Killer Cards: Dexter Autograph Trading Cards Guide

Killer Cards: Dexter Autograph Trading Cards Guide

Seasons 1 & 2

Dexter may not be going out with the excitement it generated during its early seasons, but few will argue that it's one of the most talked-about shows in recent history. For collectors, there are plenty of Dexter autographs to collect via Breygent trading cards. Nearly all of the show's main actors have signed cards, including several from Dexter Morgan himself, Michael C. Hall.

Shop for Breygent Dexter autographs on eBay.

So far, Breygent has put out three full releases, all of which have autographed trading cards as a key component. There have also been a handful of exclusives available at the San Diego Comic Con.

2009 Breygent Dexter trading cards cover seasons one and two. This set has the most Dexter autographs with a checklist that includes 11 cards. 2010 Breygent Dexter Season 3 added dual autographs and autographed costume cards to the mix. Moving towards a premium factory set format, 2012 Breygent Dexter Season 4 has just four autographs.

Besides Hall, other lead cast members signing at least once include Jennifer Carpenter (Debra Morgan), Julie Benz (Rita Bennett) and Lauren Vélez (Lt. Maria LaGuerta). Breygent is the only company to land autographed cards from both John Lithgow (Arthur "Trinity Killer" Mitchell) and Jimmy Smits (Miguel Prado).

One thing to watch for, particularly with Season 3 cards, is beaded ink. The markers and card stock didn't get along on many of the cards, making for some very poor autographs.

We've put together a full gallery of Dexter autographs from all three of Breygent's main Dexter sets released so far as well as those offered at the 2010 and 2012 San Diego Comic Cons. Seasons 1 and 2 are below. Other seasons can be seen by clicking on the tabs above.

2009 Breygent Dexter Autographs

Click on the names or images to shop for cards on eBay.

DA1 Michael C. Hall as Dexter Morgan

2009 Breygent Dexter Autographs DA1 Michael C. Hall as Dexter Morgan

DA3 Jennifer Carpenter as Debra Morgan

2009 Breygent Dexter Autographs DA3 Jennifer Carpenter as Debra Morgan

DA5 David Zayas as Angel Batista

DA7 C.S. Lee as Vincent Masuka

DA9 Margo Martindale as Camilla

DA11 Mark Pellegrino as Paul Bennett

DA2 Julie Benz as Rita Bennett

DA4 Lauren Vélez as Lt. Maria LaGuerta

DA6 James Remar as Harry Morgan

DA8 Erik King as Sgt. Doakes

DA10 Mark L. Young as Jeremy Downs

Top eBay Listings

Dexter Season 1 Autograph Card DA2 Julie Benz Rita Bennett
$75.00

DEXTER THE THIRD SEASON AUTOGRAPH COSTUME CARD #DH DESMOND HARRINGTON
$10.00

DEXTER SEASONS 7 & 8 DUAL AUTOGRAPH CARD YVONNE STRAHOVSKI #AYS2 (AUCTION)
$89.00

DEXTER SEASON 5 & 6 DUAL AUTOGRAPH MICHAEL C HALL & MARIA DOYLE KENNEDY AUCTION
$40.00

DEXTER SEASONS 7 & 8 DUAL AUTOGRAPH CARD MICHAEL C. HALL & YVONNE (AUCTION)
$95.00

2016 SDCC DEXTER 7 & 8 AUTOGRAPH COSTUME CARD MICHAEL C. HALL #CCAC1 (AUCTION)
$40.00

2016 DEXTER 7 & 8 3X5" AUTOGRAPH COSTUME CARD MICHAEL C. HALL #MAIL IN (AUCTION)
$49.95

SDCC DEXTER THE FOURTH SEASON AUTOGRAPH CARD MICHAEL C. HALL (AUCTION)
$45.00

DEXTER THE FOURTH SEASON AUTOGRAPH CARD MICHAEL C. HALL #D4 AMCH (AUCTION)
$35.00

2016 SDCC DEXTER SEASON 7 & 8 AUTOGRAPH COSTUME CARD AIMEE GARCIA #CCAC3
$17.00

2016 SDCC DEXTER SEASON 7 & 8 R AUTOGRAPH COSTUME 3X5" GEOFF PIERSON MAIL IN #GP
$95.00

2016 SDCC DEXTER SEASON 7 & 8 AUTOGRAPH COSTUME 3X5" MICHAEL C.HALL MAIL IN #MH
$95.00

2016 SDCC DEXTER SEASON 7 & 8 B AUTOGRAPH COSTUME 3X5" GEOFF PIERSON MAIL IN #GP
$95.00

2016 Dexter Season 7 & 8 Autograph #ASU Sam Underwood as Zach Hamilton Auto
$7.50

DEXTER SEASONS 7 & 8 2016 BREYGENT SAM UNDERWOOD ZACH AUTOGRAPH INSERT CARD ASU
$21.24

DEXTER SEASONS 7 & 8 2016 BREYGENT SAM UNDERWOOD ZACH AUTOGRAPH INSERT CARD ASU2
$21.24
« Previous1234

Season 3

2010 Breygent Dexter Season 3 Autographs

D3A-MCHJB Michael C. Hall as Dexter Morgan, Julie Benz as Rita Bennett

2010 Breygent Dexter Season 3 Autographs Michael C. Hall as Dexter Morgan and Julie Benz as Rita Bennett

D3A-JR James Remar as Harry Morgan

D3A-MCHS Michael C. Hall as Dexter Morgan

D3A-MCHJS Michael C. Hall as Dexter Morgan, Jimmy Smits as Miguel Prado

D3A-JS Jimmy Smits as Miguel Prado

2010 Breygent Dexter Season 3 Autographed Costume Cards

Red- and blue-ink autograph variations exist.

D3AC-CSL C.S. Lee as Vince Masuka

D3AC-DZ David Zayas as Angel Batista

D3AC-JB Julie Benz as Rita Bennett

D3AC-MCH Michael C. Hall as Dexter Morgan

2010 Breygent Dexter Season 3 Autographed Costume Card Michael C. Hall as Dexter Morgan (Black)

D3AC-DH Desmond Harrington as Joey Quinn

D3AC-JC Jennifer Carpenter as Debra Morgan

D3AC-LV Lauren Vélez as Maria LaGuerta


2010 Breygent Dexter Season 3 San Diego Comic Con Autographs

Michael C. Hall as Dexter Morgan


Jimmy Smits as Miguel Prado


Top eBay Listings

2016 DEXTER 7 & 8 3X5" AUTOGRAPH COSTUME CARD MICHAEL C. HALL #MAIL IN (AUCTION)
$49.95

2016 SDCC DEXTER SEASON 7 & 8 AUTOGRAPH COSTUME CARD AIMEE GARCIA #CCAC3
$17.00

2016 SDCC DEXTER SEASON 7 & 8 R AUTOGRAPH COSTUME 3X5" GEOFF PIERSON MAIL IN #GP
$95.00

2016 SDCC DEXTER SEASON 7 & 8 AUTOGRAPH COSTUME 3X5" MICHAEL C.HALL MAIL IN #MH
$95.00

2016 SDCC DEXTER SEASON 7 & 8 B AUTOGRAPH COSTUME 3X5" GEOFF PIERSON MAIL IN #GP
$95.00

Dexter Seasons 7 & 8 San Diego Exclusive Auto Costume Card CCAC3 Aimee Garcia
$16.47

2016 DEXTER SEASONS 7 & 8 RED AUTOGRAPH & COSTUME CARD GEOFF PIERSON #CA3
$39.39

DEXTER SEASONS 7 & 8 AUTOGRAPH CARD YVONNE STRAHOVSKI #AYS #3 of 5 (AUCTION)
$100.00

BREYGENT DEXTER SEASONS 5-8 SAN DIEGO SDCC AIMEE GARCIA AUTOGRAPH COSTUME CCAC3
$14.99

Dexter season 3 dual auto autograph D3A-MCHJB Hall and Benz
$91.80

DEXTER SEASON 3 VELEZ AUTOGRAPH COSTUME D3AC-LV BLACK
$32.88

DEXTER SEASON 3 LEE -MASUKA AUTOGRAPH COSTUME D3AC-CSL
$39.88

DEXTER SEASON 3 BLACK AUTOGRAPH MICHAEL C. HALL #D3A-MCHS
$85.00

DEXTER SEASON 3 JAMES REMAR AS HARRY MORGAN AUTOGRAPH CARD D3A-JR BLACK
$34.88

2010 DEXTER SEASON 3 MICHAEL C. HALL & JULIE BENZ AUTOGRAPH CARD D3A-MCHJB
$98.88

DEXTER SEASON 3 JIMMY SMITS AUTOGRAPH TRADING CARD #D3A-JS
$39.99
« Previous12

Season 4

2012 Breygent Dexter Season 4 Autographs

All but Hall have red ink and black ink versions.

D4-ACH Courtney Ford as Christine Hill

D4-AJL John Lithgow as Arthur Mitchell


D4-ADH Desmond Harrington as Joey Quinn

D4-AMCH Michael C. Hall as Dexter Morgan


2012 Breygent Dexter Season 4 San Diego Autographs

Michael C. Hall as Dexter Morgan


John Lithgow as Arthur Mitchell


Top eBay Listings

DEXTER THE FOURTH SEASON AUTOGRAPH CARD MICHAEL C. HALL #D4 AMCH (AUCTION)
$35.00

Dexter Seasons 7 & 8 San Diego Exclusive Auto Costume Card CCAC4 Jadon Wells
$16.47

Dexter Season 4 Sealed Card CASE 15 Sets Autograph Costume Prop Cards
$399.00

Dexter Seasons 5-8 JADON WELLS Autograph Costume Card CCAC4 j Harrison Morgan
$12.50

Dexter Season 4 John Lithgow Red Ink On-Card Auto Autograph 2012 Breygent
$39.95

Dexter Season 4 Trading Card - Courtney Ford RED Autograph - D4 ACF
$44.99

Dexter Season 4 Autograph Card D4 ADH Desmond Harrington As Joey Quinn
$36.72

DEXTER SEASON 4 MICHAEL HALL, JOHN LITHGOW, FORD, HARRINGTON AUTOGRAPH CARD SET
$209.88

Dexter Season 4 Four Sealed Card CASE 15 Sets Autograph Costume Prop Cards
$495.00

24 SEASON 4 NESTOR SERRANO AS NAVI ARAZ AUTOGRAPH CARD DEXTER NCIS
$9.73

Dexter Season 4 - D4-ACF Courtney Ford "Christine Hill" Auto Autograph Card
$52.44

Dexter Season 4 - D4-ADH Desmond Harrington "Joey Quinn" Auto Autograph Card
$39.33

Ryan Cracknell

E-Mail Author | 
Ryan is a former member of The Cardboard Connection Writing Staff. His collecting origins began with winter bike rides to the corner store, tossing a couple of quarters onto the counter and peddling home with a couple packs of O-Pee-Chee hockey in his pocket. Today, he continues to build sets, go after inserts with cool technologies, chase Montreal Expos and finish off his John Jaha master collection.

Leave a Comment:

MENU