Johnny Mize Cards, Rookie Card and Autographed Memorabilia Guide

Johnny Mize

Date of Birth: 1/17/1913
Rookie Card Year: 1948
Investment Rating: 7.0


Johnny Mize possessed the rare ability to hit for power and average. During his 15-year career, he amassed 359 home runs while hitting for a lifetime batting average of .312. He played on five World Series-winning teams while with the New York Yankees. His early years were spent with the St. Louis Cardinals before moving on to the New York Giants. Each team he played for has passionate fan bases and, as a result, Johnny Mize cards and memorabilia are popular with fans and collectors of both clubs.

Mize has numerous cards from the early part of his career. Designating which one is his rookie card has been the topic of debate among vintage collectors for years. Many of the issues he appears in are regional releases tied to various retail products.

His first appearance in a baseball set is in 1936 Pastels. The set is often referred to by its American Card Catalog designation R312. One of Mize's more widely available cards was issued in 1941 Double Play. He has two cards in the set, one pairing him with Enos Slaughter and the other with Dan Litwhiler. Despite having numerous earlier cardboard appearances, many vintage experts consider Johnny Mize's true rookie card to be 1948 Bowman.

Johnny Mize's first autographed card was part of the relatively obscure 1983 American Softball Association set. It is his only on-card autograph. Mize died in 1993 and all subsequent autograph cards are cut signatures. His first card of this type is from the 2001 SP Legendary Cuts set. It is serial numbered to 84 total copies.

His first memorabilia cards were also released in 2001. Topps, Fleer, and Upper Deck all produced game-used memorabilia cards of Mize. All but one of the cards contains a piece of game-used bat. The exception is Mize's card from 2001 Bowman Heritage. This card is a seat relic and contains a piece of the bleachers from the old Polo Grounds stadium.

Being a Hall of Famer makes Johnny Mize's signature very collectible. The majority of the authentic examples found today are paper collectibles in the form of signed index cards, checks, photographs, trading cards and cut signatures.

Key Johnny Mize Cards

1936 R312 Pastels Johnny Mize #17

1936 R312 Pastels Johnny Mize 219x300 Image

These cards are often referred to as "Pastels" due to their post printing colorization. You can see this in Mize's rosy red cheeks. The card measures 4 by 5-3/8 inches.

1941 Double Play Johnny Mize #39 with Enos Slaughter

1941 Double Play Johnny Mize with Enos Slaughter 260x208 Image

This is one of two cards Mize has within the set. This is the more valuable of the two due to the fact that he is paired with fellow Hall of Famer Enos Slaughter. The card measures 2-1/2 by 3-1/8 inches.

1941 Double Play Johnny Mize #99 with Dan Litwhiler

1941 Double Play Johnny Mize with Dan Litwhiler 240x300 Image

Another dual-player card, this one isn't worth as much. However, that might appeal to some more casual fans who are more interested in Mize rather than who he's paired with.

1948 Bowman Johnny Mize #4

1948 Bowman Johnny Mize. 248x300 Image

This classic image was taken late in Mize's career and is considered to be one of the key cards in the set. The cards measure 2-1/16 by 2-1/2 inches. The black and white photography has been a favorite of vintage collectors for years.

ebaysmalllogo Image
1312980608494040 1 Image
1950 bowman #139 JOHNNY MIZE yankees BGS BCCG 8 (excellent or better)
3013167579964040 1 Image
JOHNNY MIZE Autograph Serial #d 11 41 2008 SP LEGENDARY CUTS Certified Auto HOF
1913401037084040 1 Image
1961 Fleer Baseball Greats IP Autograph Johnny Mize
3511758710234040 1 Image
1960 Fleer Baseball Greats IP Autograph Johnny Mize
2514883873794040 1 Image
1953 Topps — Johnny Mize #77 — PSA 5
2011729157824040 1 Image
1952 Topps Johnny Mize #129 EX
1913337365924040 1 Image
2011 Topps Titanic Threads Jumbo Game Used Bat Johnny Mize 99 Cardinals
3610532733774040 1 Image
1951 Bowman Auto Johnny Mize #50 PSA DNA Yankees HOF Autograph Signature
1511115087534040 1 Image
1953 Topps #77 Johnny Mize BVG 7 Near Mint New York Yankees HOF
3214440153094040 1 Image
1993 ASG 24 Kt.Gold Johnny Mize 13G,Monte Irvin 10G,Billy Herman 9G All HOF
1904448202724040 1 Image
2611787147554040 1 Image
1983 Donruss HOF Heroes Baseball Signed Johnny Mize JSA Certified Autograph
1913338436294040 1 Image
1951 Bowman JOHNNY MIZE #50
2011730065214040 1 Image
1953 Bowman Black White JOHNNY MIZE #15
1108378936994040 1 Image
1953 Topps #77 Johnny Mize Yankees HOF PSA 5
1906641551334040 1 Image
1979 Diamond Greats #39 Johnny Mize New York Giants PSA 8
« Previous1234

Autograph Guide

Johnny Mize Autographed Memorabilia Buying Guide

Below you will find an example of what Johnny Mize's authentic signature looks like. This can be used as a first point of reference for determining the legitimacy of autograph memorabilia, but is not a substitute for having your items authenticated by a well-respected professional autograph authentication companySome of the trusted sources within the sports memorabilia market include the following companies: PSA, JSA, Steiner, Mounted Memories and Tristar. Click on any of the images below to view full size photos.

Johnny Mize Cut Signature Exemplar:

Johnny Mize Signature Example 260x133 Image

Johnny Mize Key Signature Attributes: An authentic Johnny Mize signature autograph will exhibit several distinguishing characteristics. Regardless of  the type of item or when it was signed, look for the following signature features:

  1. The signature is written in cursive on a relatively even horizontal plane.
  2. Each of the letters are legible.
  3. The "J" and "M" are larger than the other letters.
  4. The "J" has a distinct vertical line on a slight angle. The top loop forms a backwards "D" shape. The bottom loop forms an elongated tear-drop shape.
  5. The "o" has a small opening in the center.
  6. The "h" has a long narrow loop on the vertical line.
  7. The "n"s are small but discernible and written almost identically.
  8. The tail of the "y" drops below the plane and creates an upside-down triangle shape.
  9. The "M" starts high with a curved line. The second hump rises slightly above the first.
  10. The "i" is dotted.
  11. The "z" has a tail similar to the bottom loop of the "J."
  12. The "e" has a small opening.

Johnny Mize Signed Memorabilia Pricing

Active Listings for Johnny Mize Signed Memorabilia

Johnny Mize Signed Photo 238x300 Image                    Johnny Mize Signed Postcard 189x300 Image

Johnny Mize Signed Baseball 260x253 Image  Johnny Mize Cut Signature 260x158 Image

ebaysmalllogo Image
2611787147554040 1 Image
1983 Donruss HOF Heroes Baseball Signed Johnny Mize JSA Certified Autograph
1411029534184040 1 Image
Johnny Mize Signed 8x10 Photo PSA DNA Auto Autograph S87827
2208131525284040 1 Image
Johnny Mize 8X10 Signed Color Auto PSA DNA
2208131525334040 1 Image
Johnny Mize NY Giants 8 X 10 Signed Sepia Auto PSA DNA
2208131525404040 1 Image
Johnny Mize 8X10 Signed Sepia Auto PSA DNA
2511943951974040 1 Image
3604717675834040 1 Image
2509084821904040 1 Image
Johnny Mize PSA DNA Signed Autographed 1983 Donruss Hall Of Fame Heroes #10 Card
2512548021684040 1 Image
JOHNNY MIZE Signed Auto Basebal Feeney PSA DNA S97159
2011737597774040 1 Image
Johnny Mize Giants Yankees Signed 3x5 Index Card PSA DNA Slabbed # 81991203
2614653628934040 1 Image
Johnny Mize Perez Steele Celebration PSA DNA Autographed Signed HOF NY Giants
2615750868424040 1 Image
Johnny Mize SIGNED 1961 Fleer #63 New York Giants Hall of Fame JSA AUTOGRAPH
3906201797334040 1 Image
Johnny Mize Signed 1985 NY Yankees Envelope HOF JSA LOA Guaranteed Authentic
3610326847504040 1 Image
1308823190214040 1 Image
Johnny Mize Signed Autographed Yellow Hall Of Fame Postcard PSA DNA COA
3008855134554040 1 Image
« Previous1234

More Info

For general information and player statistics about Johnny Mize, visit:

 |  E-Mail Author | 
Rob Bertrand is an avid collector with over 20 years of active experience in the hobby. He is one of the site's most accomplished writers, as well as the co-host of Cardboard Connection Radio. You can follow him on Twitter @VOTC.

Leave a Comment: