Gary Payton Rookie Cards and Autographed Memorabilia Guide

Gary Payton

Date of Birth: 7/23/1968
Rookie Card Year: 1990-91
Investment Rating: 6.5


Overview

Gary Payton was one of the top point guards of the 1990s and most known for his ferocious defense. Nicknamed "The Glove" for his strong defending, Payton was a fan favorite for multiple franchises. Despite all this, Gary Payton cards and autographs remain relatively inexpensive and make a great budget Hall of Fame addition to any collection.

Shop for Gary Payton Cards on eBay.

Gary Payton played collegiate basketball at Oregon State University and was named the 1990 Pac-12 Player of the Year and a first team All-American during his senior season. The same year, Payton was selected second overall by the Seattle SuperSonics. He spent the majority of his career with the Sonics, forming a strong duo with Shawn Kemp.

Later on in his career, Gary Payton was part of the trade that brought Ray Allen to Seattle and sent Payton to the Milwaukee Bucks. From there, he played for some of the powerhouse franchises in the league, chasing a title. After spending time with the Los Angeles Lakers and Boston Celtics, Payton finally got his NBA championship with the Miami Heat in 2006. He retired after the following season.

Gary Payton ended his career as a nine-time NBA All-Star and was named to the NBA All-Defensive First Team nine times. He was also recognized as the Defensive Player of the Year in 1996. In addition to his lone NBA title, Payton won two gold medals with the 1996 and 2000 Olympic teams. He was inducted into the Basketball Hall of Fame in 2013.

Gary Payton has three rookie cards that can all be found for very cheap. Not as common as other stars from this era, Payton's autograph cards are still plentiful enough to keep prices low. However, Gary Payton autographed memorabilia still commands a slight premium.

Gary Payton Rookie Cards

Click on the listings or images to shop for singles on eBay. 

1990-91 Fleer Update Gary Payton RC #U92

Only available as part of the hobby-exclusive, 100-card update set, this simple rookie card for Gary Payton is the most traditional option for collectors. It is also the only card to show Payton in action.

1990 91 Fleer Update Gary Payton RC U92 218x300 Image

1990-91 Hoops Gary Payton RC #391

Can you hear me now? Certainly a bizarre image choice for a card and likely one of the few rookie cards to showcase a player with a corded phone. There is a lot going on in this Gary Payton card and most of it is not good.

1990 91 Hoops Gary Payton RC 391 216x300 Image

1990-91 Skybox Gary Payton RC #365

Easily the most colorful Gary Payton rookie card, the rainbow swirl would have worked better without the gold/khaki border. At least he seems ready for the picture, unlike the Hoops version.

1990 91 Skybox Gary Payton RC 365 212x300 Image

ebaysmalllogo Image
3507585262584040 1 Image
2000-01 Fleer Gary Payton Feel The Game Game-Worn Jersey Seattle Supersonics
$5.24
3312668742274040 1 Image
1996-97 BOWMANS BEST ATOMIC REFRACTOR #22 GARY PAYTON
$8.00
3010835280784040 1 Image
ITG FAMOUS FABRICS Gary Payton Nameplate "O' #1 1, Los Angeles Lakers
$249.99
3707908648554040 1 Image
2010-11 National Treasures All Decade #16 Gary Payton 22 25 Los Angeles Lakers
$9.95
2612988207974040 1 Image
1992 TOPPS #184 GARY PAYTON SUPERSONICS POP 3 PSA 10 K1439916
$6.99
3012289264914040 1 Image
14 SETS 1990 91 Fleer Update Rookie Gary Payton 1400 Cards Sealed Basketball
$59.95
1413539627804040 1 Image
1990 Fleer Basketball Update Set - Factory Sealed - W Gary Payton RC - L@@K !
$5.99
3904287218834040 1 Image
GARY PAYTON 1999 2000 FINEST TEAM FINEST SONICS #TF15 1361 1500 FREE S H
$5.95
3808540310214040 1 Image
1996 BOWMAN'S BEST RETRO REFRACTOR #TB6 GARY PAYTON POP 1 PSA 9 K1550714
$21.99
2613644082134040 1 Image
00-01 FINEST MOMENTS RELIC GARY PAYTON GAME-WORN TEAM USA BASKETBALL JERSEY CARD
$20.00
2715551601594040 1 Image
2004-05 SPx Winning Materials Combos Marcus Banks Gary Payton BGS 9 Mint #BP
$5.99
3107603473294040 1 Image
2003-04 Topps Double Team Shaquille O'Neal Gary Payton GU JERSEY 40 50 LAKERS
$19.99
3214709143484040 1 Image
13-14 Preferred Shawn Kemp Gary Payton Olajuwon Drexler Jersey Booklet Card 199
$23.26
3214709147034040 1 Image
13-14 Preferred Shawn Kemp Gary Payton Olajuwon Drexler Jersey Booklet Card 199
$5.50
3708476110234040 1 Image
1998-99 Stadium Club Chrome Refractor #SCC29 Gary Payton Seattle SuperSonics
$5.00
1912570043664040 1 Image
1990 HOOPS BASKETBALL #391 GARY PAYTON SEATTLE SUPERSONICS ROOKIE CARD LOT OF 20
$14.99
« Previous1234
 Image

Autograph Guide

Gary Payton Autographed Memorabilia Buying Guide

Below you will find an example of what Gary Payton's authentic signature looks like. This can be used as a first point of reference for determining the legitimacy of autograph memorabilia, but is not a substitute for having your items authenticated by a well-respected professional autograph authentication company. Reputable authentication companies include JSA, PSA, Panini Authentic and Mounted Memories, to name a few.

Gary Payton Cut Signature Exemplar

Gary Payton Cut Signature Image

Gary Payton Key Signature Attributes: An authentic Gary Payton signature autograph will exhibit several distinguishing characteristics, depending on when in his career the item was signed. Other characteristics that play into his signature style are the particular item and venue. Look for the following signature features:

  1. Gary Payton's signature is basically five total letters.
  2. The "G" is more similar to an "8" and followed by an "a" and "y" that resembles a "J" on its side.
  3. The last name is simply a thin "P' and a large lowercase "t." The "t" is normally crossed.
  4. Gary Payton commonly includes "The Glove" as an inscription.

Gary Payton Signed Basketball Pricing:

Active Listings for Gary Payton Signed Basketballs

Gary Payton Signed Basketball Image

Gary Payton Signed Jersey Pricing:

Active Listings for Gary Payton Signed Jerseys

Gary Payton Signed Jersey  Image

Gary Payton Signed Photograph Pricing:

Active Listings for Gary Payton Signed Photographs

Gary Payton Signed Photograph Image

ebaysmalllogo Image
4002829894084040 1 Image
Gary Payton Signed F*CK YOU Michael Jordan 8x10 Photo PSA DNA COA Auto Sonics
$99.99
1510760060354040 1 Image
Gary Payton Signed Spalding NBA Basketball - JSA COA J09977
$99.00
3509668797484040 1 Image
Gary Payton Autographed Signed Sports Illustrated Magazine PSA DNA #4A37429
$59.00
3509668802794040 1 Image
Gary Payton Autographed Signed Sports Illustrated Magazine PSA DNA #4A37457
$59.00
3709757395154040 1 Image
Gary Payton Autographed Signed Sports Illustrated Magazine PSA DNA #4A37444
$59.00
3709757398964040 1 Image
Gary Payton Autographed Signed Sports Illustrated Magazine PSA DNA #4A37456
$59.00
4007461940234040 1 Image
GARY PAYTON Signed 8X10 Seattle Sonics Photo PSA DNA AUTHENTICATED
$34.99
2911377660774040 1 Image
Nike White Zoom Flight Gloves Signed Autographed By Gary Payton. W Box JSA COA!
$499.99
2312212098934040 1 Image
Gary Payton Autographed Signed 1992 Ultra Card #175 PSA DNA #65050143
$29.00
3809415132474040 1 Image
Gary Payton Signed Sports Illustrated 03 05 1990 Oregon State PSA DNA Auto
$29.99
3710948572194040 1 Image
Gary Payton Autographed Signed SI Magazine Oregon State PSA DNA #W66916
$49.00
2011213972724040 1 Image
GARY PAYTON Signed Autographed 8"x10" LA Lakers Photo COA PSA DNA "The Glove"
$44.95
3904403168614040 1 Image
GARY PAYTON USA "2000 GOLD" SIGNED AUTO AUTOGRAPH 16x20 PHOTO PSA DNA 4A22980
$97.47
3904403169154040 1 Image
GARY PAYTON USA "2000 GOLD" SIGNED AUTO AUTOGRAPH 16x20 PHOTO PSA DNA 4A22981
$97.47
3903824116214040 1 Image
GARY PAYTON SIGNED AUTO AUTOGRAPH DREAMTEAM USA GOLD MEDAL 8X10 PHOTO PSA DNA *2
$38.97
3903824117504040 1 Image
GARY PAYTON SIGNED AUTOGRAPH DREAM TEAM USA GOLD MEDAL 8X10 PHOTO PSA DNA *2551
$38.97
« Previous1234
 Image

More Info
For general information and player statistics visit:


 |  E-Mail Author | 
Trey Treutel is an Ole Miss grad and a lifelong sports fanatic. He is a huge fan of the NBA and NFL, as well as soccer, college basketball and college football. As a kid, he collected football and basketball cards. As an adult, he started collecting basketball cards again on a whim, and has since expanded to other sports and entertainment options. Find Trey on Twitter at @datreute.

Leave a Comment: