10 Most Valuable 2011 Topps Five Star Football Cards

10 Most Valuable 2011 Topps Five Star Football Cards

Having been out for almost a couple of weeks now, 2011 Topps Five Star Football cards are, not surprisingly, bringing some extremely strong sales. Highlighted by on-card autographs, high-end memorabilia patches and the favorable afterglow from last year's set, 2011 Topps Five Star Football is tearing up the single-card market.

To the shock of no one, Cam Newton dominates the list of cards reaching the highest prices. The rookie quarterback is featured on eight of the top 10 selling cards. His rookie card, which comes with a jersey patch and on-card autograph, and is numbered to 199 is commanding huge sums. With just a couple of exceptions, the cards have been selling for at least $500. Unless someone supplants Newton as the best player of this year's rookie class, the 2011 Topps Five Star Football Cam Newton will be one of the best rookie cards of the year, if not the best.

Other Newton cards to make the list include rookie parallels numbered to 25, a dual laundry tag autograph that also features Jake Locker and an inscription autograph numbered to 25.

The only two cards that don't have the Panthers' quarterback are a pair of dual autographs. A card with clean signatures from Joe Montana and Jerry Rice closed on eBay at $799. A dual autograph of legendary Green Bay quarterbacks Bart Starr and Aaron Rodgers saw bidding reach $710.

Here are the top 10 2011 Topps Five Star Football single-card eBay sales thus far:

1. Cam Newton Autographed Patch Rookie Card 101/199 - $908.88

01 2011 Topps Five Star Football Autographed Patch Rookie Cam Newton 199 260x186 Image

2. Cam Newton Autographed Patch 05/25 - $807.03

01 2011 Topps Five Star Football Autographed Patch Rookie Cam Newton 25.jpg 260x183 Image

3. Joe Montana and Jerry Rice Dual Autograph 05/10 - $799

03 2011 Topps Five Star Football Joe Montana Jerry Rice Dual Autograph 260x182 Image

4. Cam Newton Autographed Patch Rookie Card 065/199 - $761

04 2011 Topps Five Star Football Autographed Patch Rookie Cam Newton 199.jpg 260x184 Image

5. Bart Starr and Aaron Rodgers Dual Autographs 05/10 - $710

05 2011 Topps Five Star Football Dual Autographs Bart Starr Aaron Rodgers 10 260x183 Image

6. Cam Newton and Jake Locker Five-Star Futures Autographed Laundry Tag Book Card 4/5 - $641.56

06 Cam Newton Jake Locker Autographed Laundry Tag Image

7. Cam Newton Inscription Autograph 13/25 - $610

07 2011 Topps Five Star Cam Newton Inscriptions Autograph 25 260x183 Image

8. Cam Newton Autographed Patch Rookie Card 168/199 - $610

08 2011 Topps Five Star Football Autographed Patch Rookie Cam Newton 199 260x180 Image

9. Cam Newton Autographed Patch 04/25 - $605.99

09 2011 Topps Five Star Football Autographed Patch Rookie Cam Newton 25 260x182 Image

10. Cam Newton Autographed Patch Rookie Card 124/199 - $600

10 2011 Topps Five Star Football Autographed Patch Rookie Cam Newton 199 260x191 Image

And because it's such a beautiful card and was just a dollar away from making the list, here's there 11th top-seller:

11. Aaron Rodgers Super Bowl XLV Football Relic 16/20 - $599

11 Aaron Rodgers Super Bowl Football Relic 25.jpg 260x186 Image

Cards not cracking the top 10 but still seeing extremely strong bidding include more of the Super Bowl memorabilia cards, inscribed autographs from Hall of Famers and multi-player autographed patch combos.

ebaysmalllogo Image
2814157062994040 1 Image
2013 GIOVANI BERNARD TYLER EIFERT TOPPS FIVE STAR AUTO 3 CL PATCH BOOKLET RC 5 5
$43.92
3804174118334040 1 Image
2011 TOPPS FIVE STAR AUTOGRAPH PATCH TORREY SMITH 17 55
$179.95
1108366833154040 1 Image
2011 TOPPS FIVE STAR AUTOGRAPH PATCH AUSTIN PETTIS 046 199
$29.95
3706194700214040 1 Image
2011 TOPPS FIVE STAR JAKE LOCKER GOLD AUTO PATCH S P 2 COLOR 55
$249.00
2212745215894040 1 Image
2011 Five Star JAMIE HARPER RC AUTO PATCH # 199 "3 COLOR" AUTOGRAPH, CD#169
$47.99
2212745229014040 1 Image
2011 Five Star MARK INGRAM RC AUTO PATCH #64 65 (RPA) AUTOGRAPH, SAINTS, CD#160
$117.99
3307437526794040 1 Image
2011 Topps Five Star Rainbow Titus Young Patch ON CARD Auto 15 25 #177
$80.00
3807810145294040 1 Image
DARREN McFADDEN 2011 Topps Five Star Veteran Autograph AUTO Patch # 99 RAIDERS
$49.95
4004999024574040 1 Image
2011 Topps Five Star Football Ryan Williams Autographed Patch Card 18 55 On Card
$30.00
3007736772504040 1 Image
MARK INGRAM 2011 TOPPS FIVE STAR LETTER PATCH AUTO 1 1 #FSL-MI BGS 8.5 AU 10
$300.00
2512693817794040 1 Image
11 2011 Topps Five Star Christian Ponder 3C Jersey Patch Auto RC 65 BGS 9 MINT
$189.99
3007548226114040 1 Image
AARON RODGERS 2011 TOPPS FIVE STAR VETERAN AUTOGRAPHED PATCH 20 70 BGS 9.5 AU 10
$900.00
« Previous123456
 Image
 |  E-Mail | URL
Ryan's collecting origins began with winter bike rides to the corner store, tossing a couple of quarters onto the counter and peddling home with a couple packs of O-Pee-Chee hockey in his pocket. Today, he continues to build sets, go after inserts with cool technologies, chase Montreal Expos and finish off his John Jaha master collection. Ryan can be found on Twitter @tradercracks and Google+.

Leave a Comment: