T206 Honus Wagner Baseball – History of the World’s Most Famous Card
Widely considered the most valuable baseball card of all-time, the T206 Honus Wagner has been the subject of great debate and, at times, controversy. Produced by the American Tobacco Company for its T206 series of baseball cards between 1909 and 1911, the Wagner has reached such mythical proportions that it is often simply called The Card.
It has even been the topic of a book by the same name. Written by Michael O'Keeffe of the New York Daily News, The Card provides a detailed account of the origins of the T206 Honus Wagner baseball card, its rise to hobby prominence, and some of the less-than-noble events surrounding the card's provenance in the last several years.
Origin of the T206 Honus Wagner Baseball Card
It is estimated that less than 60 of the T206 Honus Wagner cards still exist. By last count, there have been 57 known examples. Having produced anywhere between 60 and 200 in total, it is remarkable that this many of the cards have survived the test of time.
Production of the card was cut short due to a dispute between Wagner and American Tobacco. The exact reason for this has become something of legend, but it has been widely accepted to be one of two scenarios. The first suggests that Wagner, a Hall of Fame shortstop for the Pittsburgh Pirates, didn’t want his likeness used to market tobacco. He didn't like the idea of how it might encourage kids to use tobacco.
The second, and more probable, is that Wagner felt entitled to compensation from the American Tobacco Company for the use of his name and likeness to market their product. Regardless of the specific reason, what is known is that, unlike other cards in the set, the T206 Honus Wagner is disproportionately short-printed compared to other cards in the series.
The Physical T206 Honus Wagner Card
Despite being pulled from production, several variations of the card were printed. The majority of the cards seem to have been printed with a Sweet Caporal 150 Series-Factory 25 back. However, a handful are known to have the Sweet Caporal 150 Series-Factory 30 advertisement. Three are also known to have the Piedmont backing, making it the rarest version of all.
Even the most beat up copies of the T206 Honus Wagner sell for at least six figures, just as long as it's deemed authentic. With a hobby so dependent on condition and rarity for determining value, it is remarkable that the Wagner gets such a pass on condition.
Because of its rarity, history and the iconic Hall of Famer it depicts, the T206 Honus Wagner has been coveted, pursued, owned and sold by industry executives, Hollywood moguls, athletes and entertainers. Perhaps, the most famous is the Gretzky T206 Honus Wagner. The card long had a controversial past, as some speculate that it was once altered, most likely having been trimmed or cut from an undistributed sheet. This would account for its almost impossible-to-believe Near Mint condition.
This controversy didn’t prevent the card from receiving a grade of 8 from PSA/DNA, the first card ever graded by the company in 1991. The Gretzky T206 Wagner was first sold by collector Alan Ray to the famed sports memorabilia dealer named Bill Mastro, the one-time owner of Mastro Auctions. In later years, Mastro Auctions was the subject of an FBI investigation for using unscrupulous methods such as card doctoring, price-fixing and shill bidding to increase profits.
Mastro eventually sold the card to Jim Copeland, a sporting goods magnate, for nearly four times the price he had originally paid. The size and scope of the deal revitalized interest in the sports memorabilia market as investors saw it as a means of sheltering money in turbulent economic times, free from the volatility of the stock market and other traditional investment tools. In 1991, Copeland sold the card to legendary hockey Hall of Famer Wayne Gretzky and one-time owner of the Los Angeles Kings, Bruce McNall for $451,000, which again caught the attention of non-collectors and the mainstream press.
Gretzky resold the card four years later to Walmart and a company called Treat Entertainment for $500,000. The card was used as the grand prize in a promotional contest. The next year, a Florida postal worker won the card and auctioned it at Christie's auction house for $640,000. The winning bid was placed by Chicago collector, Michael Gidwitz.
As you can see, every time the card has sold, the value has risen significantly. The short amount of time it has remained in the hands of a single owner is indicative of the commodity status the card has achieved. Gidwitz sold the T206 Honus Wagner in 2000, through Robert Edward Auctions, to card collector Brian Siegel for a record-setting $1.27 million.
In February, 2007, Siegel then sold the card privately to an anonymous collector for $2.35 million. It was later revealed that the anonymous collector was former major league pitcher Tom Candiotti. Just a short six months later, the card was sold to another anonymous collector for $2.8 million. In April, 2011, the identity of the buyer was revealed to be Ken Kendrick, managing general partner of the Arizona Diamondbacks.
In October, 2013, controversy finally caught up with the Gretzky Wagner as Bill Mastro admitted to trimming the card.
A handful of other T206 Honus Wagner baseball cards have surfaced in recent years, some real and some not. Several of the authentic cards have fetched hundreds of thousands of dollars in auctions regardless of their condition.
One particular T206 Honus Wagner of suspect provenance is the example owned by John Cobb and Ray Edwards of Cincinnati. The card attracted lots of media attention over its questionable authenticity, including being a feature segment on the highly rated sports documentary program, HBO Real Sports. Additionally, many leading hobby experts regarded the card as a fake, including PSA president, Joe Orlando.
After years of refusing to have the card graded, the owners agreed to have the card examined by a fringe grading service, Card Collector Services, who also ruled that the card was simply a well-produced reprint. This didn’t thwart the owners' attempts to prove the legitimacy of their card, who next presented it to Integrated Paper Services (IPS), an independent paper testing and analysis lab to have their card's paper checked for era of production.
An IPS expert determined that the card dated back to 1910, which would be consistent to the time period when the card was distributed. The expert ruled that the "paper stock was consistent with the time that card would have been made." With this proof as their claim to credibility, they proceeded to list the card on eBay but eventually had the listing removed due to the overwhelming number of questions the online auction marketplace received about the card’s authenticity.
The Story of the T206 Honus Wagner Baseball Card Continues
In 2010, the fabled T206 Honus Wagner card once again gained national notoriety when a new card was found. Belonging to the brother of Sister Virginia Muller, he left all his possessions to the Baltimore-based School Sisters of Notre Dame convent. Heritage Auctions handled the sale of the card, which exceeded pre-auction estimates. It sold for $262,000 despite being in poor condition.
The publicity the latest T206 Honus Wagner received proved, once again, that regardless of condition, deep-pocketed collectors and investors are willing to pay huge amounts for this rare card. Only time will tell if other examples are waiting to be discovered. One thing is certain, whenever a T206 Honus Wagner is sold, it will make national headlines.