Guide to Collecting Official League Baseballs

Guide to Collecting Official League Baseballs

The quintessential element to the game of baseball is obviously the ball itself. From a collectibles standpoint, the baseball is more than just a canvas for acquiring autographs. Baseballs document the game from a historical perspective and the lineage of league presidents and commissioners serves as a timeline for the game itself.

Collecting official league baseballs has become a growing aspect of the hobby. Much like other pieces of memorabilia, the value of the balls is determined by age, rarity and most importantly, condition. Since 1877, only three companies have produced official major league baseballs; Spalding, Reach and Rawlings.

The legendary sporting goods company started by the Spalding brothers, Walter and Albert, obtained the rights to produce National League baseballs around 1876. American League baseballs were manufactured by the Reach Sporting Goods Company. In 1889, Spalding acquired Reach. When the two leagues merged to create Major League Baseball in 1901, Spalding continued to use the Reach brand name for American League baseballs.

Distinguishing the differences between the two baseballs used by each league is simple. American League baseballs, with the Reach name, have red and blue stitching, and the National League, Spalding name baseballs, have black and red stitching. Starting in 1934, both leagues switched to a baseball with only red stitching.

The physical dimensions of the baseball itself have changed very little in terms of size or weight since its professional debut. A major league baseball can weigh between 5 and 5-1⁄4 ounces, and is 9 to 9-1⁄4 inches in circumference. There are 108 double stitches on a baseball.

The materials used in the manufacturing process did change, however, in 1909, when the cork-centered ball was introduced. Previous to that, a cushioned, wood center had been used. The new "livelier" ball ended what has been referred to as the "dead-ball" era.

Wartime rationing and material shortages forced a temporary change in the ball's core. Baseballs used during the World War II-period were made with a rubber core similar to those used in golf balls. Baseballs were manufactured using a horsehide cover for almost 100 years. In 1974, the league began using cowhide covers, which are still used today.

In 1977, Rawlings won the contract to produce official league baseballs and continues to do so to this day. The following year, they would introduce the first World Series logo balls used in the annual Fall Classic.

In 2000, when Bud Selig became commissioner of Major League Baseball, he did away with separate balls for each of the two leagues. Rawlings debuted a newly-designed, official Major League baseball for the 2000 season that features the patented MLB batter logo.

Official league baseballs have always been adorned with the name of the league president. This is an important attribute from a collecting perspective. Autographed baseballs carry the most value when they are signed on an official league ball from the player's era. This practice also aids the authentication process.

Factual evidence, like knowing what period a player was active and when he died, provides a basis for determining the balls authenticity. Such was the case in the mid-2000s when a reputable auction company made the oversight of listing a bogus Ty Cobb autographed baseball. Cobb's alleged signature was on an official American League ball dated from a period after he had died. Knowing there was no way he could have signed the ball, the company removed it from the auction catalog.

Knowing the historical lineage of league presidents is a crucial characteristic when collecting official league baseballs. The following guide notes the league president and duration of usage for each baseball. It is important to note that replicas can be more common than originals, especially from the earlier years of baseball, so make sure you know what  you are buying.

Official League Baseball Checklist

Click on the listings to shop for baseballs on eBay. 

Baseball Evolution Visual Guide

A gallery, showing official league balls throughout the years, provides a look at how the aesthetics of the ball have changed.

Guide to Collecting Official League Baseballs 7
« Previous12

Rob Bertrand

E-Mail Author | 
Rob is a former member of The Cardboard Connection Writing Staff and co-host of Cardboard Connection Radio.He is an avid collector with over 20 years of active experience in the hobby.

User Comments

  1. i have a baseball that says winnwell official league baseball no 88 sold by eatonsfor $1.89 435id wellinger & dunn ltd. toronto, canada . can you date that? Paul

  2. I have a box of 1974 Winnwell baseballs. Is there any value to these balls?

  3. I purchased 2 baseballs at a house sale and I can’t find a value?

    1) OFFICIAL LEAGUE BALL, Core Center, Genuine Horsehide fiber core, Karn wound No. 975
    It also states ” Trade Offical Mark with stars around it.

    2) Rawlings Playmaker “The Finest in the filed” MMI HATI

    Are there any value to these baseballs?

  4. I have a 1959 or 1960 reach autographed American League Baseball very very good condition in box. with authentic autographs from all the players and it was a game ball they were Cleveland Indians what can you tell me about its value

  5. i have a mickey mantle /willy mays signed baseball G078656 what does the G078656 stand for thank you and the worth please

  6. Have a 79 50th allstar ball that has been incased sense the day. Interested. Let me know CA

  7. I’ve got a rawlings leonard coleman NL game ball signed by Greg Maddux, still sealed. any idea how I can find it’s value?

  8. I have an autographed baseball from the 1959 All Star game held in Pittsburgh which contains all participants for the National League. What is it worth and would anyone be interested in purchasing?

  9. I have a baseball that reads ” Major League Ball”. At the top of the ball, it reads” JoleBEER and SON established 1889″ At the bottom of the ball, it reads ” NO.79 9 IN. FULL Yarn Wound CORK AND RUBBER CENTER.

  10. I have a team autographed 1964-65 St. Louis Cardinals baseball and It does not appear to have an official baseball logo. Does this devalue the ball? It was my fathers and got it while attending a game in St. Louis. Iam interested in selling it along with two others balls a 1953 N.Y Giants and 1967 Baltimore both have official baseball logos.

  11. I have a old red and black or blue stitched ball that’s stamped “Big League Ball” Cork & rubber center below, C736 stamp. Can’t find any info on it. Any guesses? Thanks

  12. I have some old baseballs from the 1972. in the original boxes . WORTH Baseballs manufactured by Lannom in Tullahoma Tenn.

    HARDWOOD LLL Baseballs manufactured by Hardwood & sons Natick, Mass.

    Do they have a value?

  13. I have a game-used MacGregor Official League 92722 ball, and don’t remember where I got it. Either a Cubs spring training game, or a triple-A Knights game. Which is more likely?

  14. I have a Winnwell Live Centre Cemented? No.
    66? white, red stitching official league baseball. Used but in good condition. Any info?


  15. Have 2 old rawhide Rawlings baseballs with Willie Starggl, Jim Lefebore?, ect…probably from 1960s-70s…what would be price? good condition?

    Leave a Comment: