Sidney Crosby Hockey Cards: Rookie Cards Checklist and Buying Guide

Sidney Crosby

Date of Birth: 8/7/1987
Rookie Card Year: 2005-06
Investment Rating: 8.0


Overview

Few athletes have had to live under the pressure and scrutiny that Sidney Crosby has endured in his young career. When the entire NHL Entry Draft of 2005 was dubbed, “the Sidney Crosby Sweepstakes" and the press nicknames you “The Next One" you begin to understand why. Instead of wilting under that pressure, Crosby blossomed. During his rookie campaign, Crosby placed sixth in the NHL scoring ranks. Hitting his stride his sophomore year, Crosby became the youngest player and the only teenager to ever win the Art Ross Trophy as the league's scoring leader. He pulled off an award hat trick that year, also winning the Hart Memorial Trophy as the league's most valuable player and the Lester B. Pearson Award, a prestigious award where the players pick the NHL's top player. In so doing, Crosby became only the seventh player in league history to win all three awards in a single season. He was also the youngest to do so.

As a result of his early success, his cards and collectibles are among the most desirable in all of hockey. With  nearly 20 rookie cards from the 2005-06 season, unopened wax boxes are a rarity and quite expensive when found. Because of his success at numerous levels, his autographs, on international items in particular, are highly coveted in the Canadian marketplace. Crosby's game used memorabilia is highly coveted by high-end collectors and command top dollar on the secondary market. A willing signer, he has all types of memorabilia in the market including photographs, pucks, jerseys and sticks.

Top 3 Sidney Crosby Rookie Hockey Cards

Population reports current as of 10/13.

2005-06 Upper Deck Young Guns Sidney Crosby#201

2005-06 Upper Deck Sidney Crosby

The defining card for any Sidney Crosby collection. This short-printed base card features no serial numbering, autograph or memorabilia. However, because of the long-standing popularity of the Young Guns rookie set within the checklist of Upper Deck's base hockey brand, few cards can compete with its desirability amongst collectors.

2005-06 Upper Deck Sidney Crosby RC BGS Population Report:
# Submitted: 1,904
Pristine 10: 74
Gem Mint 9.5: 1,274
Mint 9: 465

2005-06 Upper Deck Sidney Crosby RC PSA Population Report:
# Submitted: 438
Gem Mint 10: 302
Mint 9: 102

2005-06 The Cup Sidney Crosby #180

When it comes to high-end Sidney Crosby rookie cards, look no farther the his card from The Cup by Upper Deck. Featuring a swatch of game used jersey and autograph, the cards are extremely limited with a print run of just 99 serial numbered copies. This highly desirable card can be difficult to find and when they do appear on the secondary market, they command top dollar.

2005-06 The Cup Sidney Crosby RC BGS Population Report:
# Submitted: 54
Pristine 10: 0
Gem Mint 9.5: 8
Mint 9: 27

2005-06 The Cup Sidney Crosby RC PSA Population Report:
# Submitted: 2
Gem Mint 10: 1
Mint 9: 0

2005-06 Upper Deck Black Diamond Sidney Crosby #193

Sidney Crosby 2005-06 Black Diamond

The short-printed nature of the quad diamond rookie cards from the Black Diamond sets, make this Crosby RC particularly attractive to collectors. With foil accents and a great player photo, this is a relatively affordable rookie card of one of the game's greatest players. The card is also available in several parallel versions; of emerald, gold and ruby.

2005-06 Upper Deck Black Diamond Sidney Crosby RC BGS Population Report:
# Submitted: (394)
Pristine 10: (24)
Gem Mint 9.5:(284)
Mint 9: (65)

2005-06 Upper Deck Black Diamond Sidney Crosby RC PSA Population Report:
# Submitted: 120
Gem Mint 10: 52
Mint 9: 53

Top eBay Listings

2005 Upper Deck Sidney Crosby Alex Ovechkin rookie showdown hockey card
$12.99

2014-15 ud spx winning materials sidney crosby jersey stick card wm-sc pens
$21.50

SIDNEY CROSBY 2005 OCEANIC, TEAM CANADA & HIGH SCHOOL "6" CARD ROOKIE CARD LOT!
$9.99

SIDNEY CROSBY 2004 05 RIMOUSKI OCEANIC, TEAM CANADA "5" CARD ROOKIE CARD LOT!!
$9.99

SIDNEY CROSBY 2005 06 OCEANIC & TEAM CANADA "6" CARD ROOKIE CARD LOT! PENGUINS!
$9.99

13-14 Cup Sidney Crosby Rookie Tribute Phil Esposito Auto 3 10
$500.00

Sidney Crosby Rookie Rc 2005-06 ud mcdonald #51 hockey card graded 10 GMA
$39.99

2005-06 UD Upper Deck McDonalds SIDNEY CROSBY #51
$24.95

Sidney Crosby 2008-09 Upper Deck Black Diamond Gemography BGS 9 10 Autograph
$199.99

05-06 UD BREAKTHROUGH ROOKIE RC Sidney Crosby ONLY 1 ON EBAY!! STUNNING!
$81.00

2005-06 Upper Deck Sidney Crosby Phenomenal Beginning Complete Set Plus Oversize
$20.12

2005-06 Fleer Ultra Hockey Complete Set 271 271. Sidney Crosby Rookie Card
$61.00

★★(3) 2005-06 UD McDonalds SIDNEY CROSBY RC Lot Mint Pittsburgh Penguins
$48.30

2005 05-06 FLEER DIFFERENCE MAKER SIDNEY CROSBY JERSEY
$49.48

(25) 2011 Sports Illustrated SI for Kids #10 SIDNEY CROSBY Hockey Cards
$24.99

05-06 Parkhurst "Rookies" Sidney Crosby
$7.99
« Previous1234

Other Rookie Cards

Sidney Crosby Rookie Card Checklist

Top eBay Listings

2005 Upper Deck Sidney Crosby Alex Ovechkin rookie showdown hockey card
$12.99

SIDNEY CROSBY 2005 OCEANIC, TEAM CANADA & HIGH SCHOOL "6" CARD ROOKIE CARD LOT!
$9.99

SIDNEY CROSBY 2004 05 RIMOUSKI OCEANIC, TEAM CANADA "5" CARD ROOKIE CARD LOT!!
$9.99

SIDNEY CROSBY 2005 06 OCEANIC & TEAM CANADA "6" CARD ROOKIE CARD LOT! PENGUINS!
$9.99

13-14 Cup Sidney Crosby Rookie Tribute Phil Esposito Auto 3 10
$500.00

Sidney Crosby Rookie Rc 2005-06 ud mcdonald #51 hockey card graded 10 GMA
$39.99

2005-06 Upper Deck Power Play #133 Sidney Crosby RC Penguins B65011
$29.97

05-06 UD BREAKTHROUGH ROOKIE RC Sidney Crosby ONLY 1 ON EBAY!! STUNNING!
$81.00

2005-06 Fleer Ultra Hockey Complete Set 271 271. Sidney Crosby Rookie Card
$61.00

★★(3) 2005-06 UD McDonalds SIDNEY CROSBY RC Lot Mint Pittsburgh Penguins
$48.30

2005 UD Sidney Crosby PB GOLD Rookie 6 Box CASE-126 RC-Look for $1,500 AUTOGRAPH
$49.87

2005-06 Upper Deck Trilogy Sidney Crosby RC #211 Rookie Card 624 999
$199.99

05-06 Upper Deck NHL ROOKIE RC Sidney Crosby FINALIST! Close to Perfect Card!!
$12.60

2005-06 UD ROOKIE CLASS SIDNEY CROSBY & ALEXANDER OVECHKIN BGS BCCG 10 MINT+
$16.99

2003 Sidney Crosby Rimouski Extreme QMJHL Insert rookie Gem Mint 10 #87 Rare SP
$44.99

2003 Sidney Crosby Rimouski Extreme QMJHL Die Cut rookie Gem Mint 10 Rare SSP
$54.99
« Previous1234

Autograph Guide

Sidney Crosby Autographed Memorabilia Buying Guide

Below you will find examples of what an authentic Sidney Crosby autograph looks like. This can be used as a first point of reference for determining the legitimacy of autograph memorabilia, but is not a substitute for having your items authenticated by a well-respected professional autograph authentication company. Some of the trusted sources within the sports memorabilia market include the following companies: PSA, JSA, and Mounted Memories. Click on any of the images below to view full size photos.

Cut Signature Exemplar

Sidney Crosby Cut

Sidney Crosby Key Signature Attributes: An authentic Sidney Crosby signature will exhibit several distinguishing characteristics. Regardless of  the type of item or when it was signed, look for the following signature features:

  1. Heavily pronounced letter "S" at a slight, right leaning angle
  2. A dot is almost always present, signifying the letter 'i"
  3. Looping letter "y's" at the end of each name
  4. Jersey number "87" between the letter "C" and "y" of his last name

Sidney crosby Signed Puck Pricing:

Active Listings for Sidney Crosby Signed Pucks

Sidney Crosby Signed Puck and COA

Sidney Crosby Signed Puck Close-up

Sidney Crosby Signed Jersey Pricing:

Active Listings for Sidney Crosby Signed Jerseys

Sidney Crosby Signed Jersey  Sidney Crosby Signed Jersey Close-up  Sidney Crosby Signed Jersey COA  Sidney Crosby Signed Jersey Tags

Sidney Crosby Signed Stick Pricing:

Active Listings for Sidney Crosby Signed Sticks

Sidney Crosby Signed Stick  Sidney Crosby Signed Stick Close-up  Sidney Crosby Signed Stick COA Sticker  Sidney Crosby Signed Stick Model

Sidney Crosby Signed 8x10 Pricing:

Active Listings for Sidney Crosby Signed Photographs

Sidney Crosby Signed Photo 2  Sidney Crosby Signed Photo Closeup  Sidney Crosby Signed Photo 3  Sidney Crosby Signed Photo

Top eBay Listings

Sidney Crosby Signed Framed Olympic 18x24 Photo Display JSA Team Canada
$269.99

Sidney Crosby Autographed Signed ESPN Magazine Cover Penguins PSA DNA #Q89387
$149.00

Sidney Crosby Autographed Signed Pittsburgh Penguins 8x10 Photograph (JSA)
$114.95

Sidney Crosby Signed Sports Illustrated Magazine JSA Authenicated Go Penguins 1A
$249.99

2011 Stanley Cup Finals Sidney Crosby PITTSBURGH PENGUINS Signed Ticket PSA DNA
$279.99

Sidney Crosby Signed Framed 11x14 Photo Poster Penguins JSA
$179.99

Sidney Crosby Signed Pittsburgh Penquins 11x14#3 in person. JSA CERTIFIED
$125.00

Sidney Crosby Signed SI Pittsburgh Penquins 11x14 #4 in person. JSA CERTIFIED
$125.00

Sidney Crosby Signed Pittsburgh Penquins SI 11x14#2 in person. JSA CERTIFIED
$150.00

SIDNEY CROSBY SIGNED PITTSBURGH PENGUINS STICK JSA LOA AUTHENTICATED X38266
$499.99

SIDNEY CROSBY SIGNED PITTSBURGH PENGUINS STICK PSA DNA AUTHENTICATED
$499.99

Sidney Crosby Signed September 2005 Beckett Hockey Magazine JSA COA #E74064
$149.99

SIDNEY CROSBY AUTOGRAPHED SIGNED NHL PITTSBURGH PENGUINS PSA DNA 8X10 PHOTO
$175.00

Steiner Sports Sidney Crosby Penguins Signed Framed 16x20 "Overhead vs Brodeur"
$934.99

Steiner Sports Sidney Crosby Penguins Signed Framed 8x10 "Slapshot"
$579.99

Sidney Crosby PITTSBURGH PENGUINS Signed 8x10 PSA DNA
$199.99
« Previous1234

Fan Shop

Sidney Crosby Fan Shop Apparel and Souvenir Guide

When it comes to team and player loyalty, NHL fans proudly display their colors with everything from jerseys, to outwear, wall decor, collectibles and everything in between. Fans of "Sid the Kid" are no different. With a wide variety of jersey styles and apparel to choose from, we'll help you pick the stuff that's right for you. Having played his entire young career as a member of the Pittsburgh Penguins, Sidney Crosby fans can sport a jersey with one of the coolest logos in all of sports. In addition, Crosby has been a member of several Canadian National teams, providing his fans north of the border plenty of gear to sport as well.

Jerseys and Apparel

Manufacturers: Reebok, CCM, Nike

Reebok is currently the officially licensed provider for NHL jerseys. Their top of the line EDGE Authentic jersey is just like what the pros wear which includes an authentic fight strap sewn into the jersey. It's made of  a water repellant,250-gram double-knit polyester spandex fabric. Each jersey features sewn twill numbers, names, patches and team logos. They also include the NHL shield sewn on the bottom of the front collar, and the Reebok name embroidered on the back of the neck.

The Reebok Premier jersey is made of a tight weave mesh fabric and features tackle twill letters, numbers, logos and patches. The Reebok logo is embroidered and the collar is a soft rib-knit. Both jerseys are available in home, road and third jersey alternate varieties, the Premier jersey is a detailed replica of the the ones the pros wear.

Sidney Crosby Road Jersey  Sidney Crosby Home Jersey  Sidney Crosby Alternate Jersey  Sidney Crosby Team Canada

Bobbleheads and Figures

No superstar these days can avoid be rendered in 3D figure or bobblehead. Sidney Crosby is no different. Several companies have produced figures and bobble of "Sid the Kid" through the years, with some of the more common manufactures listed below.

Manufacturers: (Figures) - Upper Deck, McFarlane, Lego (Bobbleheads) - Forever Collectibles, Fanatics, SGA

Sidney Crosby McFarlane Penguins  Sidney Crosby All Star Vinyl      Sid Crosby McFarlane Team Canada  Sidney Crosby Bobblehead

Photographs, Posters and Prints

With amazing speed, dizzying stick-handling skills and an award winning smile, Sidney Crosby is of the subject of interest for photographers wherever he goes. As such, Crosby has a wide array of wall decor and images available to dress up any man-cave, office or child's room. Available as photos only, posters, framed and matted pieces and more, you'll be sure to find a bragging rights piece for the Crosby fan in your life. Some of the more notable rights holders are listed below.

Rights Holders: PhotoFile, Photomint, Frameworth, Highland Mint

Sidney Crosby Photo 2  Sidney Crosby Poster     Sidney Crosby Framed  Sidney Crosby Photo 3

Top eBay Listings

SIDNEY CROSBY #87 PITTSBURGH PENGUINS WHITE AUTHENTIC AWAY JERSEY sz 56 used
$225.87

SIDNEY CROSBY Pittsburgh Penguins White Away Authentic Jersey with SC Patch
$79.99

SIDNEY CROSBY FATHEAD Throwback Jersey Lifesize 3'8"x6'5" REAL BIG Penguins+Xtra
$85.99

New Sidney Crosby Small Adult Jersey
$90.00

Sidney Crosby NHL Pitsburgh Penguins Youth Jersey #87 NWT Sz Lg Xlg Winter Auth
$92.07

Sidney Crosby Pittsburgh Penguins Black Hoodie Jersey
$149.99

SIDNEY CROSBY*87*PITTSBURGH PENGUINS*NHL Youth L XL*REEBOK*Home Hockey Jersey*
$60.00

2005-06 Upper Deck Sidney Crosby Rookie Threads Jersey Card Graded Gem Mint 10
$149.99

Sidney Crosby Framed 87 Jersey "Numbers Collection" Photo UpperDeck
$85.00

Reebok authentic nhl stitched sidney crosby black ice jersey (nw ot) size 50
$80.00

#87 Sidney Crosby Pittsburgh Penguins White XL Reebok Jersey
$84.99

Authentic Pro CCM SIDNEY CROSBY Pittsburgh Penguins Jersey: sz 52, Fightstrap
$199.99
« Previous12345

Resources

Don't miss our other Sidney Crosby card and memorabilia guides:

For general information and player statistics visit:

 


 |  E-Mail Author | 
Rob Bertrand is an avid collector with over 20 years of active experience in the hobby. He is one of the site's most accomplished writers, as well as the co-host of Cardboard Connection Radio. You can follow him on Twitter @VOTC.

User Comments

  1. Hi I have a where is sidney icon card out of 50. I have limited to info on this card. Its from 05 06 upperdeck

  2. what is the value of a pristine upper deck Sidney Crosby mvp signed in gold 2012 and 2013 hockey season and the card number is 37..please and thanks

    jon

    Leave a Comment:

MENU