Ryan Howard's Record HR Ball Subject of Dispute Between Fan, Team

Ryan Howard’s Record HR Ball Subject of Dispute Between Fan, Team

Home run balls are some of the most treasured game-used collectibles one can obtain from a Major League Baseball game - especially when they come off the bat of a star player like Ryan Howard. Though they can be sold by enterprising fans lucky enough to be in the right place in the right time, most often they end up going home with the lucky recipient and retaining more sentimental value for their connection to the game than anything else.

Milestone home run balls are different. Fans have become increasingly aware of the fact that catching the right record-setting baseball can be a financial gold mine, and disputed ownership of some record-breaking homers over the last decade has led to physical and legal battles alike.

On top of that, players often want especially significant home run balls back for themselves. MLB teams are accustomed to dealing with these requests, and it's not uncommon for them to identify who caught the baseball and offer him or her autographed memorabilia in order to secure its return.

But even these transactions don't always go smoothly, and it appears that is the case with Howard's most recent record-setting blast. On July 16, the Phillies slugger became the fastest player in MLB history to 200 homers, reaching the mark in 658 games when he went deep against the Florida Marlins.

That round-tripper was caught by 12-year old Jennifer Baldiva. The Phillies approached the girl about obtaining the ball, and team officials said she asked for a ball autographed by Howard in return. They complied with the request and thought the matter was resolved with everyone happy.

However, Baldiva told a Philadelphia TV station she also asked to meet Howard in person and was upset when that proved not to be the case.

"They lied to me and I was like really sad that I couldn't meet Ryan Howard," Baldiva said to Fox 29.

For their part, the Phillies have promised to make it up to Baldiva later in the season, as she has made noises about wanting the original ball back. The team has a three-game series in late September that could offer the chance to straighten out the whole situation.

"Because there appears to have been a simple misunderstanding, we're going to be very happy to make Ryan Howard available to the young girl who caught his home run ball when the team goes back to Florida in September," Phillies spokesman Scott Palmer said to Fox 29.

Top eBay Listings

2010 Bowman Platinum Autographed Relic Refractor #PAR-RH Ryan Howard Auto 0u7
$25.25

2005 Upper Deck Reflections #DMRH Dallas McPherson Ryan Howard Auto Card 0f4
$12.50

RYAN HOWARD AUTO & RELICCARD--2011 FINEST "FINEST mOMENTS" #'D TO 74
$19.99

2005 Sweet Spot Signatures Red-Blue Stitch Black Ink HO Ryan Howard Auto 6 50
$39.99

2011 Bowman Platinum Ryan Howard Auto Patch 6 50 Jersey Number Phillies
$49.99

2008 Topps Co-Signers Conor Jackson Ryan Howard Auto Autograph
$0.99

2007 Topps Sterling Ryan Howard Auto Patch Jersey Booklet 2 10-8.5
$695.00

2010 Bowman Platinum Autographed Relic Refractor #PAR-RH Ryan Howard Auto 2b3
$13.95
« Previous12345...1213

 |  E-Mail | URL
Nick has been collecting sports cards and memorabilia, especially football, basketball, boxing and MMA, for over 25 years. He's been writing about the hobby for a while too, most recently for About.com. When cards and collectibles give him writer's block, Nick spends time editing and writing for BoxingWatchers.com, contributing to SLAM! Wrestling and reviewing music for HipHopSite.com. He lives outside of Hershey, PA (a.k.a. Chocolatetown, USA) with his wife Diane, daughter Beth and son J.T.

Leave a Comment:

MENU