Top Barry Sanders Cards of All-Time

Top Barry Sanders Cards of All-Time

No stranger to collectors, Barry Sanders is one of the most accomplished players in league history and appeared certain to break the all-time rushing record until his abrupt retirement. While it is fair to wonder how much greater Sanders could have become, he still did plenty in his ten seasons and is easily one of the most popular former NFL players in the hobby. The following guide looks at some of the top card options for Barry Sanders.

View the most popular Barry Sanders card auctions on eBay.

Given the sheer volume of cards available for Barry Sanders, the overall purpose of this list was to identify a good mix of options across all budgets and collecting periods. Clearly there are many other great Barry Sanders cards not mentioned on this list.

Let us know your favorite in the comments or feel free to mention the top Barry Sanders card in your collection.

Top Barry Sanders Football Cards of All-Time

Click on the listing to shop for singles on eBay or check completed sales to see current values. 

1989 Police Oscar Mayer Detroit Lions Barry Sanders #11

While it is not an official rookie card, the oddball Barry Sanders card from the Detroit Police Department is a popular choice for collectors. The narrow card was part of a 12-card set sponsored by Oscar Mayer and Claussen and values can push into the hundreds for high-grade cards.

Top Barry Sanders Cards of All-Time 1

1989 Pro Set Barry Sanders RC #494

One of the three Barry Sanders rookie cards, 1989 Pro Set has aged the worst. The orange color, college image and lined border combine to make a card that is unlikely to impress. However, the card will always maintain interest based on the fact that it is a Barry Sanders rookie card.

Top Barry Sanders Cards of All-Time 2

1989 Score Barry Sanders RC #257

1989 Score Football is the place to find the top rookie card for Barry Sanders in terms of value and the green-heavy design still works today.  The card stands out among the three because it is the only one to feature Sanders in a posed image.

Top Barry Sanders Cards of All-Time 3

1989 Topps Traded Barry Sanders RC #83T

The final Barry Sanders rookie card came in the update box set called 1989 Topps Traded Football. The simple design and Detroit Lions uniform make it arguably the best-looking Barry Sanders rookie card for collectors.

Top Barry Sanders Cards of All-Time 4

1990 Pro Set Barry Sanders #1 Hawaii Trade Show Promo

For most collectors, Pro Set is indicative of the period defined by huge print runs and low values. While this is largely true, there are exceptions. One of these is a limited variation for Barry Sanders from the 1990 Pro Set. The rare promo was originally issued at the Hawaii Trade Show Conference and can be easily distinguished from the base card by the image on the back. The regular version shows Sanders hoisting the Rookie of the Year trophy. Also, the promo card does not display "THE OFFICIAL NFL CARD" on the top part of the gold border on the card's front.

Top Barry Sanders Cards of All-Time 5

Top Barry Sanders Cards of All-Time 6

1991 Score Dream Team Autographs Barry Sanders #677 (PR=500)

One of the earliest Barry Sanders autographs, this card rarely surfaces and has long caused headaches for collectors. The base version, shown second, is very common and displays a facsimile autograph on the back. The signed version, reportedly limited to 500 copies, is signed on the front and a blank spot replaces the facsimile autograph on the back.

 Top Barry Sanders Cards of All-Time 7Top Barry Sanders Cards of All-Time 8

Top Barry Sanders Cards of All-Time 9Top Barry Sanders Cards of All-Time 10

1994 Finest Refractor Barry Sanders #44

Part of the Refractor revolution that would become a fixture of the hobby, 1994 Finest Football is a terrific option for collectors. The loud Barry Sanders parallel card is rare enough to yield a premium but is still affordable for most collectors.

Top Barry Sanders Cards of All-Time 11

1996 Upper Deck Game Jersey Barry Sanders #GJ9

While collectors can find game-used football relics for Barry Sanders in 1996 Collector's Edge Advantage, the first game-used jersey card for Sanders came in 1996 Upper Deck. Most would think little of the small jersey pieces now, but at the time, these cards were very notable and strong values follow whenever they surface.

Top Barry Sanders Cards of All-Time 12

1997 E-X2000 Essential Credentials Barry Sanders #11 #/100
1998 E-X2001 Essential Credentials Future Barry Sanders #5 #/56

Already one of the most distinct brands from the history of the hobby, E-X also introduced Essential Credentials parallels. 1997 and 1998 are both very popular editions for Barry Sanders collectors. In addition to the pinkish 1998 Future parallel shown below, there is also a Now version that is limited to just five copies.

Top Barry Sanders Cards of All-Time 13Top Barry Sanders Cards of All-Time 14

1997 Fleer Metal Precious Metal Gems Barry Sanders #162 #/150

The PMG craze never reached the same heights in football as it did for basketball collectors, but the foil-covered Precious Metal Gems parallels are still an appealing option. There are 150 total cards for Barry Sanders and the first 15 are done in green foil, while the remaining 135 cards in the print run are red.

Top Barry Sanders Cards of All-Time 15

1999 Donruss Elite Passing the Torch Autographs Barry Sanders, Walter Payton #4

Celebrating two of the greatest running backs in NFL history, this signed card for Barry Sanders and Walter Payton is a piece of sports history. While the print run of 1,500 might seem high, only the first 100 were actually signed and the remainder were issued as an unsigned insert.

Top Barry Sanders Cards of All-Time 16Top Barry Sanders Cards of All-Time 17

High-End Upper Deck Barry Sanders Autographs

Although sticker autographs became the norm for most products during the 2000s, premium releases brought the on-card autographs back to collectors. Exquisite Collection is one of the most popular choices from Upper Deck and the set presents several low-numbered options for Barry Sanders.

Top Barry Sanders Cards of All-Time 18

High-End Topps Barry Sanders Autographs

Another top modern collecting option for Barry Sanders is found in Topps sets. Among the various choices, Five Star brings a quality design and on-card autograph.

Top Barry Sanders Cards of All-Time 19

High-End Panini Barry Sanders Autographs

Offering the most current NFL cards on the list, Panini has a stable of high-end brands for Barry Sanders autographs. While there are several notable choices, Flawless features all the hallmarks of a premium release for collectors. Other top options include Immaculate Collection and National Treasures.

Top Barry Sanders Cards of All-Time 20

Multi-Player Barry Sanders Autographs

In addition to his many single-player cards, Barry Sanders is also a popular option for dual, triple, quad and other multi-player autographs. Sanders is frequently paired with other Hall of Fame players, especially running backs, and these limited cards can produce some of the highest total values.

Top Barry Sanders Cards of All-Time 21

Top Barry Sanders Cards of All-Time 22

Trey Treutel

 |  E-Mail Author
Trey Treutel is an Ole Miss grad and a lifelong sports fanatic. He is a huge fan of the NBA and NFL, as well as soccer, college basketball and college football. As a kid, he collected football and basketball cards. In more recent years, he started collecting basketball cards again on a whim and has since expanded to other sports and entertainment options. Find Trey on Twitter at @datreute.

User Comments

  1. i have a Barry sanders rookie and am trying to find the value of it and where I could go to sell it.

  2. Hi noticed on the 1991 pro set gazette inserts it mentions redemption cards for the all-star cards #d to 25, do you know if these exist, can’t find any info on these cards at all.

    2 of my best Sanders cards are from the 1990 Pro Set Cincinnati Fact set, extremely rare

  3. Hi I have a Fleer Mystique Barry Sanders Card That had the Back of it being all Red With no stats and no year.If you would like pics of the card you can Email me at Joelindsey44@gmail.com PLZ HELP ME JUST WONDERING IF I HAVE SOMETHING SPECIAL OR WHAT.THANKS I HOPE TO HEAR FROM YOU SOON

  4. It says Members choice on the bottom and Barry sanders is about to cut and he only has 2 hands on the ball. Theres 2 players that have there have body in the card picture its the bears are broncos that half of there body was in the card picture

  5. How much is the Barry Sanders Super Bowl xl worth. Topps. Thanks Bob

  6. I actually have all 4 of the listed Barry Sanders RC’s including the Oscar Meyer. How much would the complete set of the 4 be worth?
    Actually have multiples of the score and proset versions.

    Leave a Comment: