Law of Cards: Topps' Chances for Victory in Its V Trademark Application? Very Small

Law of Cards: Topps’ Chances for Victory in Its V Trademark Application? Very Small

As previously reported, Topps filed a trademark application for the letter V. In any style, format or font you can imagine, as well as for any "sports trading card." It's quite an expansive filing.

To be fair, Topps isn't the first company to file for a trademark on the letter V. There are over 1,900 other filings for the letter V. However, not all of those filings cover "trading cards." Including Topps, there are only five of those. Three are pending applications. Two are registered.

Legal translation: Three want Trademark Office approval. Two already have it.

The first registered trademark is from a company called Ashland Oil. From the registration, this V looks pretty boring:

Valvoline V Trademark Image

It's only registered use is for "trading cards," and was allegedly first used in 1995. So, how does an oil company use a boring old V on trading cards?

Valvlone trading card Image

Ah. The Valvoline V. It looks much better in color.

The other registered trademark is from another innocuously named company: Top of the Third, Inc., which does business as the Visalia Rawhide.

Legal translation: That's the Class A Advanced minor league team for the Arizona Diamondbacks.

The Visalia V is a stylized V, which, in the registration's own words is a "letter 'V' made to look like the shape of a cow's head which is encircled to give the appearance of a brand from a branding iron."

Visalia trademark Image

The mark was allegedly first used on December 28, 2008, and is registered for, among other things, baseball cards, like the Tyler Skaggs card from 2011 below.

Now, both the Valvoline V and Visalia V are what we call potential "bad facts" for Topps because March 20, 2013 is Topps' alleged priority date. Therefore, Valvoline's 1995 date and Visalia's 2008 dates beat it.

You see, Topps is trying to stake out land that covers any letter V for all sports trading cards. The Valvoline V and Visalia V, however, already have territory staked out, and approved, by the Trademark Office in two tiny sections of Topps' desired world.

Trademark attorneys love Venn diagrams to show stuff like this, so, here we go:

 

Venn Diagram Image

Legal translation: Yeah…someone already has some of that property…

Also, isn't it great that Visalia already had their V circled? It's like it was made for a Venn diagram. Valvoline, you need to get with it!

Topps could still overcome a rejection in view of the Valvoline V and Visalia V if it gets permission, and who knows, it might. Topps has made cards of Visalia players in their uniforms for its Pro Debut and Heritage Minors products.

 

Goldschmidt Topps Pro Debut Image

But even if it secures Visalia's permission, Topps will still need permission from Valvoline and the two other applicants (if those applicants haven't abandoned their marks).

Legal translation: Trademarks are in the "use it or lose it world." You can't just sit on a trademark. If you don't use it in commerce, it's gone.

So, Topps' chances of getting the broad V it wants isn't impossible, but it'll be very difficult. I think it recognized this because it also has a backup plan: it also filed a trademark application for VALOR.

But hey, if Topps wants a V, it could just file on the specific Valor V Topps uses now on its cards. And it's already circled too.

Valor card image Image

And it's just perfect for a Venn diagram to show how it doesn't interfere with the Valvoline V and Visalia V.

The information provided in Paul Lesko's "Law of Cards" column is not intended to be legal advice, but merely conveys general information related to legal issues commonly encountered in the sports industry. This information is not intended to create any legal relationship between Paul Lesko, the Simmons Browder Gianaris Angelides & Barnerd LLC or any attorney and the user. Neither the transmission nor receipt of these website materials will create an attorney-client relationship between the author and the readers.

The views expressed in the "Law of Cards" column are solely those of the author and are not affiliated with the Simmons Law Firm. You should not act or rely on any information in the "Law of Cards" column without seeking the advice of an attorney. The determination of whether you need legal services and your choice of a lawyer are very important matters that should not be based on websites or advertisements.

ebaysmalllogo Image
1514063008744040 1 Image
2012 Isaiah Pead Rams Rookie Valor Honor Auto SSP 46 50!!
$5.00
2215449886314040 1 Image
Robert Turbin 2012 Topps Valor AUTO rc 70 SPEED HOT
$12.00
1112422442854040 1 Image
2012 TOPPS VALOR DWAYNE ALLEN LEGIONARY AUTO AUTOGRAPH # 5 170
$9.99
1514102425894040 1 Image
2012 Topps Valor STEVE SMITH Auto Card #d 004 111! Panthers, Baltimore Ravens SP
$13.99
1815279085204040 1 Image
2012 topps valor mohamed sanu rookie auto 50 70
$9.99
1112422594334040 1 Image
2012 TOPPS VALOR CEDRIC BENSON CENTURION AUTO AUTOGRAPH # 127 200
$14.99
3215140344784040 1 Image
T.J. Graham Field Armor Patch 2012 Topps Valor
$24.99
1414083949614040 1 Image
ANDREW LUCK 2012 TOPPS VALOR TRUE ROOKIE 151 170
$65.00
3908239421034040 1 Image
2012 TOPPS VALOR AHMAD BRADSHAW AUTOGRAPH AUTO #D 149 200
$6.99
3809770220454040 1 Image
2012 Topps Valor Field Armor Strength Brandon Weeden Rookie 2 Color Patch #02 50
$14.99
3807034531004040 1 Image
SHONN GREENE 2012 Topps Valor Centurion Autograph Speed # 70 AUTO
$20.00
1713907798444040 1 Image
Doug Martin 2012 Playbook RC Rookie VALOR Jersey Booklet Auto 27 99 Tampa Bay
$38.95
« Previous12345
 Image
 |  E-Mail | URL
Paul Lesko is a shareholder at Simmons Hanly Conroy and the chair of its Intellectual Property Department (http://www.simmonsfirm.com). Don’t hold the fact that Paul is a lawyer against him, he’s also a rabid baseball and college basketball fan, and an avid baseball card collector. Paul can be found on Twitter @Paul_Lesko and Google+.

Sorry, comments for this entry are closed at this time.