Mario Lemieux Cards and Memorabilia Guide

Mario Lemieux

Date of Birth: 10/5/1965
Rookie Card Year: 1985-86
Investment Rating: 6.5


Without question, Mario Lemieux is one of the greatest and most decorated players in hockey history. Had it not been for injuries and a bout with cancer, there would likely by more discussion over whether he was the greatest. The Penguins legend is also one of the most beloved players in NHL history, making Mario Lemieux cards and memorabilia extremely desirable on the secondary market.

Over 17 seasons, Lemieux racked up 690 goals and 1,723 total points. He won the Hart Trophy as the league's MVP three times and the Art Ross Trophy for getting the most points six times. In 1991, Lemieux led the Pittsburgh Penguins to their first Stanley Cup. The team repeated the following year.

Mid-way through 1992-93, Lemieux was diagnosed with Hodgkin's lynphoma, a form of cancer. He missed just two months while undergoing treatment. Nagging back injuries led Lemieux to retire following the 1997 playoffs. The Hall of Fame inducted him immediately, waiving the traditional three-year waiting period.

And that's exactly how long it took Lemieux to come back. After sitting out three full seasons, he came back in 2000 and played in parts of five more seasons. By this point he was also the owner of the Penguins. In his final year on the ice, Lemieux acted as a mentor for then rookie, Sidney Crosby. In 2009, Lemieux became a Stanley Cup winner once again, this time as an owner.

Besides his tremendous NHL play, Lemieux also made his mark on the international scene. Wearing the maple leaf, he helped Canada win both the 1987 Canada Cup and the 2002 Olympic Gold Medal.

When it comes to Mario Lemieux cards, he has just two rookies. Released in 1985-86, they are nearly identical and both command strong prices on the secondary market. Lemieux is one of those rare players where even his base cards are widely collected. Autographed Mario Lemieux cards are also highly collectible, regularly topping $100, often much more.

Signed Mario Lemieux memorabilia isn't too difficult to find, but it comes with a price. Signed jerseys and photos are the most popular items with collectors.

With his playing days behind him, the values of Mario Lemieux cards have likely settled. But while his legacy is firmly established in several areas, his importance to the Penguins could lead to future boosts. However, these are not likely to be too significant overall. Lemieux is one of those players who is safe to buy but don't expect much movement either way.

Mario Lemieux Rookie Card Checklist

1985-86 O-Pee-Chee Mario Lemieux RC #9

The 1985-86 O-Pee-Chee Mario Lemieux is easily the more popular of his two rookie cards. Its presence on the checklist made the set one of the most iconic of the 1980s. While the front is identical to is Topps rookie, the back has the O-Pee-Chee logo and bilingual text. Expect to pay several hundred dollars for a top-condition card. Lemieux is also on a Rookie Scoring Leader card. Although not a rookie, it costs just a fraction of the price and might be a more affordable option for some just looking for an early Lemieux card.

1985 86 O Pee Chee Mario Lemieux RC 213x300 Image

1985-86 Topps Mario Lemieux RC #9

Topps hockey has a bit of a stigma compared to its Canadian cousins. For bargain hunters, this might be a good thing as the 1985-86 Topps Mario Lemieux rookie card is about half the price as the O-Pee-Chee rookie. It looks nearly the same save for the all-English text on the back and a different logo.

1985 86 Topps Mario Lemieux 211x300 Image

ebaysmalllogo Image
1814664372414040 1 Image
2008-09 ITG Ultimate Memorabilia Jerseys-Emblems #5 Mario Lemieux #5 9
1512383367124040 1 Image
1992-93 Ottawa 67's 25th Anniversary Set, Mike Peca, Shean Donovan Pre-Rookies
3008260739414040 1 Image
06-07 The Cup xx 249 Made! Mario LEMIEUX #75
2715293129624040 1 Image
2001-2002 Pacific Retail Limited Mario Lemieux 149 Rare 316 2001-02 Penguins
2214954799614040 1 Image
09-10 THE CUP Signature patches Mario Lemieux # 25 3 colors patch
3804516701094040 1 Image
1992 HIGH FIVE 5 PREVIEW MARIO LEMIEUX P5 * Pittsburgh Penguins HOF center
2310074980544040 1 Image
3708435839824040 1 Image
3708435840054040 1 Image
2003-04 SPX #176 MARIO LEMIEUX 250 PRO
1513533850824040 1 Image
2003-04 Topps C55 Hockey MARIO LEMIEUX #66 Brooklyn MINI BLACK back card
2010596878684040 1 Image
1993 Pocket Pages Magazine Inserts Pogs, Mario Lemieux, Emmitt Smith
2911914207284040 1 Image
2012-13 Ultimate Memorabilia Ciccarelli Lemieux Messier 500 Goal Stick Rack 8 24
« Previous12345

Autograph Guide

Mario Lemieux Autographed Memorabilia Buying Guide

Below you will find an example of what Mario Lemieux's authentic signature looks like. This can be used as a first point of reference for determining the legitimacy of autograph memorabilia, but is not a substitute for having your items authenticated by a well-respected professional autograph authentication company.

Mario Lemieux Autograph Image

Signed Puck Pricing:

Average eBay Sales Price: $137.22
Lowest Amazon Price: Image $126

Signed Jersey Pricing

Average eBay Sales Price: $600
Lowest Amazon Price: Image $479.99

Signed 8x10 Photo Pricing

Average eBay Sales Price: $101
Lowest Amazon Price: Image $124.99

ebaysmalllogo Image
3902089686034040 1 Image
3902089686424040 1 Image
3506571075354040 1 Image
Mario Lemieux Signed Beckett Hockey Monthly Magazine SI
2911916962294040 1 Image
Autographed Photo of Mario Lemieux and Wayne Gretzky
3808910883944040 1 Image
Mario Lemieux signed autograph auto 2.5x3.5 cut Hockey Legend PSA DNA Slabbed
1911135450174040 1 Image
Mario Lemieux Signed Framed 16x20 Photo Set Penguins Stanley Cup
2011295239854040 1 Image
Pittsburgh Penguins Mario Lemieux Signed 8x10 W CoA
1713876209594040 1 Image
Mario Lemieux Signed 1988-89 White Pittsburgh Penguins Jersey - ReichPM COA
1713876711414040 1 Image
Autographed Mario Lemieux Glen Sather Bryan Trottier Velvet 97' Canadian Mint
1713876716554040 1 Image
Autographed Mario Lemieux Glen Sather Bryan Trottier Velvet Canadian Mint Set
2615131955004040 1 Image
Mario Lemieux Signed Limited Edition Hockey HOF Medallion Collection
2615131963914040 1 Image
Mario Lemieux Signed 1997 Limited Edition Hockey HOF Medallion Collection
« Previous12345

 |  E-Mail Author | 
Ryan's collecting origins began with winter bike rides to the corner store, tossing a couple of quarters onto the counter and peddling home with a couple packs of O-Pee-Chee hockey in his pocket. Today, he continues to build sets, go after inserts with cool technologies, chase Montreal Expos and finish off his John Jaha master collection. Ryan can be found on Twitter @tradercracks and Google+.

User Comments

  1. I have for sale a 3D framed picture of Mario Lemieux, Hollywood series production. This picture orginally sold by Natahn James Corp.
    Any interest?

  2. I have a sign Mario Lemieux hockey stick. Interested in selling..trying to find out what price to ask for it. Can you give me some ideas. Perfect condition.

    Leave a Comment: