Top 10 Football Rookie Cards of the 1980s

Top 10 Football Rookie Cards of the 1980s

For a lot of things, the 1980s have become a punchline. Mullets, slouch socks and My Two Dads all seemed like good ideas at the time. But some things from the 1980s will never grow old, like The Goonies, Pac-Man and the music video for A-Ha's "Take on Me." In the same vein comes the list of the top 10 football rookie cards of the 1980s.

Spanning all parts of the decade, the list encapsulates a good part of a generation's greatness. Although many sets, particularly in the latter part of the 1980s, suffer from massive print runs, they're still not nearly as bad as what you find in baseball. At least that's the case for sets released before 1988.

Every card in our top 10 list of the 80s best football rookies pictures a Hall of Famer, just as one might expect. With all the players' careers over, prices should remain largely stable. There will likely be some movement in one direction or the other, but likely not much unless it's part of a bigger hobby trend.

Top 10 Most Valuable Football Rookie Cards of the 1980s

Rankings are based on average online sales of copies graded 9 Mint by PSA and Beckett.

10. 1980 Topps Phil Simms RC

A career New York Giant, the quarterback may not have the fanciest rookie card of all-time but we are talking about a two-time Super Bowl winner. Combine that with the age of the card and you've got a card that will always have demand.

1980 Topps Phil Simms 214x300 Image

9. 1989 Score Barry Sanders RC

By the time 1989 rolled around, print runs were soaring. As a result, prices of the 1989 Score Barry Sanders, the running back's most popular rookie, have softened in recent years. This could make it a bargain in the years to come as there's lots of room for growth once again.

1989 Score Football Barry Sanders 211x300 Image

8. 1982 Topps Lawrence Taylor RC

It looks as though Lawrence Taylor's troubling legal issues may have caught up with him as far as the hobby goes. Although he is still one of the most widely recognized (and collected) defensive players in NFL history, his appeal has softened in the past few years.

1982 Topps Football Lawrence Taylor RC 211x300 Image

7. 1982 Topps Ronnie Lott RC

As a key part of the San Francisco 49ers dynasty of the 1980s, Ronnie Lott will always have a following in the hobby. His Hall of Fame career kicked off in a big way as Lott got seven interceptions in his rookie campaign. He also didn't have to wait long to get his first Super Bowl ring with the 49ers taking Super Bowl XVI.

1982 Topps Football Ronnie Lott RC 212x300 Image

6. 1986 Topps Reggie White RC

Who said defensive players weren't collected. The third defender (and -- small spoiler alert -- last) on the list is the late Reggie White. The "Minister of Defense" was a 13-time Pro Bowl selection. In 2010, White was named by the league as the NFL's seventh best player of all-time. As far as top football rookie cards of the 1980s go, he's right up there as well.

1986 Topps Football Reggie White 213x300 Image

5. 1984 Topps Dan Marino RC

As far as all-round great sets go, 1984 Topps Football is one of them. It features rookie cards of two of the greatest and most popular quarterbacks of all-time. First up is Dan Marino. His career stats are legendary. His appearance in Ace Ventura: Pet Detective was amazing. Okay, maybe not but it was still worthy of a couple of cheap laughs. Yet, the fact that Marino never won a Super Bowl is something many still hold against him. Obviously not a ton of collectors, as the 1984 Topps Dan Marino rookie still commands a lot of attention.

1984 Topps Dan Marino RC 211x300 Image

4. 1984 Topps John Elway RC

For the majority of his career, John Elway was in the same boat as Marino. He couldn't bring a Super Bowl to Denver. That changed in Super Bowl XXXII when the quarterback led the Bronco's to their first-ever championship. With that off his back, Elway followed it up with another Super Bowl the following year, cementing his place as one of the all-time greats. It also took his 1984 Topps rookie card to a new level.

1984 Topps John Elway RC 210x300 Image

3. 1986 Topps Steve Young RC

It's weird seeing Steve Young in a Bucs uniform. For many collectors, it can't be too strange as it's one of the top-selling football cards of the 1980s. And the 1986 Topps Football Steve Young rookie card isn't even his first Topps card (we'll get to that in a bit). It took the quarterback a while to emerge as a hobby favorite, spending several years as Joe Montana's backup. Yet, once the proverbial torch was passed, Young emerged as one of football's best quarterbacks. He retired with three Super Bowls, two MVP selections and seven trips to the Pro Bowl.

1986 Topps Football Steve Young RC 212x300 Image

2. 1986 Topps Jerry Rice RC

Is Jerry Rice the best football player in NFL history? The league thinks so. The wide receiver spent most of his career as the main target for Joe Montana and Steve Young in San Francisco. Among his many records is the one for most career touchdowns with 208. Rice has three Super Bowl rings and was the game's MVP at Super Bowl XXIII.

1986 Topps Football Jerry Rice RC 213x300 Image

1. 1981 Topps Football Joe Montana RC

One of the most beloved and respected athletes of all-time for any sport, Joe Montana has long been a hobby favorite. The face of the 49ers dynasty it seemed like Montana's warm smile was everywhere. It should come as no surprise that his 1981 Topps card remains the best and most valuable football rookie card of the 1980s after all these years.

1981 Topps Joe Montana RC 213x300 Image

Special Mention for non-NFL Cards

The list above ranks NFL cards. During the 1980s, Topps also made sets in 1984 and 1985 for the short-lived USFL. Those sets did have the cardboard debuts for several players, including two currently on our list. Also, during the early part of the decade, Warren Moon was tearing up the CFL and appeared on some sets north of the border. So while they're not NFL rookie cards, here are six cards deserving of a mention in any discussion about the best football cards of the 1980s:

ebaysmalllogo Image
1911450509784040 1 Image
1982 Topps 486 Ronnie Lott RC NM #D22292
$15.00
1813891004134040 1 Image
1984 Topps 63 John Elway RC NM #D22294
$40.00
1813891005134040 1 Image
1984 Topps 123 Dan Marino RC NM #D22295
$40.00
2912410748174040 1 Image
1982 Topps Rookie Lawrence Taylor New York Giants #434 Football Card
$14.95
2516431802784040 1 Image
1984 Topps Dan Marino Miami Dolphins Rookie Card
$50.00
3313170918434040 1 Image
1988 Topps Cello W BO JACKSON Rookie on top
$21.97
2009787262754040 1 Image
1989 TOPPS FOOTBALL CARD ANDRE RISON ROOKIE #102T LOT (12) NRMT-MINT 141013
$5.99
3110879369324040 1 Image
1-1989 ProSet Football Series 2 Factory Sealed Troy Aikman & Barry Sanders RC EX
$19.99
1514104476424040 1 Image
1983 TOPPS GARY ANDERSON 7 CARD ROOKIE LOT,NR MT MT
$7.99
3607477865894040 1 Image
1989 DEION SANDERS - Score "ROOKIE" Football Card- #224 - Atlanta Falcons
$10.95
2611474680854040 1 Image
BRIAN QUICK RAMS 2012 TOPPS CHROME '1984 ROOKIE RC # 19 GRADED 10
$22.40
2309036854624040 1 Image
ISAIAH PEAD RAMS 2012 TOPPS CHROME '1984 ROOKIE RC # 17 GRADED 10
$22.40
« Previous12345
 Image

Ryan Cracknell

E-Mail Author | 
Ryan's collecting origins began with winter bike rides to the corner store, tossing a couple of quarters onto the counter and peddling home with a couple packs of O-Pee-Chee hockey in his pocket. Today, he continues to build sets, go after inserts with cool technologies, chase Montreal Expos and finish off his John Jaha master collection. Ryan can be found on Twitter @tradercracks and Google+.

User Comments

  1. Great article this listed could have been a mile long for all the great players of the era. Football in the late 80’s and early 90’s was the best. Some honorable mentions for this list 89 Score Troy Aikman RC
    and 88 Topps Bo Jackson RC.

  2. Jeremy Brannon (ID 54209) ยป Thanks Jeremy, My notes had TONS more great cards. I actually went out and bought the Aikman immediately after writing the piece. Along with Thurman Thomas.

  3. Phil Simms is not in the HOF.

    Leave a Comment: