Reviews

We assign review grades to products using a 5 star scoring system, with 1 star being the worst score and 5 stars being the best score that a product can obtain.

Latest Product Reviews

Top 50 Sets

The 50 most highly rated sports card sets based on staff review score.

Product NameCardboard Connection Rating
2010 Topps UFC Main Event Product Review5.0
2010 Bowman Baseball Product Review5.0
2011 Topps Inception Football4.8
2011 Topps Tier One Baseball4.8
2010 Bowman Draft Picks & Prospects Review4.8
2011 Bowman Sterling Football4.7
2010 Playoff Contenders Football Review4.7
2011 Topps UFC Moment of Truth4.6
2011 Topps Triple Threads Football4.6
2010-11 Upper Deck Series 1 Hockey Review4.6
2010 Bowman Chrome Baseball Review4.6
2011 Bowman Baseball4.5
2010 Topps USA Baseball Review4.5
2010 SP Authentic Football Review4.5
2011 TriStar TNA Signature Impact Wrestling4.5
2011 Panini Gridiron Gear Football4.5
2010 Topps Magic Football Review4.5
2009 Topps Tribute Baseball Product Reviews4.5
2009 Topps UFC Round 2 Review4.5
2010 Donruss Elite Extra Edition Review4.5
2009 Topps National Chicle Football Product Review4.5
2009-10 SP Authentic Hockey Review4.5
2010 Topps Allen & Ginter Review4.5
2011 Bowman Sterling Baseball4.4
2011 Topps American Pie Trading Cards4.4
2010-11 Black Diamond Review4.4
2010-11 Upper Deck Series 2 Hockey Product Review4.4
2010 Topps Football Review4.4
2010 Donruss Rated Rookie Box Set Review4.3
2010 Topps Sterling Review4.3
2011 Topps Heritage Review4.3
2011 Topps Chrome Baseball 4.3
2010-11 Donruss Hockey Review4.3
2010-11 Zenith Hockey4.3
2009-10 Topps Basketball4.3
2011 Topps Heritage Baseball4.3
2009 TRISTAR Prospects Plus Baseball Product Review4.3
2010 TriStar Obak Review4.3
2010 Topps Chrome Baseball Review4.3
2010 Topps Finest Football Review4.3
2011 Bowman Draft Picks & Prospects Baseball4.2
2011 Topps Supreme Football4.2
2011 Upper Deck Football Review4.2
2010 Topps Update Baseball Review4.2
2011 Leaf Metal Draft Football Review4.1
2011 Cryptozoic The Walking Dead Trading Cards4.1
2010 Triple Threads Football Review4.1
2010 Topps Prime Football Review4.1
2010-11 Certified Hockey Review4.1
2010-11 Panini Threads Basketball Review4.1

We'd like to thank Topps, Panini, In The Game and Upper Deck for providing us with the complimentary review boxes of their sports card products which made the writing of many of these reviews possible.