Leaf Loses Motion for Temporary Restraining Order Against Industry Summit

Leaf Loses Motion for Temporary Restraining Order Against Industry Summit

On February 10, a hearing was held on Leaf's motion for a temporary restraining order (TRO) in its lawsuit against the Industry Summit. At the hearing, basically, Leaf asked the court to allow it to attend the 2014 Industry Summit in March.

The state court judge denied Leaf's motion.

Now, a TRO is an extraordinary remedy so it is hard to obtain. The party that files such a motion, in essence, asks the judge to award it an early win before the case really begins. There's a high burden of proof and the party bringing the motion must prove, among other things, that it is "likely to succeed on the merits" of the case and to show that it is being "irreparably harmed" (i.e., harmed in such a manner that money will not make it whole).

What does the denial of this motion mean for Leaf? Well, that's a tough one. Simply because Leaf lost the motion does not mean it will lose the case.  And the court did not issue a written order explaining why the motion was denied, so assessing a "winner" and "loser" is difficult.

Legal translation: Let's say the court denied the motion, and in doing so held that although Leaf was "likely to win on the merits," it could not prove that it was "irreparably harmed" (i.e., money could make it whole). Leaf then would have lost the motion, however, the court's ruling would be a good indicator that Leaf could "likely" win its case. If, on the other hand, the court said Leaf was "unlikely to win on the merits"…well, that doesn't need a legal translation.

This type of information is what's included in a written order. So, without a little help from the judge, I can't say who is in the lead.

I can say that with the denial of the motion, however, the Summit notches the first win in this battle. And that unless Leaf files a motion for a preliminary injunction (where it'll face the same hurdles), it's likely a foregone conclusion that Leaf will not be in attendance at the Industry Summit.

Of note, a few days after the state court denied Leaf's motion, the Summit moved the case to federal court.

Legal translation: A defendant can move a case from state court to federal court by just filing a piece of paper. And that's what the Summit did.

The Summit's move confuses me. The state court judge ruled in its favor for the TRO. Why then move the case to a different court with an unknown judge?

Sure, there are a number of additional items to consider before moving a case to federal court, but if your current judge already likes you, your case and your arguments, stick around!

Unless, at the hearing, the court indicated Leaf was "likely to succeed on the merits," and he was denying the motion because "money would make Leaf whole."

But now we're getting into the land of speculation. Man, I wish the judge would have issued a written order. This is even less likely now that the case has been moved to federal court.

Ugh!

I contacted Leaf and the Industry Summit about the order, but both declined to comment.

Which is wise. As an attorney, I tell all of my clients to say "no comment." Not just because it's fun, but because rarely anything good can come of it.

Legal Aside: I really should do a better job of asking people for comments. Now, pretty much every time I do, I always say something like, "If you were my client, I'd tell you not to." To which everyone predictably says, "No comment." I better stop doing that!

Anyway, what's next in this case? We could see a little more action if Leaf wants to try and remand the case back to state court, or if Leaf wants to take a run at the new judge to see if it could obtain a different ruling on another TRO-ish type motion. But in all likelihood, the case is going to progress into discovery. Both sides will start collecting evidence and building their case, but since these actions are typically done outside of the court's docket, it'll be screened from the public's view.

Unless a dispute breaks out that is.

So, in all likelihood, this case will quiet down for a bit. Almost certainly until after the Summit takes place.

The information provided in Paul Lesko's "Law of Cards" column is not intended to be legal advice, but merely conveys general information related to legal issues commonly encountered in the sports industry. This information is not intended to create any legal relationship between Paul Lesko, the Simmons Browder Gianaris Angelides & Barnerd LLC or any attorney and the user. Neither the transmission nor receipt of these website materials will create an attorney-client relationship between the author and the readers.

The views expressed in the "Law of Cards" column are solely those of the author and are not affiliated with the Simmons Law Firm. You should not act or rely on any information in the "Law of Cards" column without seeking the advice of an attorney. The determination of whether you need legal services and your choice of a lawyer are very important matters that should not be based on websites or advertisements.

ebaysmalllogo Image
1512440440054040 1 Image
2013 Leaf Trinity Ryan Nassib pure glass blue rare AUTO RC #4 11 Autograph
$59.95
2214520792354040 1 Image
2013 Leaf Trinity Draft Hunter Dozier Pure Glass Silver Auto 25 60 RC Royals
$20.00
2213456287884040 1 Image
BILL WALTON "SPRINGFIELD'S FINEST AUTOGRAPH CARD #08 25" LEAF SPORTS HEROES 2013
$34.99
2713597247864040 1 Image
BILL WALTON "AUTOGRAPH CARD #07 10" LEAF SPORTS HEROES 2013
$39.99
1512440469144040 1 Image
2013 Leaf Sports Heroes Going for the Gold Dominique Wilkins Bronze Auto HOF
$25.00
2713597249084040 1 Image
DOMINIQUE WILKINS "GOING FOR THE GOLD AUTOGRAPH #06 10" LEAF SPORTS HEROES 2013
$39.99
2713597252824040 1 Image
VICTOR OLADIPO "AUTOGRAPH CARD" LEAF SPORTS HEROES 2013
$39.99
1413561162744040 1 Image
2014 Leaf History of Football Lee Roy Jordan Cut Autograph BGS Certified Auto
$14.99
1413561162864040 1 Image
2014 Leaf History of Football Reggie Roby Cut Autograph BGS Auto Died 2005
$14.99
1512440577774040 1 Image
2013 Leaf Sports Heroes Steve Largent ruby red Auto Autograph #ed 2 3 RARE!!!
$79.95
2311478894624040 1 Image
2013 LEAF TRINITY LEVINE TOILOLO INSCRIPTION AUTO RC 2013 ROSE BOWL CHAMPS # 60
$14.99
2011185481194040 1 Image
2014 LEAF TRINITY BRANDON COLEMAN PATCH AUTO 25 SAINTS PRESTIGE EXTRA POINTS 25
$39.99
1213927856264040 1 Image
2014 Leaf Originals Football 1948 Variation Mike Evans Blue Auto 25 Raiders A
$29.99
1114151033544040 1 Image
2014 Leaf Valiant MIKE EVANS Green Rookie Auto Buccaneers SSP Short Print
$39.99
2614113593854040 1 Image
2013 LEAF U.S. ARMY ALL AMERICAN BOWL AUTOGRAPH TA-BM1 BRENDON MAHON PENN STATE
$25.00
1512441278674040 1 Image
2013 Leaf Sports Heroes Base Set Dave Wilcox Gold Auto 05 10 49ers HOF autograph
$19.95
« Previous1234
 Image
 |  E-Mail | URL
Paul Lesko is a shareholder at Simmons Hanly Conroy and the chair of its Intellectual Property Department (http://www.simmonsfirm.com). Don’t hold the fact that Paul is a lawyer against him, he’s also a rabid baseball and college basketball fan, and an avid baseball card collector. Paul can be found on Twitter @Paul_Lesko and Google+.

User Comments

  1. I cannot comment in detail at the advice of counsel, BUT I can say I am extremely pleased with the judge’s commentary at the hearing.
    I am more confident than ever that we will prevail at trial. The only thing that changes is that we seek money damages vs attending the event this year.

    Leave a Comment: