Ultimate New York Yankees Collector and Super Fan Gift Guide

Ultimate New York Yankees Collector and Super Fan Gift Guide

As arguably the biggest franchise in all of professional sports, the New York Yankees fan base extends across the globe. With all these supporters, the Yankees are among the most collected teams of all-time. Chances are good that a close family member or friend is a fan of the Yankees and armed with that limited information, we have made buying a holiday or birthday gift much more simple.

This guide is designed as a resource for those that are lost in the sea of Yankees' gear and memorabilia. Collectors and fans looking for a more detailed guide can check out our comprehensive Yankees collecting guide here.

The following list includes a good supply of gift options that are specifically relevant for fans of the New York Yankees. Both broad suggestions and specific options are provided and the price points extend to most shopping budgets.

Top 20 Gifts for Fans of the New York Yankees

Click on the listings to shop for gifts online.

New York Yankees "The Bronx Bombers" Framed Canvas

Featuring two of the most storied figures in the history of the Yankees and Major League Baseball, this beautiful canvas print perfectly captures Lou Gehrig and Babe Ruth in a more relaxed moment.

Lou Gehrig, Babe Ruth New York Yankees The Bronx Bombers Framed Canvas

Derek Jeter New York Yankees "Farewell Captain" Framed Collage

While his professional career has ended, Derek Jeter remains the face of the modern Yankees. This is perfectly memorialized with the "Farewell Captain" collage that features four different images from the end of Jeter's career.

Derek Jeter New York Yankees Farewell Captain Framed Collage

Babe Ruth New York Yankees Framed HOF Collage

Babe Ruth is one of the biggest names in the history of the game and some of his memorabilia can run well into the six-figure range. This attractive collage is more of a budget piece, but still has a premium feel thanks to the Hall of Fame plaque and frame. There are several additional options for Ruth at the link above.

Babe Ruth New York Yankees Framed HOF Collage

Derek Jeter "The Last At-Bat" Mini Dirt Collage

Not simply stopping at an image collage, "The Last At-Bat" also includes a small capsule of dirt from the site of Jeter's final at-bat versus the Baltimore Orioles. Official dirt is a common theme for other Jeter items and can be seen here.

Derek Jeter The Last At-Bat Mini Dirt Collage

Yogi Berra New York Yankees Signed Photograph

Yogi Berra is a New York legend and most collectors would love to own a signed photograph of the Hall of Fame catcher. In addition to the photo shown below, there are plenty of other signed photos available for the former great.

Yogi Berra New York Yankees Signed Photograph

Mickey Mantle New York Yankees Signed Picture

Like Berra, Mickey Mantle holds a special place for fans of the New York Yankees. His autographs values check in a bit higher given that he passed away in 1995, but there is still a decent supply and several versions can be seen at the link above.

Mickey Mantle New York Yankees Signed Picture

Mariano Rivera New York Yankees Signed Jersey

Mariano Rivera ended his career as a Yankee and was dominant throughout. Other than Jeter, Rivera is the most popular modern Yankee for fans and collectors. There are plenty of choices and a signed jersey would be high on the list for many super fans. If that is a little too steep, other signed options for Rivera can be seen at the link above.

Mariano Rivera New York Yankees Signed Jersey

Derek Jeter New York Yankees Signed Baseball 

Derek Jeter is one of the most celebrated players in the last few decades and remembered most as "The Captain" of the New York Yankees. Anything signed by Jeter would make a great gift, but a signed baseball tends to be one of the most preferred present for fans and collectors.

Derek Jeter New York Yankees Signed Baseball

Mariano Rivera, Derek Jeter New York Yankees Photo 

This photo of Rivera and Jeter keeps things simple with a hug between teammates. The budget option would be a great item to have signed or to simply display as is.

Mariano Rivera, Derek Jeter New York Yankees Photo

New York Yankees Original Stadium Dirt Plaque

Older fans are well aware of the original Yankee Stadium which remained in use from 1923 until 2008. Although it was later demolished, fans and collectors of the team can continue the legacy of the historic stadium with a collage that features authentic dirt from the inaugural season.

New York Yankees Original Stadium Dirt Plaque

New York Yankees World Series Replica Ticket Framed Collage

It is easy to forget just how successful the Yankees have been. The team has amassed 27 World Series titles and a fan that is also a historian would especially appreciate this collage that covers all those championship teams with a replica ticket from each World Series win.

New York Yankees 27-Time World Series Replica Ticket Framed Collage

New York Yankees Framed Subway Sign with Game-Used Dirt

With four titles in five seasons, the Yankees of the late-1990s were a dynasty. This subway sign pays homage to that team with a listing of all the players that were on the roster for each of the four World Series wins. There is also a small capsule of game-used dirt.

New York Yankees Framed Subway Sign with Game-Used Dirt

New York Yankees Team Card Sets

Baseball cards are a popular option for fans, but they are not as simple to buy because they are so specific. One option we recommend for budget gifts or stocking stuffers is New York Yankees team sets. Some are sealed and some are hand-collated, but the result is the same. Make sure to verify the year of the card and the players included to make sure you are getting what you expect.

New York Yankees Team Card Sets

New York Yankees Bobbleheads/Figures

Figures have certainly picked up steam in recent years, and the Yankees offer some of the most popular options. In addition to bobbleheads and various statues, companies like Starting Lineup and McFarlane offer an extensive look at some of the most popular players from the franchise. The links below will let you shop specific figures on eBay.

Derek Jeter New York Yankees Bobblehead

New York Yankees Fatheads

(Shop Amazon | Shop Fathead.com)

There are a good variety of different New York Yankees team fatheads. In addition to team logo versions, players are some of the top Fatheads and three of the most popular Yankees are noted below.

Derek Jeter New York Yankees Fathead

New York Yankees Phone Covers

Smartphones are the new norm and can make for an easy and inexpensive gift for a New York Yankees fan. Just make sure to verify the exact make and model before you buy. We have included direct links to Amazon below for the most popular phone models.

New York Yankees iPhone Cover

New York Yankees Jerseys

(Shop Amazon | Shop MLB.com)

Jerseys remain the most common way for fans to display their love of the Yankees. Replica versions offer cheaper prices and fans can also have them customized for added appeal. If you are overwhelmed by the many versions, check our detailed MLB jersey guide here.

New York Yankees Jersey

New York Yankees Hats

(Shop Amazon | Shop MLB.com)

New York Yankees Hats

New York Yankees T-Shirts

(Shop Amazon | Shop MLB.com)

New York Yankees T-Shirt

New York Yankees Jackets/Outerwear

(Shop Amazon | Shop MLB.com)

New York Yankees Jacket

Top eBay Listings

DEREK JETER "UniFrame" New York Yankees Photographic Jersey Glass Framed 20x20"
$59.99

999 MENS MAJESTIC New York Yankees RAFAEL SORIANO #29 SEWN Baseball Jersey GRAY
$69.99

Official Derek Jeter New York Yankees GOLD Retirement Jersey w Patch HOT! Md
$75.00

1951 MICKEY MANTLE KANSAS CITY BLUES minors NEW YORK YANKEES Road Jersey XL RARE
$119.99

Mariano Rivera #42 New York Yankees Majestic Mens Home White Replica Jersey
$75.00

Mitchell & Ness # 44 Reggie Jackson 1977 NY New York Yankees Throwback Jersey 54
$60.00

PHIL HUGHES NEW YORK YANKEES JERSEY MAJESTIC REAL
$114.99

RAFAEL SORIANO NEW YORK YANKEES JERSEY MAJESTIC REAL
$114.99

MARIANO RIVERA NEW YORK YANKEES JERSEY MAJESTIC REAL
$114.99

MARIANO RIVERA NEW YORK YANKEES JERSEY MAJESTIC REAL
$114.99

MARIANO RIVERA NEW YORK YANKEES JERSEY MAJESTIC REAL
$114.99

MARIANO RIVERA NEW YORK YANKEES JERSEY MAJESTIC REAL
$114.99

MARIANO RIVERA NEW YORK YANKEES JERSEY MAJESTIC REAL
$114.99

JORGE POSADA NEW YORK YANKEES JERSEY MAJESTIC REAL
$114.99

LANCE BERKMAN NEW YORK YANKEES JERSEY REAL MAJESTIC
$114.99

LANCE BERKMAN NEW YORK YANKEES JERSEY REAL MAJESTIC
$114.99
« Previous1234

 


Trey Treutel

E-Mail Author | 
Trey Treutel is an Ole Miss grad and a lifelong sports fanatic. He is a huge fan of the NBA and NFL, as well as soccer, college basketball and college football. As a kid, he collected football and basketball cards. As an adult, he started collecting basketball cards again on a whim and has since expanded to other sports and entertainment options. Find Trey on Twitter at @datreute.

Leave a Comment: