The 17 Most Valuable 1970s Baseball Rookie Cards

The 17 Most Valuable 1970s Baseball Rookie Cards

To compile our list of the most valuable 1970s baseball rookie cards, we took realized eBay prices of Topps cards. Many players also have O-Pee-Chee versions that are nearly identical. To keep all conditions equal, rankings were determined based on sales averages of cards graded PSA 8.

Using this point of comparison led to some big surprises. A couple of Hall of Famers didn't make the final cut while several less-recognizable cards not only made the list, but finished near the top. But numbers don't lie. Here are the most valuable 1970's baseball rookie cards starting with #17. Also be sure to check out our database of 1970s baseball card sets for more in-depth information about the cards produced during this era.

17. 1975 Topps Gary Carter, Marc Hill, Danny Meyer and Leon Roberts RC #620

Like a lot of rookies from the era, Gary Carter is pictured alongside several other players. The Hall of Fame catcher is surrounded by three other players that didn't amount to much. So while it's still a fantastic card of an all-time great, many collectors are still probably wishing that Carter were given the same single-player treatment George Brett and Robin Yount got in the same set.

1975 Topps Gary Carter RC 214x300 Image

16. 1978 Topps Eddie Murray RC #36

Although one of the best hitters of his time, Eddie Murray failed to reach the hobby's elite. Sure, there are plenty of collectors who passionately go after his cards and memorabilia, but he's not held in the same regard as other players on this list.

1978 Topps Eddie Murray RC 213x300 Image

15. 1975 Topps Jim Rice, Dave Augustine, Pepe Mangual ad John Scott RC #616

Rice's situation is much the same as Carter's: greatness surrounded by players who weren't so great. The result is a card that's not as valuable as it might have been.

1975 Topps Jim Rice RC 210x300 Image

14. 1978 Topps Paul Molitor, Alan Trammell, Mickey Klutts and U.L. Washington RC #707

The 1978 Topps Paul Molitor rookie is a rare instance where a Hall of Famer is paired with at least one other standout. In this instance, Molitor has Alan Trammell to keep him company. It's not an ideal scenario for both, but it's better than it could have been.

1978 Topps Paul Molitor RC 210x300 Image

13. 1974 Topps Dave Winfield RC #456

1974 marked the first time Topps went for one large release instead of several smaller ones. The key card in the set is the Dave Winfield rookie card, who would go on to be one of the best hitters of the 1980s.

1974 Topps Dave Winfield RC 209x300 Image

12. 1973 Topps  Dwight Evans, Al Brumby and Charlie Spikes RC #614

When it comes to the value of baseball cards, players aren't the only variables. In the case of the 1973 Topps Dwight Evans/Al Brumby/Charlie Spikes rookie card, rarity trumps the players on it. Evans is the key player on the card, a beloved member of the Boston Red Sox.

1973 Topps Dwight Evans RC 260x184 Image

11. 1973 Topps Rich "Goose" Gossage RC #174

It took Rich "Goose" Gossage a while to gain the hobby's respect. But the moment he was elected to Cooperstown, that all changed. Coming from the early part of the 1970s, age also comes into play as far as value goes.

1973 Topps Goose Gossage RC 214x300 Image

10. 1976 Topps Dennis Eckersley RC #98

Relievers have the hardest time winning over collectors. Dennis Eckersley is one of the game's exceptions. His long career, impressive stats and key place on the dominant Athletics teams of the late-1980s and early-1990s, make him one of the few closers to win over the hobby.

1976 Topps Dennis Eckersley RC 215x300 Image

9. 1979 Topps Ozzie Smith RC #116

One of the most electrifying fielder's the game has ever seen, Ozzie Smith translated highlight plays into a Hall of Fame career. His cool demeanor has also helped solidify his status as one of the game's most popular players. However, looking at his rookie card, it's strange not seeing him in his Cardinals colors.

1979 Topps Ozzie Smith RC 214x300 Image

8. 1972 Topps Carlton Fisk, Mike Garman and Cecil Copper RC #79

Judging by the player placement, it looks like Topps had higher hopes for Cecil Cooper than they did Carlton Fisk. If that were the case, how very wrong they were. The art deco design of 1972 Topps is one of the most distinct of the decade and the Fisk is the best rookie in the set.

1972 Topps Carlton Fisk RC 260x184 Image

7. 1975 Topps Robin Yount RC #223

There's not much to say about Robin Yount's rookie card other than it's a classic, just like the Brewer's career was. The memorable design and solo portrait make it one of the most iconic cards of the 1970s.

1975 Topps Robin Yount 212x300 Image

6. 1971 Topps Steve Garvey RC #341

Right now, you're probably scratching your head. Sure, Steve Garvey was the 1974 National League MVP and a ten-time All-Star, but why is his rookie card worth more than so many Hall of Famers? Try finding on in top condition. Then you'll find your answer.

1971 Topps Steve Garvey RC 209x300 Image

5. 1975 Topps George Brett RC #228

There was a time at the end of their respective careers that the George Brett and Robin Yount rookie cards held similar values. However, as more time passes, the hobby has nudged the Royals legend ahead. Brett is one of the lucky few players to have a solo rookie card. The 1975 Topps George Brett is one of the most instantly recognizable cards from the 1970s.

1975 Topps George Brett RC 214x300 Image

4. 1971 Topps Dusty Baker, Don Baylor and Tom Paciorek RC #709

If you took a poll at your local card shop, most collectors would probably take a George Brett rookie over a Don Baylor/Dusty Baker combo. But the combination of the card being a short print and those nasty black borders make high-grade copies extremely valuable.

1971 Topps Don Baylor Dusty Baker RC 260x178 Image

3. 1970 Topps Thurman Munson and Dave McDonald RC #189 with Dave McDonald

Although Thurman Munson's life ended tragically, his legacy and status as a beloved Yankee lives on. His rookie card has him pictured alongside Dave McDonald, a first baseman who drove in a total of six runs during his career. And while Munson's rookie card holds strong values, it's worth noting  that his second-year card actually sells for much more thanks to its condition sensitivity and iconic photo.

1970 Topps Thurman Munson RC 212x300 Image

2. 1973 Topps Mike Schmidt, Ron Cey and John Hilton RC #615

One of baseball's all-time greatest slugger's, Mike Schmidt was also one of the most popular players of his era. One does have to wonder what heights his rookie card might have reached if he were on his own. While Ron Cey was no slouch, it still takes away from the Schmidt's mystique.

1973 Topps Mike Schmidt RC 260x186 Image

1. 1971 Topps Bert Blyleven RC #26

You didn't see that one coming, did you? Although a Hall of Famer, there are several players on this list who are better than Bert Blyleven. One could even make the argument that the majority of players on this list are more widely collected than the pitcher. Yet, here he is, atop the list of the most valuable rookie cards of the 1970s. As stated earlier, to make things equal, cards were ranked based on prices of PSA 8 cards. The black borders make 1971 Topps one of the toughest sets to find in top condition. As a result, those that are command massive premiums because they're so rare.

1971 Topps Bert Blyleven RC 215x300 Image

ebaysmalllogo Image
3215536470034040 1 Image
1978 Topps Ed "Too Tall" Jones RC # 427 -- nice centering
$17.00
1413853350034040 1 Image
1973 Topps #174 Rich Goose Gossage Rookie RC EXMT+
$15.00
2814732846544040 1 Image
1978 Topps Eddie Murray Baltimore Orioles #36 Baseball Card Rookie
$16.99
3810250558694040 1 Image
PAUL MOLITOR (HOF) ALAN TRAMMEL 1978 TOPPS ROOKIE #707 NM-MT
$34.99
3810250562484040 1 Image
PAUL MOLITOR(HOF) ALAN TRAMMEL 1978 TOPPS ROOKIE #707 EX-MT
$24.99
3111038303354040 1 Image
1970 Topps #189 Thurman Munson RC VG-EX 71443
$37.00
3215316090234040 1 Image
1970 Topps #189 Thurman Munson RC VG 71444
$30.00
3215316090984040 1 Image
1970 Topps #189 Thurman Munson RC VG-EX 71446
$34.00
1213057160484040 1 Image
1979 TOPPS BASEBALL #116 OZZIE SMITH ROOKIE CARD (RC), SAN DIEGO PADRES, HOF
$23.99
3109953015484040 1 Image
1975 TOPPS #228 GEORGE BRETT K.C. ROYALS ROOKIE BASEBALL CARD NM OFF CENTER
$50.00
2616285546494040 1 Image
1978 Rookie Card Short Stops Klutts Molitor Trammell Washington, Topps #707
$15.95
3509402027624040 1 Image
1975 GARY CARTER O-PEE-CHEE OPC ROOKIE CARD #620 GRADED KSA 8.5 NEW YORK METS bc
$100.00
« Previous12345
 Image
Related Topics:

Ryan Cracknell

E-Mail Author | 
Ryan's collecting origins began with winter bike rides to the corner store, tossing a couple of quarters onto the counter and peddling home with a couple packs of O-Pee-Chee hockey in his pocket. Today, he continues to build sets, go after inserts with cool technologies, chase Montreal Expos and finish off his John Jaha master collection. Ryan can be found on Twitter @tradercracks and Google+.

User Comments

  1. How about 1977 Topps Dawson Rookie?

  2. michael (ID 62436) » It’s a great card but when I crunched the numbers it was just outside. It would have been there on a top 25 list.

    Leave a Comment: