Mark McGwire Cards, Rookie Card and Autographed Memorabilia Guide

Mark McGwire

Date of Birth: 10/1/1963
Rookie Card Year: 1985
Investment Rating: 6.5


Overview

Mark McGwire cards and autographed memorabilia once ruled the hobby. Unfortunately, the values of his cards and memorabilia fell with his public reputation. Allegations of PED use severely tainted his record-breaking season of 1998 when he became the single-season home run king, even if his reign was short-lived.

McGwire's lone rookie card is in 1985 Topps Baseball. The card features McGwire as a member of Team USA's 1984 Olympic team. A Tiffany version of the card featuring glossy card stock, was also produced. Player collectors are also fond of McGwire's minor league card, 1985 Chong Modesto A's.

McGwire's rise to superstar status paralleled the introduction of memorabilia and autographed cards. Mark McGwire's first memorabilia card was included in 1999 Upper Deck Black Diamond product as part of the Piece of History insert set. In 2002, Upper Deck signed an exclusive agreement with McGwire that would bring the first certified Mark McGwire autograph cards. Although he was featured extensively in their products, his signature is still considered quite rare.

At the height of McGwire's popularity, the cost of his autographed memorabilia was astronomical. Single-signed baseballs, bats and jerseys routinely sold for $500 to $3,500. Once he became a member of the 500 Home Run Club, the demand for his signature on multi-signed items increased significantly. Often McGwire would refuse to sign such items. So those authentic 500 Home Run Club pieces that did have his signature quickly escalated in value.

Since his congressional hearing on PEDs, McGwire has shunned the limelight and does not participate in autograph signing events. In late 2013, Topps announced that they had signed an autographed deal with the slugger for many of its 2014 products. These are his first signed MLB-licensed cards since 2003.

Top Mark McGwire Cards

1985 Topps Mark McGwire RC #401

1985 Topps Baseball Mark McGwire RC #401

During it's heyday, this card sold for well into the four figures with a high grade from PSA or BGS. How the mighty have fallen. Today it can be found for a small fraction that. Raw copies are easily found for under $20 and it's unlikely it'll ever rebound. This card is still on of the most iconic rookie cards of the 1980s. It often appeared in mainstream news coverage about the hobby during McGwire's pursuit of the home run record.

1985 Chong Modesto A's Mark McGwire #17

1985 Modesto Mark McGwire 1985 Chong Modesto A's Mark McGwire Error

The 1985 Chong Modesto Mark McGwire has two versions. One has his last name spelled correctly. An error version uses the common mistake, "McGuire." The misspelled version can still sell in the $150 range. However, this reflects a significant decrease in value from where it once was. Both cards have  been copied and reprinted significantly over the years, further dragging values down. If you're looking for this minor league gem, opting for a professionally graded card that has been authenticated by a reputable third-party  service like SGC, BCG, or PSA is highly recommended.

1985 Topps Tiffany Mark McGwire #401

1985 Topps Tiffany Mark McGwire

Topps Tiffany cards were only available in factory set form. The sets themselves are easy to spot as they come in distinct royal blue boxes. But once they're opening, the differences are a little less obvious. Topps Tiffany cards are printed on a thicker card stock with a high-gloss finish. Much more rare, the 1985 Topps Tiffany Mark McGwire commands a significant premium over the base version.

2002 SP Authentic Chirography Mark McGwire #MM Autograph #/50

2002 SP Authentic Chirography Mark McGwire Auto

One of several cards McGwire has in the product, autographs from the Chirography subset, have always been popular with collectors. The regular version of the card is numbered to 50 while a Gold parallel is limited to 25 copies. Other than the numbering, there is very little difference between the two.

Top eBay Listings

1988 Topps #3 Mark McGwire with WHITE TRIANGLE RC Rookie Card PSA 10 Gem Mint
$11.25

2002 TOPPS HERITAGE #36 MARK MCGWIRE
$5.00

2015 Topps Gypsy Queen Mini Box Variations #37 Mark McGwire
$6.25

1985 Chong Modesto A's Mark McGwire #17 PSA GEM MINT 10 ROOKIE Oakland
$37.95

1996 Finest Refractor Mark McGwire #74 RARE
$60.00

Jose Canseco Autographed 1987 Leaf #40 w Mark McGwire
$19.95

24K Gold Home Run Record Breakers 1998 Mark McGwire (COA & CASES)
$5.00

Mark McGwire Starting Line Up 1989
$5.00

1999 UPPER DECK IONIX #N9 MARK MCGWIRE NITRO ST. LOUIS CARDINALS
$5.21

1987 TOPPS Rack Pack Baseball Unopened Mark McGwire RC Showing
$5.00

1999 AVON EXCLUSIVE MARK MCGWIRE RAWLINGS BALL TO COMMEMORATIVE 70 HRS
$5.00

MARK McGWIRE RICK ANKIEL Game Worn Jersey Upper Deck 2000
$20.00

1998 Fleer Tradition Diamond Tribute #6DT Mark McGwire St. Louis Cardinals 2u3
$24.25

2016 Topps 65th Anniversary Buybacks Rare Blue #1988-580 Mark McGwire Card 2a5
$30.25

1988 DONRUSS MARK MCGWIRE #256 EX-NM LOT OF 50
$20.00

1999 Mark McGwire MLBA Gold Card St Louis Cardinals
$19.49
« Previous1234

Autograph Guide

Mark McGwire Autographed Memorabilia Buying Guide

Below you will find an example of what Mark McGwire's authentic signature looks like. This can be used as a first point of reference for determining the legitimacy of autograph memorabilia, but is not a substitute for having your items authenticated by a well-respected professional autograph authentication companySome of the trusted sources within the sports memorabilia market include the following companies: PSA, JSA, Steiner, Mounted Memories and Tristar. Click on any of the images below to view full size photos.

Mark McGwire Cut Signature Exemplar

Mark McGwire Signature Example

Mark McGwire Key Signature Attributes: An authentic Mark McGwire signature autograph will exhibit several distinguishing characteristics. Regardless of  the type of item or when it was signed, look for the following signature features:

  1. A very hard to decipher signature in terms of letter-by-letter analysis.
  2. The signature consists of several looping letters and rounded lines, written on an even horizontal plane.
  3. The first character looks like a backwards and over-sized "r."
  4. The next character looks like a lover case cursive "l," which is followed by a larger more oval-shaped letter.
  5. A smaller version of the "r" shape intersects the larger oval "l" shape.
  6. Next is a small looking 's" shape, with a large tear-drop shaped loop below the horizontal plane.
  7. A near horizontal line extends to the right and finished the name.
  8. McGwire items are often found with numerous inscriptions.

Mark McGwire Signed Baseball Pricing

Active Listings for McGwire Signed Baseballs

Mark McGwire Signed Baseball 1 Mark McGwire Signed Baseball 2

Mark McGwire Signed Bat Pricing

Active Listings for Mark McGwire Signed Bats

Mark McGwire Signed Bat

Mark McGwire Signed Jersey Pricing

Active Listings for Mark McGwire Signed Jerseys

Mark McGwire signed Jersey 1 Mark McGwire signed Jersey 2

 

Mark McGwire Signed Photograph Pricing

Active Listings for Mark McGwire Signed Photographs

Mark McGwire Signed Photo

Top eBay Listings

Cardinals Mark Mcgwire Signed Authentic 11X14 Photo Autographed PSA DNA #U59073
$119.99

1998 Mark Mcgwire Signed Autographed Game Used National League Baseball JSA COA
$159.99

Mark McGwire Autographed Signed Game Used OMiLB Baseball Global (GAI) COA A's
$74.99

MARK McGWIRE SIGNED 8X10 DONRUSS PHOTO CARD MLB A'S AUTOGRAPH PSA DNA COA
$69.99

Mark McGwire Cardinals 23x29 Lithograph Signed Auto Autograph PSA DNA T26623
$179.00

Mark McGwire Signed Color 8x10 Photo PSA DNA Auto Autograph *7883
$59.00

Mark McGwire Signed Mother's Cookies 4 Card Uncut Sheet Strip PSA DNA Auto *7898
$39.00

Mark McGwire signed 16x20 with JSA Certificaton St. Louis Cardnials
$150.00

Mark McGwire Signed 3x5 Index Card PSA Beautiful!
$35.00

MARK MCGWIRE SIGNED ST. LOUIS CARDINALS #25 JERSEY HOF JSA LOA
$249.99

MARK McGWIRE SIGNED AUTOGRAPH SPORTS ILLUSTRATED 1998 COMMEMORATIVE MAGAZINE JSA
$103.96

MARK McGWIRE SIGNED AUTOGRAPH SPORTS ILLUSTRATED 1998 70th HOME RUN MAGAZINE JSA
$103.96

MARK MCGWIRE SIGNED JSA CERTIFIED 8X10 PHOTO AUTHENTIC AUTOGRAPH
$67.50

MARK MCGWIRE SIGNED JSA 1988 SPORTS ILLUSTRATED AUTHENTIC AUTOGRAPH
$67.49

1987 Mother's Cookies Mark McGwire PSA DNA Certified AUTH #3 Signed PSA 6 EX-MT
$64.95

MARK MCGWIRE SIGNED JSA AUTHENTICATED AMERICAN LEAGUE BASEBALL AUTOGRAPH
$134.10
« Previous1234

More Info

For general information and player statistics about Mark McGwire, visit:


 |  E-Mail Author | 
Rob is a former member of The Cardboard Connection Writing Staff and co-host of Cardboard Connection Radio.He is an avid collector with over 20 years of active experience in the hobby.

User Comments

  1. have two framed nostalgia items for McGwire…with the cardinals hard to explain it all but if you want I can take a picture of them and email them to you. no idea if any value at all but cannot find a likeness on the internet.

  2. Great piece on McGwire, though I disagree that his popularity in the hobby has waned. True, the big cards like the ’85 Topps & ’85 Tiffany along with many of his ’87 cards have dropped in value; but this happens in the hobby. Let us not forget that the ’89 Upper Deck Griffey rookie once booked at over $100, it is now at $40! McGwire’s Autograph and Relic cards as well as higher end graded versions of his ’85 Topps & Tiffany cards are still sought after by many collectors. I think many fans and collectors still respect what he did for baseball in 1998. He captured the attention and imagination of the nation and brought fans back to the sport of baseball. I think he’ll get in the H.O.F via the Veteran’s Committee when his time comes and stand in his rightful place among all the greats of the game!

  3. I have an 88 fleer misspelled holographic card… can’t seem to find any info on it at all can someone please help

    Leave a Comment:

MENU