Gary Sheffield Cards, Rookie Cards and Autographed Memorabilia Guide

Gary Sheffield

Date of Birth: 11/18/1968
Rookie Card Year: 1989
Investment Rating: 6.0


It's easy to forget that Gary Sheffield hit 509 home runs and 1,676 RBI in his 21-year MLB career. Unfortunately, his name was tied to alleged PED use that has tainted his legacy. However, there are still plenty of collectors, who pursue Gary Sheffield cards and autographed memorabilia.

Gary Sheffield has a total of seven rookie cards, all coming from 1989 baseball sets. His 1987 ProCards minor league card is also popular with collectors.

Sheffield's first certified autograph card is in the 1993 Classic Best Gold set. It is a minor league card that is hand-numbered to 2,050. His first major league autograph cards were produced by Donruss and Upper Deck in 1997.

Upper Deck produced the first Gary Sheffield memorabilia cards in 1998. These include both jersey and bat cards. One of the more unique cards is an over-sized box topper card from 1998 SP Authentic Baseball. Numbered to 125, it measure 5" by 7" and has a large jersey swatch.

Prices Gary Sheffield's autographed memorabilia dipped as a result of his alleged connections to PEDs. He rarely participates in organized signing events. However, he was a willing in-person signer during his career so there is a significant amount of memorabilia available on the secondary market.

Gary Sheffield Rookie Card Checklist

1989 Bowman Gary Sheffield RC #142

1989 Bowman Gary Sheffield RC

1989 marked the return of the Bowman brand and its focus on rookies. Slightly over-sized, the card is very cheap. More pricey is the premium Topps Tiffany version that was available only in special factory sets.

1989 Donruss Gary Sheffield RC #31

1989 Donruss Gary Sheffield RC

Tagged with the iconic "Rated Rookie" moniker, this card features a great action photo that helps make it very popular with collectors. Like virtually all Gary Sheffield rookie cards, prices are kept in check due to extremely large print runs.

1989 Fleer Gary Sheffield RC #196

1989 Fleer Gary Sheffield RC

This is definitely one of the more plain Gary Sheffield rookie cards. There is a Glossy version that was exclusive to a factory set. It carries a premium, but it's still very affordable.

1989 Score Gary Sheffield RC #625

1989 Score Gary Sheffield RC

A very popular rookie card of Sheffield, it was one of three total cards Score printed  of Sheffield that year. However, this is considered to be his only Score rookie card.

1989 Sportflics Gary Sheffield RC #41

1989 Sportflics Gary Sheffield

There's definitely no mistaking the Sportflics Gary Sheffield rookie. It comes with the company's trademark lenticular design that flicks between a portrait and a shot of Sheffield batting. The slugger appears on a second card in the set that also features Gregg Jefferies and Sandy Alomar.

1989 Topps Gary Sheffield RC #343

1989 Topps Gary Sheffield RC

It might not be worth much, but this is one of the more iconic Gary Sheffield rookie cards. In addition to this card, Sheffield has a rarer Tiffany version. Like his Bowman Tiffany card, it has a glossy finish and brighter card stock. Additionally, Sheffield is one of 22 players included in the 1989 Topps Glossy Rookies set that was inserted in jumbo cello packs.

1989 Upper Deck Gary Sheffield RC #13

1989 Upper Deck Gary Sheffield RC

This card was originally printed in error with the moniker SS on the front printed upside down. It was later corrected, although neither version carries a significant premium. While it falls far behind the iconic Ken Griffey Jr, Sheffield is still considered one of the key rookie cards in the set.

Top eBay Listings

2004 Upper Deck Etchings Baseball Etching Bats Purple #BE-GS Gary Sheffield 0k9

2001 Topps Gold Label MLB Award Ceremony Relic #GLR-GS Gary Sheffield Card 0y0

2004 Donruss World Series Gold Holofoil 10 #WS-122 Gary Sheffield 10 Card 0r4

1995 Donruss Press Proof #168 Gary Sheffield Miami Marlins Baseball Card 0q3

1996 Select Certified Edition Mirror Blue #3 Gary Sheffield Miami Marlins 0q3

1992 Topps Stadium Club East Coast National Show Base #766 Gary Sheffield 0q3

2003 Topps Heritage Chrome Retrofractor #THC90 Gary Sheffield 554 Card 0q3

1995 Select Artist's Proof #62 Gary Sheffield Miami Marlins Baseball Card 0q3




1997 Topps Finest Embossed #109 Gary Sheffield Miami Marlins Baseball Card 2l3


1989 Donruss Gary Sheffield Milwaukee Brewers #31 Baseball Card-PSA 9

GARY SHEFFIELD #158 Marlins slugger MVP 2016 Topps Archives 1979 5x7 #ed 49 made

2005 #G-16 Frank Robinson Gary Sheffield Andre Dawson 100 Chicago Cubs Card 3i4
« Previous1234

Autograph Guide

Gary Sheffield Autographed Memorabilia Buying Guide

Below you will find an example of what Gary Sheffield's authentic signature looks like. This can be used as a first point of reference for determining the legitimacy of autograph memorabilia, but is not a substitute for having your items authenticated by a well-respected professional autograph authentication companySome of the trusted sources within the sports memorabilia market include the following companies: PSA, JSA, Steiner, Mounted Memories and Tristar. Click on any of the images below to view full size photos.

Gary Sheffield Cut Signature Exemplar:

Gary Sheffield Signature Example

Gary Sheffield Key Signature Attributes: An authentic Gary Sheffield signature autograph will exhibit several distinguishing characteristics. Regardless of  the type of item or when it was signed, look for the following signature features:

  1. This is a unique signature with few, if any, discernible letters.
  2. A distinguishable character at the start of the signature starts below the horizontal plane. It forms a half-circle before a horizontal line extends back through the left. The end of the line has a small curl.
  3. The very tiny written letters "a-r-y" are visible when written with an ink pen. When written with a Sharpie, those letters are hard to discern.
  4. The "S" of the last name is visible.
  5. A series of two large loops and two much smaller ones are visible.

Gary Sheffield Signed Baseball Pricing

Active Listings for Gary Sheffield Signed Baseballs

Gary Sheffield Signed Baseball

Gary Sheffield Signed Bat Pricing

Active Listings for Gary Sheffield Signed Bats

Gary Sheffield Signed Bat

Gary Sheffield Signed Jersey Pricing

Active Listings for Gary Sheffield Signed Jerseys

Gary Sheffield Signed Jersey

Gary Sheffield Signed Photograph Pricing

Active Listings for Gary Sheffield Signed Photographs

Gary Sheffield Signed Photo

Top eBay Listings

Gary Sheffield Signed Autographed Game Used Baseball Bat Marlins PSA DNA

GARY SHEFFIELD Signed 8x10 500 HR Photo PSA DNA Guaranty Auto!

Gary Sheffield Signed Milwaukee Brewers 8x10 Photo PSA DNA- G64419

Gary Sheffield Signed Milwaukee Brewers 8x10 Photo PSA DNA-G64425

Gary Sheffield Signed G53547 8x10 Photo PSA DNA-G53547

Gary Sheffield Signed 16X20 Photo JSA COA


Gary Sheffield Detroit Tigers Signed custom Jersey psa dna S83382

Gary Sheffield Signed Game Worn 04-06 Yankees Baseball Cleat PSA DNA

Gary Sheffield Signed MLB Baseball Steiner COA

Gary Sheffield Signed MLB Baseball w "5x Silver Slugger" insc Steiner COA

Gary Sheffield Signed MLB Baseball w “92 Batting Champ” insc Steiner COA

Gary Sheffield Signed MLB Baseball w 500th HR + Date Insc Steiner COA

1998 UD 10th Anniversary Preview GARY SHEFFIELD Signed Card GAI Slabbed Auto SP

1996 Fleer GARY SHEFFIELD Signed Card GAI Slabbed Auto Florida Marlins

1998 Fleer Metal Universe GARY SHEFFIELD Signed Card GAI Slabbed Auto Marlins
« Previous1234

More Info

For general information and player statistics about Gary Sheffield, visit:

 |  E-Mail Author | 
Rob is a former member of The Cardboard Connection Writing Staff and co-host of Cardboard Connection Radio.He is an avid collector with over 20 years of active experience in the hobby.

Leave a Comment: