Andrew McCutchen Cards and Autographed Memorabilia Guide

Andrew McCutchen

Date of Birth: 10/10/1986
Rookie Card Year: 2005
Investment Rating: 7.0


Rookie Cards

The resurgence of the Pittsburgh Pirates has been led by Andrew McCutchen. His five-tool capabilities, personable demeanor and work ethic quickly made him the face of the franchise and endeared him to the city's championship starved fan base. Leading the franchise to the post season and being named the National League MVP in 2013 has created more than just a regional interest in Andrew McCutchen cards and collectibles.

A product of the 2005 rookie class, Andrew McCutchen rookie cards can be found in a handful 2005 products. McCutchen also has cards in 2004 Bowman Draft. He was on the AFLAC insert checklist. One of McCutchen's earliest autographs is the scarce 2004 Bowman Chrome AFLAC Autograph, of which only 90 were made.

Andrew McCutchen Rookie Card Checklist

Top eBay Listings

2014 Heritage #160 Andrew McCutchen Pittsburgh Pirates Chrome #999
$7.49

2015 PANINI FATHERS DAY "ELEMENTS" TRUE 1 1 ANDREW MCCUTCHEN PITTSBURGH HOT!!!!!
$19.05

Andrew McCutchen, 2009 Topps 206, ROOKIE!!!, Gem Mint 10
$9.29

2015 topps baseball series 2 Andrew McCutchen Black Border card #47 64
$7.10

2011 LIMITED MATCH-UPS DUAL AUTOS ALEX PRESLEY ANDREW McCUTCHEN SP #06 49!
$17.50

ANDREW MCCUTCHEN 2015 Topps Series 2 Two COMMEMORATIVE BAT KNOB
$14.50

2015 TOPPS SERIES 2 ANDREW MCCUTCHEN PINK BAT KNOB #d 17 25!! RARE PIRATES
$33.25

PSA 10 2004 04 Bowman Chrome ANDREW MCCUTCHEN RC Rookie #AFL5 GRADED GEM AFLAC
$69.99

Andrew McCutchen 2010 Topps Chrome Purple #520 599
$5.00

2009 Upper Deck Signature Series Top Prospects Andrew McCutchen Rookie Card SP
$6.00

2014 Donruss Series 2 Insert Face 2 Face Andrew McCutchen Clayton Kershaw 999#6
$6.00

2014 Donruss Series 2 The Elite Series SP 999 Andrew McCutchen #2 - Pirates
$5.00

2014 Donruss Series 2 The Elite Series SP 072 999 Andrew McCutchen #2 - Pirates
$5.00

Andrew Mccutchen 2005 Bowman Chrome
$15.00

ANDREW MCCUTCHEN A.J. NURNETT 2013 PRIZM BAND OF BROTHERS PIRATES #BB2
$9.80

Lot of (3) Andrew McCutchen 2005 Bowman Chrome Draft Baseball RC #BDP63 Pirates
$20.00
« Previous1234

Autograph Guide

Andrew McCutchen Autographed Memorabilia Buying Guide

Below you will find examples of what an authentic Andrew McCutchen autograph looks like. This can be used as a first point of reference for determining the legitimacy of autograph memorabilia, but is not a substitute for having your items authenticated by a well-respected professional autograph authentication company. Some of the trusted sources within the sports memorabilia market include the following companies: PSA, JSA, Steiner, Tristar and Mounted Memories. Click on any of the images below to view full size photos.

Andrew McCutchen Cut Signature Exemplar

Andrew McCutchen Signature Example

Andrew McCutchen Key Signature Attributes: An authentic Andrew McCutchen signature will exhibit several distinguishing characteristics. Regardless of  the type of item or when it was signed, look for the following signature features:

  1. A very, fluid and individualized signature with few discernible letters.
  2. The start of the signature llooks like the letters "C-l"" but is actually the letter "A", the distinct elongated loop at the top of the letter is distinct.
  3. The next signature characters resemble the letters "c-e-l."
  4. The pen lifts to start the last name which looks like "P-h-e-e-l."

Andrew McCutchen Signed Baseball Pricing:

Active Listings for Andrew McCutchen Signed Baseballs

Andrew McCutchen Signed Baseball

Andrew McCutchen Signed Jersey Pricing:

Active Listings for Andrew McCutchen Signed Jerseys

Andrew McCutchen Signed Jersey

Andrew McCutchen Signed Bat Pricing:

Active Listings for Andrew McCutchen Signed Bats

Andrew McCutchen Signed Bat

Andrew McCutchen Signed Photograph Pricing:

Active Listings for Andrew McCutchen Signed Photographs

Andrew McCutchen Signed Photo

Top eBay Listings

ANDREW MCCUTCHEN SIGNED AUTOGRAPH 8x10 PHOTO *JSA COA* PITTSBURGH PIRATES *MVP*
$99.99

ANDREW MCCUTCHEN SIGNED AUTO 2011 TOPPS CARD #60 PSA DNA PITTSBURGH PIRATES
$99.99

Andrew McCutchen Pittsburgh Pirates PSA DNA Signed ROOKIE Baseball
$149.99

Andrew McCutchen Pittsburgh Pirates Signed Autographed MLB Baseball PSA DNA
$99.99

Andrew McCutchen Signed MLB Baseball ( MLB Auth) Steiner COA
$299.99

Andrew McCutchen Auto Signed PNC Park Pittsburgh Pirates 8x10 Photo - JSA COA
$114.99

Pirates Andrew McCutchen Signed Auto 2013 Topps Card #122 JSA Certified
$69.95

Andrew McCutchen Signed Rawlings Adirondack Pro Professional Model Bat PSA
$450.00

ANDREW MCCUTCHEN PITTSBURGH PIRATES SIGNED HOME WHITE JERSEY JSA COA K27305
$351.96

ANDREW MCCUTCHEN PITTSBURGH PIRATES SIGNED MAJOR LEAGUE BASEBALL JSA COA K42395
$151.96

PITTSBURGH PIRATES ANDREW MCCUTCHEN signed JERSEY PSA DNA COA 2013 NL MVP
$350.00

Andrew McCutchen, Pgh Pirates, Signed Pirates Mini Batting Helmet, MIP, JSA COA
$99.95

Andrew McCutchen Pittsburgh Pirates Signed ORMLB '12 Gold Glove Inscription JSA
$150.00

ANDREW MCCUTCHEN PITTSBURGH PIRATES SIGNED POSED 8X10 PHOTO JSA COA #J56994
$79.98

Andrew McCutchen Signed Rawlings Adirondack Pro Big Stick Bat PSA DNA
$400.00

Andrew McCutchen Pittsburgh Pirates Signed Custom Home Jersey JSA
$349.99
« Previous1234

Other Resources

Other articles about Andrew McCutchen cards and memorabilia on Cardboard Connection:

For general information and player statistics visit:


 |  E-Mail Author | 
Rob Bertrand is an avid collector with over 20 years of active experience in the hobby. He is one of the site's most accomplished writers, as well as the co-host of Cardboard Connection Radio. You can follow him on Twitter @VOTC.

Leave a Comment:

MENU