teddy Bridgewater and Odell Beckham also played in the game and their autographs can be found in the product.

2011 Leaf All-American Bowl Autographs Sammy Watkins

2013 Exquisite Collection Draft Picks Autographs Sammy Watkins #ER-SW

Although it is technically an insert in a 2013 product, this valuable on-card autograph for Sammy Watkins features all the aspects which made Exquisite a titan in the hobby. Now with a college theme, this 2013 Exquisite card is limited to only 75 copies.

2013 Exquisite Collection Draft Picks Autographs Sammy Watkins

2014 Exquisite Collection Rookie Signature Patch Sammy Watkins #135 #/75

Building on the taste collectors received in 2013 Exquisite, the Rookie Signature Patch for Sammy Watkins adds a large jersey piece to the familiar quality and low print run.

2014 Exquisite Collection Rookie Signature Patch Sammy Watkins #135

2014 Flair Showcase Sammy Watkins (Row 2 - #5, Row 1 - #114, Row 0 - #161)

Dripping with 1990s nostalgia, 2014 Flair Showcase offers collectors three different base cards for Sammy Watkins, each with a different layout and rarity.

2014 Flair Showcase Sammy Watkins Row 2 #5 2014 Flair Showcase Sammy Watkins Row 1 #114

2014 Flair Showcase Sammy Watkins Row 0 #161

2014 Leaf Trinity Autographs Sammy Watkins

Leaf has taken big leaps in recent years and nowhere is that more evident than in 2014 Leaf Trinity. The Jumbo Patch Autograph and Pure Autographs are some of the most popular early cards for Sammy Watkins. The card quality and design is impressive enough that collectors can overlook the airbrushed college images.

2014 Leaf Trinity Jumbo Patch Autograph Sammy Watkins2014 Leaf Trinity Pure Autograph Sammy Watkins

2014 Leaf Valiant Autograph Sammy Watkins #BA-SW1

Not quite on the same level as Leaf Trinity, 2014 Leaf Valiant has a Chrome feel to it and several colors of varying rarity. In addition to his base autograph, Sammy Watkins is also included in several autographed insert sets.

2014 Leaf Valiant Autograph Sammy Watkins

2014 SP Authentic Sammy Watkins #235 Autographed Jersey #/150

There is a reason that SP Authentic has been a long favorite for rookie collectors and that has not changed despite the switch to a college theme. The good layout and design, on-card autograph and limited print run make this one of the best Sammy Watkins options for those that don't mind the lack of NFL logos.

2014 SP Authentic Sammy Watkins #235 Autographed Jersey

2014 SPx Sammy Watkins #77 Autographed Jersey #/249

SPx might not be the same to collectors without the NFL images, but 2014 SPx still carries on the rookie tradition of previous years with a large jersey piece and horizontal layout. The sticker autograph is adequately incorporated into the red-heavy color scheme and although most of the other cards check in at 425 copies, the Sammy Watkins card is limited to 249.

2014 SPx Sammy Watkins #77 Autographed Jersey

2014 Upper Deck Sammy Watkins #153,258

If you are looking for a budget base card with a great action image, and you don't mind a college image, 2014 Upper Deck is a great place to start. In addition to a  short-printed base card, collectors can also find a rare Hobby variation card for Sammy Watkins.

2014 Upper Deck Sammy Watkins #153

2014 Upper Deck Sammy Watkins #258

Top eBay Listings

2014 Bowman Sterling Blue Wave Refractors #BSARSW Sammy Watkins RC #09 15 BGS
$70.00

2014 Panini Absolute SAMMY WATKINS RC #43 99 BUFFALO BILLS
$14.68

SAMMY WATKINS 2014 TOPPS PLATINUM X-FRACTOR RC BGS GEM MINT 9.5 #119 BILLS
$11.99

SAMMY WATKINS 2014 SP AUTHENTIC FUTURE WATCH ROOKIE BGS GEM MINT 9.5 999 BILLS
$11.99

SAMMY WATKINS 2014 TOPPS CHROME ROOKIE CARD RC BGS GEM MINT 9.5 #117 BILLS
$11.99

SAMMY WATKINS 2014 TOPPS PLATINUM ORANGE REFRACTOR RC BGS GEM MINT 9.5 119 BILLS
$11.99

SAMMY WATKINS 2014 TOPPS PLATINUM BLACK REFRACTOR RC BGS GEM MINT 9.5 #119 BILLS
$11.99

2014 TOPPS CHROME SAMMY WATKINS REFRACTOR RC ROOKIE #138 BILLS
$5.00

PEYTON ELI MANNING SAMMY WATKINS SEAL EMBLEM PATCH LOT 2014 PANINI BLACK GOLD
$47.50

2014 Bowman Sterling 4CLR Patch #BSRDRSW Sammy Watkins RC Bills B87 499
$25.00

2014 Certified New Generation Jersey #NGSW Sammy Watkins RC 522 599 B87 503
$12.00

2014 Crown Royale Dual Jersey #HTCWE Mike Evans Sammy Watkins 363 399 B87 514
$15.00

2014 Panini Contenders Rookie Ticket Jerseys #37B Sammy Watkins Bills B87 188
$10.00

2014 Topps Valor Relics Courage Jersey #VRRSW Sammy Watkins RC 15 50 B87 228
$20.00

2014 Panini R&S Football - Sammy Watkins RC Relic Card - Large Relic
$7.95

2014 Bowman Chrome Sammy Watkins-Topps Shelf RC #TSR-SW(Refractor)19 50
$5.99
« Previous1234

Trey Treutel

E-Mail Author | 

Trey Treutel is an Ole Miss grad and a lifelong sports fanatic. He is a huge fan of the NBA and NFL, as well as soccer, college basketball and college football. As a kid, he collected football and basketball cards. In more recent years, he started collecting basketball cards again on a whim and has since expanded to other sports and entertainment options. Find Trey on Twitter at @datreute or Google+.


Leave a Comment: