Willie Mays Baseball Cards: Rookie Cards Checklist and Buying Guide

Willie Mays Baseball Cards: Rookie Cards Checklist and Buying Guide

Willie "The Say Hey Kid" Mays is one of the greatest players to transition from the Negro Leagues to Major League Baseball. It's a sad fact of the game, and our culture, that segregation stifled the early careers of such greats as Mays and Hank Aaron. There's no telling what their career numbers might have been without these racial barriers. What is known is that Mays is still regarded as one of the greatest players that ever lived. Blessed with natural five-tool athletic talent, Mays could single-handedly dictate the outcome of a game, either with his bat, speed or outfield defense.

Top 10 Willie Mays cards of all-time.

The statistical byline for Mays reads like the stuff of legends. He holds the record (with Stan Musial) for All-Star appearances at 24 and was twice named the game's Most Valuable Player. Mays was a 12-time Gold Glove Award winner, named the 1951 Rookie of the Year, the National League's MVP twice, and a World Series Champion in 1954.

Mays retired after the 1973 season with a lifetime batting average of .302 and 660 home runs. His lifetime total of 7,095 outfield fielding putouts remains a major league record. Mays went on to be elected to the Baseball Hall of Fame on the first ballot with a voting record of 95 percent, which is one of the highest in the history of the current BBWA election process.

Once again, as it did with the Mickey Mantle, Bowman was the first gum manufacturer to issue a trading card of "The Say Hey Kid" with their classic 1951 set. Obviously, the 1952 Topps card, given the company's stature in the hobby, is treated with rookie card reverence on the secondary market.

Willie Mays Rookie Cards

1951 Bowman #305

The 1951 Bowman set almost didn't include this important collectible. As described in a Heritage Auction catalogue, "The 'High's'  (high-number series issue late in the baseball season)  enabled the production of Willie Mays' "true" rookie card. The importance of Willie Mays' '51 Bowman card is difficult to overstate. How could any responsibly prepared group of gum cards from the time ignore one of the finest talents that would ever be made manifest on the diamond, and remain viable?" Fortunately, it's a hypothetical question that never needs to be answered. Utilizing a horizontal orientation and the classic painted imagery of the 1951 Bowman Baseball design, Mays is depicted in a batting pose with a look on his face that is truly indicative of the fierce competitor that he was known to be.

1952 Topps #261

It's amazing to think that both Mickey Mantle and Willie Mays had their first Topps cards in this set, further adding to the timeless allure of this treasured classic. Featuring a photo-painted upper body portrait of a rather confused looking Mays, the 1952 cards are getting increasingly difficult to find in decent condition because of their notorious centering issues.

Card Gallery

ebaysmalllogo Image



1712908176254040 1 Image
2014 Topps Commemorative Rookie Class Ring Of 1951 Willie Mays Giants
$15.99
2716166514624040 1 Image
1951 Bowman Willie Mays rookie GAI 4.5
$1,200.00
1114714826604040 1 Image
2012 Topps Baseball Factory Set + 5-Rookie Variations & Willie Mays
$34.99
2615817854684040 1 Image
1959 TOPPS #50 Willie Mays Non Auto ROOKIE Card San Francisco Giants HOF'er L@@K
$75.00
1114715571104040 1 Image
1951 BOWMAN WILLIE MAYS #305 EX-MT 6 (OC) HOF ROOKIE
$1,488.00
3606929614684040 1 Image
WILLIE MAYS 1952 TOPPS RC ROOKIE #261 SGC 30 GIANTS LEGEND MLB HOF RARE
$699.99
2912517213374040 1 Image
1992 UPPER DECK BASEBALL HEROES 51 ROOKIE OF THE YEAR # 46 OF 54 WILLIE MAYS A13
$0.50
2615826858364040 1 Image
1952 TOPPS NO. 261 WILLIE MAYS ROOKIE CARD WELL CENTERED & NO CREASES
$1,595.00



« Previous12345...1011

 Image


Rob Bertrand

E-Mail Author | 
Rob Bertrand is an avid collector with over 20 years of active experience in the hobby. He is one of the site's most accomplished writers, as well as the co-host of Cardboard Connection Radio. You can follow him on Twitter @VOTC.

User Comments

  1. I was an avid card collector, mainly baseball and football. In 1999 I collected many packs of Greats of the Game and I have Stan Musial’s autographed card. Nowhere on the web is there a picture or info about the card. I was wondering if you know anything about it.

  2. Dean Konop » Does the card have a brown border? If so, it’s actually from 2000, not 1999.

    Leave a Comment: