Top 10 Football Rookie Cards of the 1960s

Top 10 Football Rookie Cards of the 1960s

The 1960s saw three different companies produce mainstream football cards for the NFL and AFL. The decade had several Hall of Famers make their cardboard debuts. A handful of football rookie cards from the 1960s have reached iconic status, remaining extremely desirable with collectors five decades later.

Topps was the only company to produce football cards throughout the decade. In 1960 they had the NFL license. They added the AFL in 1961. In 1964, the company dropped the NFL and was strictly AFL through 1967. Beginning in 1968, they were the only football card maker. Fleer made football cards for the early part of the decade. They held the AFL license in 1960 and added the NFL for 1962 and 1963. The Philadelphia Gum Company took over as the lone NFL card maker from 1965 to 1967.

The decade brought the hobby several memorable designs, both vertical and horizontal. Topps also experimented with an over-sized format in 1965. Their lone "tall boy" gridiron set remains a favorite in the hobby today, bolstered immensely by Joe Namath's rookie card.

Here's a look at the ten best football rookie cards of the 1960s. Cards were selected largely based on secondary market value today, however their lasting appeal in the hobby was also taken into consideration. Some of the notable cards that just missed out include 1960 Fleer Jack Kemp, 1961 Fleer Don Meredith, 1961 Fleer Don Maynard, 1968 Topps Bob Griese, and 1969  Topps Brian Piccolo.

10. 1962 Topps Ernie Davis RC #36 SP

Winner of the 1961 Heisman Trophy, Ernie Davis proceeded to become the first pick in the 1962 NFL Draft. In the process, he became the first African American to be selected first overall. The Redskins promptly traded the running back to the Cleveland Browns. Tragically, Davis was diagnosed with leukemia before he could make his NFL debut. Davis passed away less than a year later at the age of 23. The short-printed 1962 Topps Ernie Davis rookie card is extremely condition sensitive due its black borders.

1962 Topps Ernie Davis RC 260x182 Image

9. 1963 Topps Bob Lilly RC #82 SP

Bob Lilly was the first inductee into the legendary Dallas Cowboys Ring of Honor. Between 1961 and 1974, the defensive tackle never missed a regular season game. He was an 11-time Pro Bowl selection and named to the NFL's 75th Anniversary All-Time Team. The value of the 1963 Topps Bob Lilly rookie card is bolstered by the fact that it's a short print.

1963 Topps Bob Lilly RC 208x300 Image

8. 1963 Topps Ray Nitschke RC #96

Although Ray Nitschke debuted with the Packers in 1958, he didn't get his rookie card until 1963. A hero in Green Bay, Nitschke was a key player for the Packers in both of their Super Bowl I and II victories. Nitschke played his entire career in Green Bay and was named to both the NFL's 50th and 75th Anniversary All-Time Teams.

1963 Topps Ray Nitschke RC 209x300 Image

7. 1963 Fleer Lance Alworth RC #72

Lance Alworth is viewed by many as the greatest receiver in football during the 1960s. He won an AFL Championship with the San Diego Chargers in 1963 and a Super Bowl with the Cowboys in Super Bowl VI. The Universal Press named Alworth as the AFL's Most Valuable Player in 1963. In 1978, he became the first AFL player to be elected into the Pro Football Hall of Fame.

1963 Fleer Lance Alworth RC 214x300 Image

6. 1963 Fleer Len Dawson RC #47

One of the best quarterbacks in AFL history, Len Dawson led the Kansas City Chiefs to three AFL Championships. That success transferred over to the Super Bowl, bringing Super Bowl IV to Kansas City. He was the game's MVP. Following his playing days, Dawson had a successful career in the broadcast booth. Dawson was elected to the Pro Football Hall of Fame in 1987.

1963 Fleer Len Dawson RC 213x300 Image

5. 1966 Philadelphia Gale Sayers RC #38

One of football's most recognizable players, Gale Sayers is one of football's all-time great rushers. The fourth pick in the 1965 draft, Sayers won two NFL rushing titles. He gained further notoriety when his 1971 autobiography was made into the film, Brian's Song, which documented his experiences with teammate Brian Piccolo and Piccolo's battle with cancer.

1966 Philadelphia Gale Sayers RC 213x300 Image

4. 1965 Topps Fred Biletnikoff RC #133 SP

Other than a year in the Canadian Football League, Fred Biletnikoff spent his entire career with the Raiders franchise, helping the team to a Super Bowl XI. The wide receiver was a six-time Pro Bowl selection and was elected to the Pro Football Hall of Fame in 1988. His rookie is a short print in the classic 1965 Topps Football set.

1965 Topps Fred Biletnikoff 158x300 Image

3. 1966 Philadelphia Dick Butkus RC #31

One of the biggest personalities in football history, Dick Butkus remains extremely popular with collectors today. One of the game's greatest linebackers, he was an eight-time Pro Bowl selection. A legend at the University of Illinois, Butkus has remained in the public eye since retiring thanks to many roles in movies and TV shows.

1966 Philadelphia Dick Butkus1 210x300 Image

2. 1962 Topps Mike Ditka RC #17

The third member of the Chicago Bears on the list, Mike Ditka isn't only one of football's best-ever players, but also one of its most famous coaches. Picked fifth overall in the 1961 NFL Draft, Ditka is credited as helping evolve the tight end position. He added a new dimension to the spot by taking it from a tackling spot to a receiving one. As a coach, and a very colorful one at that, he was at the helm of the Chicago Bears during their victory at Super Bowl XX.

1962 Topps Mike Ditka RC 260x183 Image

1. 1965 Topps Joe Namath RC #122 SP

There's really no contest when it comes to the top rookie football card in the 1960s. The 1965 Topps Joe Namath is easily the most popular card of the decade. In fact, it's up there as one of the most recognizable sports cards of all-time. Part of the over-sized 1965 set, Namath described how the iconic photo came to be on David Letterman. The photo was taken in a hospital as he was recovering from a knee operation.

1965 Topps Football Joe Namath RC 153x300 Image

ebaysmalllogo Image
1213183299404040 1 Image
(14) 2013 Topps Chrome 1965 Tall Boy RC Insert Lot! Eddie Lacy Bell Patterson!
$8.99
2515038747364040 1 Image
Topps Stadium 1961 NFL Jack Patera Rookie Football Card Dallas #26 M779
$24.95
3604472886584040 1 Image
GEORGE SAUER, JETS 1966 TOPPS ROOKIE CARD #101 - EX
$11.99
2308442696144040 1 Image
1968 JIM HART - Topps " ROOKIE " Football Card- # 60 - St. Louis Cardinals
$11.95
2009461555144040 1 Image
1961 Topps:#59 John Brodie,49ers RC
$14.95
3510291772414040 1 Image
ERNIE KOY 1968 TOPPS ROOKIE #5 NO CREASES (N.Y. GIANTS & TESAS) FREE SHIPPING
$10.00
3107534499254040 1 Image
1966 TOPPS #34 WENDELL HAYES RC NMMT *33768
$26.10
2714557454824040 1 Image
1961 Nucard Football Card #143-Ernie Davis-RC*Vintage lot*Gabriel #166,hadl #117
$60.00
1612751779794040 1 Image
1961 FLEER "DANDY" DON MEREDITH ROOKIE CARD
$135.00
3604309856124040 1 Image
1965 Topps, Chargers, RICK REDMAN, Washington, SP, RC
$5.29
1211162892154040 1 Image
1964 Wheaties Football Stamp #46 Merlin Olson-Los Angeles Rams-Rookie Year
$22.00
1412551022274040 1 Image
1968 TOPPS LOT OF 10 DIFFERENT ROOKIE AND STAR CARDS IN NM COND ITION
$37.50
3107116929154040 1 Image
1967 TOPPS JIM HUNT NM BOSTON PATRIOTS #10 ROOKIE CARD
$6.00
3806848349974040 1 Image
1967 TOPPS REX MIRICH NM DENVER BRONCOS #32 ROOKIE CARD
$6.00
1311661234404040 1 Image
1966 #31 DICK BUTKUS RC Rookie VG EX Great Eye Appeal Nice Centered Philadelphia
$103.50
2714540138144040 1 Image
1964 Topps Football # 95 WALT COREY (ROOKIE CARD) nr-mt+ mt
$7.00
« Previous1234
 Image
Related Topics:

Ryan Cracknell

E-Mail Author | 
Ryan's collecting origins began with winter bike rides to the corner store, tossing a couple of quarters onto the counter and peddling home with a couple packs of O-Pee-Chee hockey in his pocket. Today, he continues to build sets, go after inserts with cool technologies, chase Montreal Expos and finish off his John Jaha master collection. Ryan can be found on Twitter @tradercracks and Google+.

User Comments

  1. Nice list. I never knew that about the Namath card. Is the Gale Sayers card the first one that used the Heisman Pose? That might be a very ignorant question…

    Leave a Comment: