2x Stanley Cup Champ & 2016 Conn Smythe Winner! Top 10 Sidney Crosby Rookie Cards

2x Stanley Cup Champ & 2016 Conn Smythe Winner! Top 10 Sidney Crosby Rookie Cards

Since his 2005-06 debut, Sidney Crosby has been one of the most dynamic players in hockey. Collectors have noticed, pushing Sidney Crosby cards near the top of the hobby. As Crosby continues to pile up the hardware, one can see a legend in the making skating in Pittsburgh. Sidney Crosby rookie cards have become legendary as well, and his top options are documented below.

Shop for Sidney Crosby Rookie Cards on eBay.

Taken first overall in the 2005 NHL Entry Draft by the Pittsburgh Penguins, the Canadian stud quickly made an impression and ultimately finished second in the race for the Calder Memorial Trophy. Since then, he has been one of the best players in the NHL, only slowed by injuries and a history of concussions.

Blowout In Post Ad

The following guide identifies the ten best Sidney Crosby rookie cards for collectors to acquire. See his full rookie card checklist and other notable collecting options in our Sidney Crosby player profile.

Top 10 Sidney Crosby Rookie Cards

Click on the images or listings to shop for cards on eBay. 

10. 2005-06 Upper Deck Artifacts Sidney Crosby RC #224 #/750

The old-fashioned look of 2005-06 Upper Deck Artifacts makes this Sidney Crosby rookie stand out at number ten on the list. With a print run of 750, it's a relatively difficult find for collectors in a product that usually flies under the radar.

Sidney Crosby Rookie Cards - 2005-06 Upper Deck Artifacts

9. 2005-06 Upper Deck Black Diamond Sidney Crosby RC #193

Finding Crosby in a box of Black Diamond is like finding a diamond in the rough. This card comes from a product that only features a couple of rookies a box. While the print run isn’t known, it still fetches a lot on the secondary market.

2005-06 Upper Deck Black Diamond Sidney Crosby RC #193

8. 2005-06 Upper Deck Trilogy Sidney Crosby RC #211 #/999

While the 2005-06 Upper Deck Trilogy rookie isn't quite as beloved as some other Sidney Crosby rookie cards, its limited print run and the average product price help make it one of the young superstar's top cards.

7. 2005-06 Upper Deck Young Guns Sidney Crosby RC #201

The 2005-06 Upper Deck Hockey Sidney Crosby is probably his most recognizable and widely collected rookie card. Despite not being numbered or offering a signature or even a relic, Young Guns have been a staple of the flagship brand for years and this will always be a hobby favorite.

2005-06 Upper Deck Young Guns Sidney Crosby RC #201

6. 2005-06 Upper Deck Hot Prospects Sidney Crosby RC #276 Autographed Jersey #/199

Although Hot Prospects was one Upper Deck’s lower-priced products in 2005-06, there are still some great treasures to be found. One of those is this Sidney Crosby rookie card that features an autograph and jersey swatch. A great addition to your collection, it won't break the bank as much as some of the other autographed rookies for "The Kid."

2005-06 Upper Deck Hot Prospects Sidney Crosby RC

5. 2005-06 Upper Deck Ultimate Collection Sidney Crosby RC #91 Autograph #/299

Coming out of one of the most expensive products of the season, 2005-06 Upper Deck Ultimate Collection showcases a limited number of Sidney Crosby rookie autographs. The on-card autograph, low print run and high-end price point make it one of the top options for collectors.

2005-06 Upper Deck Ultimate Collection Sidney Crosby RC #91 Autograph

4. 2005-06 SPx Sidney Crosby RC #191 Autographed Jersey #/499

The 2005-06 SPx rookie may not be the prettiest card on the list, but it's one of the few autographed memorabilia cards Crosby had in his rookie year. Because the more limited print run makes it harder to find, collectors have responded with high secondary market values.

3. 2005-06 SP Authentic Future Watch Sidney Crosby RC #181 Autograph #/999

SP Authentic is extremely popular with rookie card collectors and having Crosby in the set only amplifies the interest for the 2005-06 edition. Although not the rarest Sidney Crosby rookie, the brand recognition bolsters its popularity as does the on-card signature.

2005-06 SP Authentic Future Watch Sidney Crosby RC #181 Autograph

2. 2005-06 Upper Deck Ice Sidney Crosby RC #106 #/99

An iconic card of its own, 2005-06 Upper Deck Ice is the most valuable of the non-autographed Sidney Crosby rookie cards. With just 99 copies available, it's also one the most sought-after among all his releases. Although the 2005-06 Upper Deck Young Guns card may be the most recognizable, many collectors would rather have Ice in their collections. There is something about those Ice Premieres and their acetate stock that makes collectors smile and the high values surely help, as well.

2005-06 Upper Deck Ice Sidney Crosby RC

1. 2005-06 Upper Deck The Cup Sidney Crosby RC #180 Autographed Patch #/99

The Holy Grail of all Sidney Crosby cards is his 2005-06 The Cup rookie, which comes with both an on-card autograph and a patch swatch. Coming from the most expensive product in hockey, it is also one of the rarest of all his rookie cards. The 2005-06 Upper Deck The Cup Sidney Crosby can fetch numbers that few athletes can ever hope to achieve. You want to buy it? Be prepared to put down the same amount of money as you might for a new car.

2005-06 Upper Deck The Cup Sidney Crosby RC #180 Autographed Patch

Top eBay Listings

05 06 Upper Deck Sidney Crosby Phenomenal Beginnings Hockey Set Factory Sealed
$9.86

2005-06 UD Rookie Update Sidney Crosby RC Dual Autograph AU SP 199
$911.23

SIDNEY CROSBY 2005-06 UD ULTIMATE ROOKIE YEAR JERSEY PATCH SP 75 #P-SC PENGUINS
$87.99

SIDNEY CROSBY Heroes Prospects Update Rookie Card PGi10
$49.99

UD SIDNEY CROSBY Phenomenal Beginning 2005 rookie year set of 20 cards + 1 large
$9.00

04-05 ITG Heroes & Prospects Sidney Crosby Autograph AUTO Pre - RC RARE!!
$531.55

05-06 ITG Ultimate Memorabilia SIDNEY CROSBY Autograph Stick Rookie 29 50 RC !
$474.60

05-06 ITG Sidney Crosby 2CLR Emblem 9 10 Rookie ROY RC * 1 1? Junior Jersey # *
$569.52

05-06 ITG Sidney Crosby Mario Lemieux Double Emblem 10 RC Franchise 3CLR 1 1?
$1,139.04

2005-06 ITG IN THE GAME #361 SIDNEY CROSBY HOT PROSPECTS ROOKIE LOT OF 6! PL031
$9.99

2005-06 UD PARKHURST SIDNEY CROSBY ROOKIE LOT OF 6! PENGUINS RC HOT! PL029
$8.99

2005-06 UD UPPER DECK #1 SIDNEY CROSBY ROOKIE CLASS LOT OF 3! PENGUINS RC PL030
$5.99

2005-06 MCDONALD'S SIDNEY CROSBY RC UD ROOKIE SP #51 PENGUINS
$21.25

SIDNEY CROSBY PENGUINS 2005 UD DIARY OF A PHENOM DP30 ROOKIE RC GRADED 10
$14.40

2003 SIDNEY CROSBY EXTREME AUTO # 125 FIRST CROSBY AUTO EVER!!! RARE PRE-RC
$5,749.87

2004-05 SIDNEY CROSBY PRE-RC ITG UPDATE #222 #6 10 GRADED 9.5 RARE EXPO CARD
$529.87
« Previous12345


Related Topics:

Kevin Ransom

E-Mail Author |  http://sportscardblog.net/
Kevin began collecting as a child during the 1990s boom of sports cards. After a short hiatus, he returned in 2005 when he learned of the new technologies that brought you closer to your favorite players. Today, he continues to collect players from his favorite teams and writes on his blog at SportsCardBlog.net. Outside of card collecting, he is currently a graduate student at George Washington University getting his Master's in Security and Safety Leadership. Find him on Twitter @SportsCardBlog.

User Comments

  1. thought rookie cards must be # out of 100 . Last on is of 99

  2. Rookie cards must be part of a base set. We don’t consider numbering to be a factor for the rookie card label.

  3. I have a 2006-07 Get In The Game Double Memorabilia Card. It has a piece of game used 2003 CHL Canada-Russia Challenge Jersey and a piece of game used glove. It is the Gold version and is 1 of 10. . Could you tell me what it may be worth? It appears to be mint. It is in a hard plastic case

    Leave a Comment:

MENU