Andy Pettitte Baseball Cards and Autograph Memorabilia Guide

Andy Pettitte

Date of Birth: 4/29/1972
Rookie Card Year: 1993
Investment Rating: 6.0

The New York Yankees are a team steeped in tradition and larger-than-life players, and that includes Andy Pettitte. Several other modern players come to mind, but Pettitte joins Derek Jeter and Mariano Rivera as players who have achieved personal success, team success and career longevity with the one of the most famous sports franchises in history. Pettitte ends his storied career with over 250 wins and as the Yankees all-time strikeouts leader. A three-time All-Star and five-time World Series Champion, Pettitte was also named the the ALCS MVP in 20o1. Although he does not enjoy the same values as Jeter or Rivera, collectors still show considerable interest in Andy Pettitte cards and memorabilia.

Andy Pettite only has just one official rookie card. However, this is not his only preferred card. Outside of current low-numbered autographs, some of Pettitte's earliest autographs are still popular with collectors and are among the top Andy Pettite cards.

Demand for Andy Pettitte autographed memorabilia is strong. While he will always be known as a New York Yankee, the fact that he helped the Houston Astros reach the World Series in 2005 creates demand in two markets. Signed baseballs are the most popular items that fans and collectors choose to acquire.

Top Andy Pettitte Cards

Population reports current as of 10/13.

1993 Bowman Andy Pettitte RC #103

1993 Bowman Andy Pettitte RC 218x300 Image

It is crazy to think that this image and card is over 20-years old. A young prospect at this point, Pettitte would not join the Yankees' roster for another two years. Despite overproduction, the lone Andy Pettitte rookie card is a hot commodity. However, prices remain reasonable.

1993 Bowman Andy Pettitte RC BGS Population Report:
# Submitted: 473
Pristine 10: 0
Gem Mint 9.5: 123
Mint 9: 127

1993 Bowman Andy Pettitte RC PSA Population Report:
# Submitted: 505
Gem Mint 10: 108
Mint 9: 273

1996 Leaf Signature Series Autographs Andy Pettitte #182 

1996 Leaf Signature Autographs Andy Pettitte 182  215x300 Image

His earliest signed card, 1996 Leaf Signature Series Autograph Andy Pettitte is one of the pitcher's top cards. Although the print run of 3,500 seems high by today's standards, the clean design and on-card signature make for a terrific card. Gold and Silver parallels add more options for collectors.

1996 Leaf Signature Autographs Andy Pettite BGS Population Report:
# Submitted: 20
Pristine 10: 0
Gem Mint 9.5: 2
Mint 9: 12

1993 Bowman Andy Pettitte RC PSA Population Report:
# Submitted: 1
Gem Mint 10: 0
Mint 9: 1

1997 Stadium Club Co-Signers #CO1 Andy Pettitte Autograph with Derek Jeter

1997 Stadium Club Co Signers CO1 Andy Pettitte Derek Jeter Autograph 1 217x300 Image 1997 Stadium Club Co Signers CO1 Andy PettitteDerek Jeter Autograph 210x300 Image

Combining two of the most iconic players in recent Yankees baseball history, the 1997 Stadium Club Co-Signers card is arguably the top Andy Pettitte card. The card pairs on-card signatures of Pettitte and Derek Jeter on a vibrant canvas.

ebaysmalllogo Image
3505862814204040 1 Image
4007019487774040 1 Image
2001 Upper Deck Victory #255 Derek Jeter Andy Pettitte Yankees PSA 10 POP 4
3214663038604040 1 Image
1993 Classic Best Gold Andy Pettitte Yankees #117 Rookie PSA 8 #21430019
2910685409384040 1 Image
New York Yankees Andy Pettitte 2013 Topps Five Star Jumbo Jersey 16 25
3709110741054040 1 Image
2010 Allen & Ginter Cabinets #NCCB9 Jacoby Ellsbury Andy Pettitte Jorge Posada
2215013112904040 1 Image
1992 Greensboro Hornets Sealed Team Set Jorge Posada Andy Pettitte Yankees
2513703047224040 1 Image
Andy Pettitte 2004 Astros Fanfest Upper Deck JSY
3908916565034040 1 Image
Andy Pettitte Yankees,Cyan Printing plate,numbered 1 1,topps 2013
3609980786514040 1 Image
1993 Bowman #103 Andy Pettitte RC Rookie New York Yankees BGS 9.5 GEM MINT
3309020879984040 1 Image
26 card lot - 2010 Upper Deck #346 Andy Pettitte Cards MINT New York Yankees
1212656288394040 1 Image
2014 Andy Pettitte Topps Series 1 Relic New York Yankees
1912571785324040 1 Image
Andy Pettitte Photo #1
1114150233544040 1 Image
2000 Upper Deck Andy Pettitte Game Worn Jersey card-Yankees-$30
3608488925344040 1 Image
Andy Pettitte 2014 Topps Series 1 Game Used Relic White Jersey Yankees
3908316922374040 1 Image
2008 08 Ballpark Quad JERSEY Derek Jeter Andy Pettitte Jake Peavy Khalil Greene
1413338685834040 1 Image
Andy Pettitte 1998 Upper Deck Yankees Commemorative Jumbo 3x5 Card #170
« Previous1234

Autograph Guide

Andy Pettitte Autographed Memorabilia Buying Guide

Below you will find examples of what an authentic Andy Pettitte autograph looks like. This can be used as a first point of reference for determining the legitimacy of autograph memorabilia, but is not a substitute for having your items authenticated by a well-respected professional autograph authentication company. Some of the trusted sources within the sports memorabilia market include the following companies: PSA, JSA, Steiner, Tristar and Mounted Memories. Click on any of the images below to view full size photos.

Cut Signature Exemplar

Andy Pettitte Signature Example Image

Andy Pettitte Key Signature Attributes: An authentic Albert Pettitte signature autograph will exhibit several distinguishing characteristics. Regardless of  the type of item or when it was signed, look for the following signature features:

  1. Overall a very legible signature from start to finish; each letter is discernible
  2. An over-sized letter "A" starts the signature on a slight, right leaning angle
  3. The pen does not lift and the letters "n-d" are combined so that part of the "n" serves as the small circle of the letter "d"
  4. The letter "y" is visble
  5. The pen lifts for the start of the last name with an over-sized letter "P"
  6. The pen lifts again to start the rest of the signature, with a closed loop letter "e"
  7. The dual letter "t" 's are each crossed together and usually have no loop in the vertical stroke

Signed Baseball Pricing:

Active Listings for Andy Pettitte Signed Baseballs

Andy Pettitte Signed Baseball 260x195 Image  Andy pettitte Steiner 260x195 Image  Andy Pettitte Signed Baseball w COA 225x300 Image  Andy Pettitte Steiner Auto 260x237 Image

Signed 8x10 Pricing:

Active Listings for Andy Pettitte Photographs

Andy Pettitte Signed Photo 260x190 Image  Andy Pettitte Signed Photo Closeup 260x207 Image Andy Pettitte Signed Photo COA 260x272 Image  Andy Pettitte Signed Photo Sticker 257x300 Image

Signed 8x10 Pricing:

Active Listings for Andy Pettitte Jerseys

Andy Pettitte Signed Jersey 260x195 Image  Andy Pettitte Signed Jersey Closeup 260x195 Image  Andy Pettitte Signed Jersey LOA 260x198 Image

ebaysmalllogo Image
1211216215184040 1 Image
Andy Pettitte Sandy Alomar 1998 Stadium Club Auto Signed Card PSA DNA 83409719
2306867769804040 1 Image
Andy Pettitte signed 11x14 New York Yankees autograph PSA DNA authenticated
2813933540334040 1 Image
Steiner Andy Pettitte Signed Game Used MLB Baseball NY Yankees Jeter Mariano CC
1413590244194040 1 Image
Andy Pettitte Signed 5-18-2013 Blue Jays@Yankees Game Used Baseball Steiner Coa
2911815290474040 1 Image
Andy Pettitte Steiner SIGNED New York Yankees 1997 Bowman CARD
2715380781164040 1 Image
Andy Pettitte signed on the Sweet Spot Official Baseball W COA from JSA, USC#240
2309775037934040 1 Image
Andy Pettitte Signed Astros 8x10 Photo Authentic Autograph PSA DNA #Q57233
1909941775234040 1 Image
Roger Clemens Andy Pettitte Signed On Deck Magazine Astros PSA DNA V50269
3214747593184040 1 Image
Andy Pettitte Signed Autographed 8x10 guaranteed to pass JSA PSA
3610040866904040 1 Image
2311134323214040 1 Image
Andy Pettitte Autographed Signed 8x10 Photo Astros PSA DNA #Q94591
3709613023844040 1 Image
Andy Pettitte Autographed Signed 8x10 Photo Astros PSA DNA #Q94594
2311134325554040 1 Image
Andy Pettitte Autographed Signed 8x10 Photo Astros PSA DNA #Q94595
3509508507624040 1 Image
Andy Pettitte Autographed Signed 8x10 Photo Astros PSA DNA #S35654
3509508507704040 1 Image
Andy Pettitte Autographed Signed 8x10 Photo Astros PSA DNA #S35653
3509508507804040 1 Image
Andy Pettitte Autographed Signed 8x10 Photo Astros PSA DNA #S35652
« Previous1234

Other Resources

For general information and player statistics visit:

 |  E-Mail Author | 
Trey Treutel is an Ole Miss grad and a lifelong sports fanatic. He is a huge fan of the NBA and NFL, as well as soccer, college basketball and college football. As a kid, he collected football and basketball cards. As an adult, he started collecting basketball cards again on a whim, and has since expanded to other sports and entertainment options. Find Trey on Twitter at @datreute.

Leave a Comment: