Top 5 Tips for New eBay Trading Card and Memorabilia Buyers

Top 5 Tips for New eBay Trading Card and Memorabilia Buyers

So you decided to enter or reenter the trading card and memorabilia collecting world. Great! Maybe you are a new collector or just returning to the hobby of your youth. Or perhaps you are looking for the perfect gift for the sports fan on your list. Either way, eBay provides plenty of opportunity to find trading cards and memorabilia of your favorite players, teams, movies, TV shows and more.

Here is a look at the top five tips for new eBay trading card and memorabilia buyers. Be sure to register for an account before you get started.

Top 5 Tips for New eBay Trading Card and Memorabilia Buyers

1. Searching eBay

One of the most important things to remember when looking to purchase trading cards or memorabilia on eBay is the correct use of search terms. To generate the most accurate results, searches should be as specific as possible.

To accurately narrow down the number of choices include the specific type of trading card or memorabilia you are looking to purchase. Instead of "Albert Pujols" try "Albert Pujols Topps Autograph." The difference in the number of results to sift through can be extraordinary and save you precious time.

Different sellers sometimes use different terms as well. By using brackets, you can expand your search to include multiple terms. One common example with sports cards is the use of "auto" instead of "autograph." So a search like "Albert Pujols Topps (auto,autograph)" keeps your results fairly specific while making sure you're finding everything you're looking for.

Albert Pujols eBay Search Results #1

Albert Pujols eBay Search Results #2

2. eBay Filters and Advanced Searches

eBay Filters

To save yourself even more time and potentially money, you should become familiar with eBay's advanced search features and listing filters. These features allow you to tailor your search to include items that are listed in several different ways. These can include the following:

  • Buying Format - Is the item being sold as an auction item or being sold via the site's Buy It Now format?
  • Price - You can see search results listed by highest or lowest price first.
  • Timing - How quickly do you need to purchase the item? This filter shows you results that are ending the soonest.
  • New Listings - Have you searched for an item recently? Do you just want to see items newly listed? This filter can do that.

eBay Search Filters

eBay Advanced Searches

The pictures below show the location of the Advanced Search button on the initial search results screen. Once you click that button, you can narrow your search even further to only include items with the criteria you choose. Some of the most popular and helpful eBay Advanced Search criteria are:

  • Sold Items - Want to know what an item is worth or what it has recently sold for in comparison to an item you are considering purchasing? This is the perfect tool. It will show you completed transactions giving you the prices sold for similar items over the last several weeks.
  • Condition - You can often save lots of money purchasing an item in good used condition, versus one that is new. Or if you only want to look at new items, you can filter those as well.

eBay Advanced Searches

3. Is it Real? Autograph Authenticity

Unfortunately, as great as eBay can be to purchase gifts or add items to one's personal collection, it also a place where you find lots of fake autographs. However, there are steps you can take to ensure what you're buying is authentic (or at least have the highest probability of being real).

Check the Seller's Feedback Rating

eBay's stringent policies make it very difficult for every seller to maintain a 100% positive feedback. This is an asset to you as a buyer because it helps to insure a fair, competitive and accurate system. More importantly than just a seller's overall feedback score are the specific transactions and resulting comments from buyers who have left neutral or negative feedback. Read them carefully and look for trends before purchasing.

eBay Feedback Comments

Letters and Certificates of Authenticity

An autographed piece of sports or entertainment memorabilia is only as good as the authentication the item has received. There are handful of reputable companies that the hobby, as a whole, have accepted as credible autograph authentication experts:

  • Professional Sports Authentication (PSA)
  • James Spence Authentication (JSA)
  • Sports Card Guaranty (SGC)
  • Onyx Authenticated
  • Steiner
  • TriStar
  • Mounted Memories
  • Fanatics Authentic
  • Upper Deck Authenticated
  • Panini Authentic.

Any autograph "authenticated" by any company, other than the ones listed here, should be treated with caution or avoided.

Albert Pujols Store COA

If It's Too Good to Be True . . .

This saying has been around forever. It is still true today, especially in the world of autograph and memorabilia authenticity. If you are looking to purchase an autographed baseball of Mickey Mantle or another legend or star player, there is typically a price range that the item sells within.

Obviously, there will be individual characteristics specific to each item that will influence the item's price. These can be things like, quality of the signature, type of pen used to sign, when it was signed in the player's career, etc.

However, if you find that perfect ball or piece of memorabilia and it is listed significantly below the price of other Mickey Mantle signed balls, you have to ask yourself, "Why?"

The picture below lists a perfect example of a listing that should give a buyer a reason to pause. The highlighted ball (second on the list) has a Buy It Now price well below the typical price range of a Mickey Mantle signed baseball. Why?

Mickey Mantle Autographed Baseball Listings on eBay

4. Trading Card and Memorabilia Terminology

What do all the abbreviations and acronyms mean and stand for? Good question. The world of trading cards and memorabilia has it's own terminology just like that of any other hobby. Here is a look at some of the more commonly seen terms and what they mean.

Hobby vs. Retail - Most new trading card products are packaged in two different configurations. Hobby products are distributed to local card shops and licensed online retailers. Retail products are those reserved for your big-box stores like Target and Walmart. Usually, hobby costs more, but you're likely to get more premium items like autographs and memorabilia cards.

Blaster - A product packaged for retail with less packs than a traditional retail box.

On-Card or Hard-Signed Autograph - Today's trading card manufacturers often use stickers for athletes and celebrities to sign. Once returned, they are then applied to the appropriate trading card. Cards that are signed directly on-card or hard-signed often carry a premium value over similar sticker autographs.

Memorabilia or Relic Card - These are cards that contain a material swatch, usually worn or used by the card's subject.

Card Grading - The condition of a card is important to its value. Third-party grading services provide an objective opinion of a card's condition and assign it a numerical value. The companies that provide this service are often referred to by their initials. Trusted companies include: Beckett Grading Services (BGS), Beckett Vintage Grading (BVG), Professional Sports Authentication (PSA), International Sports Authentication (ISA) and Sports Card Guaranty (SGC). There are several other slabs out there, but it's best to stick with ones widely accepted by the hobby. Like certificates of authenticity, anyone can put a card in a slab.

Condition - Cards are referred to by their condition in the following terms. Specific grading companies also use their own terminology in such cases. However these are the ones that are most common.

  • Pristine, Gem Mint - A perfect card.
  • Mint (M) - Traditional way to express a perfect card's condition
  • Near Mint (NM) - A nearly perfect card
  • Excellent (EX) - A card with only a minor flaw.
  • Very Good (VG) - The card may have several minor flaws.
  • Good (G) - The cad is well worn with several flaws.
  • Fair (F) - The card is barely adequate condition to call it collectible.
  • Poor (P) - The worst possible card condition.
  • Authentic (A) - An authentic card without a condition grade.

Short-print - A card produced in smaller quantities than that of other cards in the product.

Parallels and Refractors - A card  produced in a smaller quantity than the base version of the card and featuring some sort of distinguishing characteristic like serial numbering, printing technology used, color of the card, etc. Refractors are a specific type of parallel found in a lot of chromium-style sets.

 5. Understanding Shipping & Handling, Delivery Options, Returns

Above and beyond the price of an item, there is often a cost associated for postage and handling. It's important to remember that for the seller, shipping supplies cost money and postal rates seem to be constantly on the rise. The cost of shipping is listed just below the current bid or sales price of an item.  Often times a seller will offer free shipping but increase the price of the item to help offset those costs.

Unless explicitly stated, insurance is typically not included in the shipping and handling cost. If you want to have your items insured or delivered through a different service than that offered by the seller, you will need to contact them before bidding or purchasing the item to ask those questions. The seller is under no obligation to submit to your request. That being said, both eBay and Paypal do offer buyer protection on most items to help protect both the buyer and the seller.

Additional details also listed along with pricing for shipping are: expected delivery date, return policy, payment methods accepted.

eBay Shipping Costs

Top eBay Listings

2015 Panini Luxe Memorabilia Die Cut Black Nelson Agholor RC True 1 1 RaRe!
$149.99

2015 Topps Chrome Trae Waynes BLUE REFRACTOR RC 199 PSA 9 MINT VIKINGS
$12.99

2016 Dak Prescott & Ezekiel Elliott GRADED 10 Leaf Rookie Dallas Cowboys Doubles
$8.50

2014 Absolute Teddy Bridgewater Quad Jersey Rc (160 249)
$10.99

2015 Panini Immaculate Collection Collegiate #318 Rookie David Cobb 99 Auto 0f8
$20.25

2016 Panini Black Friday Thick Stock JARED GOFF RC #23 50 Made RAMS #63
$11.99

Gustav Nyquist - 75 SP Jersey Patch - 2016 17 Artifacts Emerald - Red Wings
$7.50

2016-17 Upper Deck Parkhurst Rookie Parade Gold #RP5 Anthony Man
$51.98

2016-17 Upper Deck Parkhurst Rookie Parade Gold #RP5 Anthony Mantha Hockey Card
$51.98

2016 Topps Chrome Gold Ref. Kenta Maeda Autograph RC #35 50 BGS GEM MINT 9.5
$249.78

2016 Panini Certified Chris Moore Rc FF Auto Patch 329 499 #223 Ravens Autograph
$5.99

JHOAN URENA NEW YORK METS SIGNED AUTO 2015 BOWMAN CARD #BP98 W COA
$9.98

2015 CONTENDERS ELI HAROLD RC AUTO AUTOGRAPH # 29 49 49'ERS 1 CARD ONLY
$7.00

2014 Panini Classics Significant Sigs RC BAT AUTO ROUGNED ODOR RANGERS 23 25 RC
$29.99

2016 Donruss #356 Carson Wentz RR RC Lot of 2 Eagles B00 1015
$7.80

2015 Topps Chrome Melvin Gordon PURPLE REFRACTOR RC #105 PSA 9 MINT CHARGERS
$12.99
« Previous1234

Related Topics: |

Rob Bertrand

E-Mail Author | 
Rob is a former member of The Cardboard Connection Writing Staff and co-host of Cardboard Connection Radio.He is an avid collector with over 20 years of active experience in the hobby.

User Comments

  1. Looking through your authenticator list, I wanted to point out one very big mistaken inclusion and one which should be stated.

    JSA is well known for a lot of mistaken authentications as well as false rejections. Take a look at the backlash faced by Mounted Memories/Schwartz when they used JSA instead of PSA as the on site authenticator in the autograph area. In short, JSA’s paper may be worth a slight upgrade from Scott to Charmin toilet paper.

    The one you are missing is Schwartz Sports. They are the Chicago base of Mounted Memories/Fanatics. If you do mail order or eBay through them/MM, they very likely will be the sticker & small card attached to your item. Before the family merged with MM, they ran the Chicago area for close to a decade (they still do all of the logistics for the auto area) and in my dealings with Brian and his brothers they have always come across as standup guys. ALSO, I’ve yet to have a single item rejected by PSA.

    If you are buying something with a PSA on-site authentication record ask for the seller to produce a ticket stub or other proof that he actually had it signed there. Mounted Memories has made the Chicago autograph area way too easy for fake autos of those there to be run through the PSA and be given the authentication without even a second thought.

    Another thing I do all the time when looking for throwbacks or just something to throw up on the wall (not as an investment) is buy autos on mini helmets I want to add to my collection and whose price is within $5-10 of the item without auto. I’ve done that recently with throwback Patriots and Oilers helmets. I’ve also bought B-list signed (Hank Blalock and such) bats at the Chicago shows where the cost was almost identical to what the bat sells for unsigned.

    Leave a Comment:

MENU