Gabby Hartnett Cards and Autographed Memorabilia Guide

Gabby Hartnett

Date of Birth: 12/20/1900
Rookie Card Year: NA
Investment Rating: 7.0


Overview

Gabby Hartnett spent 19-years in the majors. All but his final season were spent as a member of the Chicago Cubs. He was an outstanding all-around player and is widely considered to be one of the best defensive catchers of all-time. During his prime, Hartnett was a six-time All-Star selection and retired with a career batting average of .297. As a legend of the Chicago Cubs, Gabby Hartnett cards and memorabilia are popular with generations of Cubs' fans and pre-war collectors. His early cards can be quite valuable when found in high-grade condition.

Hartnett played during an era in which defining a rookie card can be difficult. His earliest know cards were issued in 1922 and include releases by American Caramel and a W573 Strip Card.  The two cards are identical and differ only in how they were distributed. The American Caramel E120 was inserted in the candy packaging while W573 was a standalone release.

As was common for the era, Hartnett has numerous cards that were issued as premiums for various products ranging from candy, ice cream and other food and beverage. One of his most popular cards from his playing days is from the 1933 Goudey set.

All of Gabby Hartnett's autograph cards are of the cut signature variety. The first of these cards was released by Upper Deck in 2001 SP Legendary Cuts. There were a total of 32 produced and each is serial numbered.

To date, Hartnett has not had a memorabilia or relic card, of any kind. The rarity of his game-used material has made the acquisition of such items cost prohibitive for trading card manufacturers.

Authentic autographs of Hartnett do exist in the market and are most commonly found in the form of paper collectibles like checks, index cards and photographs. Signed baseballs are much rarer and carry a significant premium.

Interesting to note is that Hartnett was the subject of some controversy when he signed a baseball for a young boy prior to a game. That boy was Al Capone's son and the moment was captured on film. It is one of the most iconic images from the time period and appeared in Life magazine.

Gabby Hartnett - Al Capone Photo

Key Gabby Hartnett Cards

1922 American Caramel Gabby Hartnett #87

1922 American Caramel Ganny Hartnett #87

These cards are designated in the American Card Catalog as E120's. They measure 2 x 3 1/4 inches. For some inexplicable reason, his nickname is wrongly shown as Dowdy.

1933 Goudey Gabby Hartnett #202

1933 Goudey Gabby Hartnett #202

This is easily Hartnett's most popular card from his playing days. It is part of one of the most revered pre-war sets. The card shows Hartnett throwing from the catcher position. This is fitting because he is well known for his defensive prowess. He had one of the best arms in baseball and regularly led the league in runners caught stealing.

Top eBay Listings

1934 Diamond Matchbook Baseball Silver Border Photo Pin Gabby Hartnett "Cubs" v3
$19.95

1934 Diamond Matchbook Baseball Silver Border Photo Pin Gabby Hartnett "Cubs"
$19.95

1930 Blue Ribbon Malt Premium Gabby Hartnett SGC 30 Good 2 Chicago Cubs 
$197.99

2015 Panini Cooperstown HOF Chronicles Blue #37 Gabby Hartnett 25 Card 2t9
$5.25

2015 Panini Diamond Kings Gold #52 Gabby Hartnett 25 Chicago Cubs Card 1k7
$8.20

1933 Goudey Gabby Hartnett #202 - 'High End' HOF Rookie RC - PSA 8 NM-MT
$1,999.00

1928 Yuengling Ice Cream # 5 Gabby Hartnett (Cubs) SGC 80
$235.00

1937 Dixie Lids Gabby Hartnett (small) (Cubs)
$57.50

1936 R311 Leather Finish GABBY HARTNETT Cubs
$65.00

2015 Immaculate Collection Accolades Materials #21 Gabby Hartnett Jersey #02 49
$49.50

HELMAR BIG LEAGUE BREW GABBY HARTNETT
$30.00

1936 Wheaties Series 3 Hand Cut Gabby Hartnett HOF PSA Authentic Chicago Cubs
$49.99

1936 World Wide #57 Gabby Hartnett SGC 60
$1,000.00

1930's Baseball Postcard Gabby Hartnett Chicago Cubs
$110.00

PSA 8 - 1960 Fleer #29 Gabby Hartnett Chicago Cubs HOF
$17.95

GABBY HARTNETT 2014 Classics Membership Materials MVP #15 Triple JERSEY #9 10
$99.90
« Previous1234

Autograph Guide

Gabby Hartnett Autographed Memorabilia Buying Guide

Below you will find an example of what Gabby Hartnett's authentic signature looks like. This can be used as a first point of reference for determining the legitimacy of autograph memorabilia, but is not a substitute for having your items authenticated by a well-respected professional autograph authentication companySome of the trusted sources within the sports memorabilia market include the following companies: PSA, JSA, Steiner, Mounted Memories and Tristar. Click on any of the images below to view full size photos.

Gabby Hartnett Cut Signature Exemplar:

Gabby Hartnett Signature Example

Gabby Hartnett Key Signature Attributes: An authentic Gabby Hartnett signature autograph will exhibit several distinguishing characteristics. Regardless of  the type of item or when it was signed, look for the following signature features:

  1. The signature is written in cursive on an even horizontal plane with a slight lean to the right.
  2. It displays a pride of penmanship that continued even into his later years.
  3. The letters "L" and "G" and "H"are larger than the other letters.
  4. He almost always signed with his legal first name followed by his known nickname.
  5. The "L" has a distinct formation on the bottom of the letter resembling the number "9."
  6. The name Gabby is usually within quotation marks.
  7. The "G" could be mistaken for an "S" and has a long narrow oval loop at the top portion of the letter.
  8. The "H" is written from an angle that comes up before beginning the down stroke. It crosses low on the letter with the second vertical stroke being much longer than the first.
  9. The "t"s are all written like a lower case "l" and then crossed.

Gabby Hartnett Signed Memorabilia Pricing

Active Listings for Gabby Hartnett Signed Memorabilia

Gabby Hartnett Signed Index Card

Gabby Hartnett Cut Signature Card - 2005 Prime Cuts

Gabby Hartnett Signed Photo

 

Top eBay Listings

Gabby Hartnett Signed Vintage Baseball PSA DNA COA Autograph Cubs Hall of Fame
$1,999.99

GABBY HARTNETT PSA DNA SIGNED INDEX CARD MINT AUTOGRAPHED HOF CUBS
$249.99

Gabby Hartnett Single Signed Baseball PSA DNA
$499.99

GABBY HARTNETT SIGNED PSA DNA PEREZ STEELE CUT AUTHENTIC AUTOGRAPH
$134.10

GABBY HARTNETT AUTOGRAPHED SIGNED PSA DNA CUT SIGNATURE SLABBED CERTIFIED HOF
$129.00

GABBY HARTNETT 1961 FLEER PSA DNA COA SIGNED ORIGINAL AUTHENTIC AUTOGRAPH
$169.00

CUBS GIANTS CHARLES LEO "GABBY" HARTNETT SIGNED AUTOGRAPHED CUT INDEX PSA DNA
$249.99

Signed HOF B & W Postcard Gabby Hartnett PSA DNA Slab
$590.55

CHICAGO CUBS GABBY HARTNETT SIGNED AUTOGRAPHED BANK CHECK PSA DNA
$299.99

RARE Gabby Hartnett Single Signed Autographed Baseball JSA LOA Chicago Cubs HOF
$2,699.00

GABBY HARTNETT PSA DNA SIGNED 3X5 INDEX CARD AUTHENTICATED AUTOGRAPH
$135.00

GABBY HARTNETT AUTOGRAPH 1938 CUT PHOTO SIGNED PSA DNA
$127.80

GABBY HARTNETT AUTOGRAPH 3X5 INDEX CARD PSA DNA SIGNED
$135.00

Gabby Hartnett Chicago Cubs PSA DNA Signed Autographed Auto Index Card 83691659
$199.00

Gabby Hartnett Roy Johnson Signed AUTOGRAPH Cut Index Card PSA DNA
$99.99

Gabby Hartnett Signed Vintage Spalding Baseball PSA DNA COA Autograph Cubs HOF
$2,699.99
« Previous123

More Info

For general information and player statistics about Gabby Hartnett, visit:


 |  E-Mail Author | 
Rob is a former member of The Cardboard Connection Writing Staff and co-host of Cardboard Connection Radio.He is an avid collector with over 20 years of active experience in the hobby.

Leave a Comment:

MENU