Top Troy Aikman Cards for All Budgets

Top Troy Aikman Cards for All Budgets

Three Super Bowl titles and the power of the Cowboy's fan base ensures that Troy Aikman will remain high on the collecting radar for years to come. The Hall of Fame quarterback is a popular player for card collectors and we take a look at ten top Troy Aikman card options across all budgets.

While there are many rare Troy Aikman cards, the list below is intended to provide a good mix of price points, as well as overall hobby significance. Let us know in the comments if there are any other Troy Aikman cards you think are worth highlighting.

Top Troy Aikman Cards of All-Time

Click on the listing or images to shop for singles on eBay. 

1989 Pro Set Troy Aikman RC #490

A mishmash of colors and shapes combine to make for an unappealing, but still memorable, rookie card for Troy Aikman. Despite being one of just three rookie options for the Hall of Fame quarterback, PSA 10 versions of the 1989 Pro Set card regularly go for $20 or less.

1989 Pro Set Troy Aikman RC #490

1989 Score Troy Aikman RC #270

The most poplar and valuable Troy Aikman rookie card comes courtesy of 1989 Score. The boyish grin and simple design make for one of the most iconic Troy Aikman cards of all-time.

1989 Score Troy Aikman RC #270

1989 Topps Traded Troy Aikman RC #70T

Simple to the point of being boring, 1989 Topps Traded is definitely a Troy Aikman card for the collecting pursuits. Although Score seems to get all the recognitions, Topps Traded is still a worthy add.

1989 Topps Traded Troy Aikman RC #70T

1991 Pro Line Portraits Autographs Troy Aikman #2

There are plenty of other signed cards available for Troy Aikman, but his 1991 Pro Line Portraits Autograph was the very first. An abnormal image choice and the fact that they were signed on the back of the card makes this one of the most affordable Troy Aikman autograph options.

1991 Pro Line Portraits Autographs Troy Aikman #2 front1991 Pro Line Portraits Autographs Troy Aikman #2 back

1994 Finest Refractors Troy Aikman #202

Modern and retro at the same time, 1994 Finest remains a pivotal set for collectors even if it does not have autographs or low print runs. The Refractor parallel for Troy Aikman adds a dose of rarity and value, but is still not difficult to track down.

1994 Finest Refractors Troy Aikman #202

1996 Select Certified Mirror Red Premium Stock Troy Aikman #54 (PR=20)

While it came before numbered parallels were a regular component of card collecting, 1996 Select Certified still has enough flash to warrant attention. Among a variety of parallel options across the color spectrum, the Mirror Red Premium Stock card was the rarest for Troy Aikman, with an announced print run of only 20.

1996 Select Certified Mirror Red Premium Stock Troy Aikman #54

1997 Collector's Edge Excalibur Game Helmets Troy Aikman #7 (PR=249)

Collector's Edge did some pretty cool things with cards in the 1990s. Troy Aikman's very first memorabilia card contains a piece of game-used football and is found in 1996 Collector's Edge Advantage. There is also an insert that features a game-used Super Bowl game ball for Aikman from the same product. However, another early Troy Aikman relic card is found in 1997 Collector's Edge Excalibur and features a game-used helmet piece and 22K gold foil. While not numbered, the reported print run is 249 copies, so they don't pop up often.

1997 Collector's Edge Excalibur Game Helmets Troy Aikman #7

1998 Fleer Brilliants 24-Karat Gold Parallel Troy Aikman #32 #/24

A Troy Aikman card with an obvious gold theme, this 1998 Fleer Brilliants parallel includes a 24KT gold stamped logo on the front of the card. While the card is appropriately numbered to 24, there are other parallels available that are easier to locate.

1998 Fleer Brilliants 24-Karat Gold Parallel Troy Aikman #32

2002 Topps Ring of Honor Autographs Troy Aikman #RH-TA

The Ring of Honor insert set in 2002 Topps is a tribute to the former Super Bowl MVPs. The large on-card signature and bold look makes it a strong Troy Aikman card on its own. The card takes on added significance for fans of the Dallas Cowboys, as they are one of several teams that induct their best overall players into the team's Ring of Honor.

2002 Topps Ring of Honor Autographs Troy Aikman #RH-TA

2013 Panini Spectra 50th Anniversary HOF Signatures Troy Aikman #142 #/50 (2014 Contenders)

It is hard to go wrong with any on-card autograph for Troy Aikman, but this Panini card has several attributes that make it stand out. The classic design is modernized with a Refractor-like finish and on-card signature. Limited to just 50 copies, the design is from the 2013 Spectra 50th Anniversary HOF Signatures set, but is actually found as an insert in 2014 Contenders.

2013 Panini Spectra 50th Anniversary HOF Signatures Troy Aikman #142

Troy Aikman Multi-Signed Cards

Taking Troy Aikman autographs to the next level, there are quite a few multi-signed card options that have been produced over the years that pair Aikman with current and former players. Obviously, the most popular and valuable cards feature him alongside other Hall of Fame players, especially other former greats for the Cowboys. Check out the available options by following the links to eBay.

2009 Exquisite Collection Ensemble 3 Signatures Roger Staubach Tony Romo Troy Aikman2000 Donruss Preferred Pen Pals Brett Favre Autographs Aikman

Top eBay Listings

2001 Private Stock Game-Worn Gear #40 Troy Aikman Dallas Cowboys Football Card
$12.23

2001 Private Stock Game-Worn Gear #40 Troy Aikman Dallas Cowboys Football Card
$12.23

2001 Private Stock Game-Worn Gear #40 Troy Aikman Dallas Cowboys Football Card
$12.24

2001 Private Stock Game-Worn Gear #40 Troy Aikman Dallas Cowboys Football Card
$12.25

2011 Topps Super Bowl Legends Die-Cut SB-56 Troy Aikman PSA 9 Mint
$49.99

1989 Score #270 Troy Aikman rc nm
$15.00

1990 Topps #482 Troy Aikman Cowboys NM MT
$10.00

1990 Topps #482 Troy Aikman Cowboys NM MT
$10.00

1990 Topps #482 Troy Aikman Cowboys NM MT
$10.00

t2502 - 1998 Aurora Gridiron Laser Cuts #3 Troy Aikman Dallas Cowboys NM-MT
$5.94

u1168 - 1995 Upper Deck Pro Bowl #PB11 Troy Aikman Dallas Cowboys NM-MT
$5.94

t2508 - 1996 Upper Deck Hot Properties #HT9 Troy Aikman Kerry Collins - NM-MT
$5.94

s2170 - 1999 Collector's Edge Supreme T3 #T2 Troy Aikman Dallas NM-MT
$5.94

T7302 - 1998 Stadium Club Chrome #SCC17 Troy Aikman Cowboys Card NM-MT
$5.94

y9558 - 1995 Summit Team Summit #4 Troy Aikman - NM-MT
$5.94

s4261 - 1998 Topps Measures of Greatness #MG7 Troy Aikman Dallas NM-MT
$5.94
« Previous1234

Trey Treutel

E-Mail Author | 
Trey Treutel is an Ole Miss grad and a lifelong sports fanatic. He is a huge fan of the NBA and NFL, as well as soccer, college basketball and college football. As a kid, he collected football and basketball cards. In more recent years, he started collecting basketball cards again on a whim and has since expanded to other sports and entertainment options. Find Trey on Twitter at @datreute or Google+.

User Comments

  1. I have 3 sons and we have collected. Sports cards for the last 20 years. Now that they are moving on and living their lives, they would like to know if they have can sell their cards for a decent price. What would you recommend?

    Just Curious,

    Deborah
    12/4/15

  2. Deborah Check here – https://www.cardboardconnection.com/collectopedia/resources/baseball-card-buyers/

  3. hi I have a 93 in a safe guard case Troy Aikman card I just want to know if it’s a collectible N if it’s worth anything

  4. I have a Troy Aikman card from 1990. It is from Pro Set but has a star logo with PRRO files trademark. I won this in a contest. I think from a TV sports show. It is a torso shot without a helmet on. I cannot find this card anywhere on the intranet. How can I find out the value of this card.

    Leave a Comment: