Comprehensive Andrew McCutchen Rookie Card Guide

Comprehensive Andrew McCutchen Rookie Card Guide

It has been a long couple of decades for Pittsburgh Pirates fans. The last time the team had a winning season, Andrew McCutchen was just starting school. Finally, the team has clawed their way back to respectability, thanks in large part to their star outfielder. With that, Andrew McCutchen rookie card prices are starting to rise as more collectors get behind him and his underdog team.

Andrew McCutchen rookie cards were released in 2005. All are from Topps products. Three of McCutchen's rookies are autographed, including the 2005 Bowman Sterling card that also has a jersey swatch.

However, these are not the first Andrew McCutchen cards to come out of a MLB set. He was also included on the 2004 Bowman Draft AFLAC checklist. Available in both Bowman and Bowman Chrome versions, the cards were offered via redemption. There is also a rare 2004 Bowman Chrome AFLAC Autograph Andrew McCutchen card that has a print run of 90. It was offered to collectors as part of a specially created make-good set in lieu of a Gold Refractor redemption (more redemptions were printed than sets).

Andrew McCutchen Rookie Card Guide

2005 Bowman Draft Andrew McCutchen RC #63

The 2005 Bowman Draft Andrew McCutchen is considered one of his basic rookie cards. It has a clean picture of the future superstar smiling while warming up with his bat. This will always be one of McCutchen's most reasonably priced rookies.

Andrew McCutchen Rookie Cards - 2005 Bowman Draft Andrew McCutchen RC

2005 Bowman Chrome Draft Andrew McCutchen RC #63

Also inserted in packs of Bowman Draft, the 2005 Bowman Chrome Andrew McCutchen rookie has the same design only with chromium card stock. The card also boasts several Refractor parallels that are popular with collectors. Outside of McCutchen's autographed rookies, this is one of the best first-year options.

Andrew McCutchen Rookie Cards - 2005 Bowman Chrome Draft Andrew McCutchen

2005 Bowman Heritage Andrew McCutchen RC #330 SP

Andrew McCutchen has two cards in 2005 Bowman Heritage: is rookie card and a variation. Both have a horizontal layout. The regular card, a short print, pictures the outfielder wearing sunglasses standing against a green backdrop. The variation has McCutchen clutching a bat. Also included in 2005 Bowman Heritage is a Signs of Greatness Andrew McCutchen autograph. Although an insert, the card is notable for being the only 2005 McCutchen card to have an on-card signature.

Andrew McCutchen Rookie Cards - 2005 Bowman Heritage Andrew McCutchen RC No Bat 2005 Bowman Heritage Andrew McCutchen RC

2005 Bowman Sterling Andrew McCutchen RC #AM Autographed Jersey

One of only two Andrew McCutchen rookies to have an autograph, his 2005 Bowman Sterling card is also the only one to have a jersey piece. The card does not give much info about the jersey swatch other than it being playing-worn. Although the autograph is on a sticker, it's integrated well into the card's design.

Andrew McCutchen Rookie Cards - 2005 Bowman Sterling Andrew McCutchen RC Autographed Jersey

2005 Topps Update Andrew McCutchen RC #329

Simple and to the point, the 2005 Topps Update Andrew McCutchen rookie is a good option for those simply wanting to stockpile first-year cards of the Pirates star. Very affordable on the secondary market, the card has a clean image and simple design.

Andrew McCutchen Rookie Cards - 2005 Topps Update Andrew McCutchen RC

2005 Topps Chrome Update Andrew McCutchen RC #329 Autograph

The second Andrew McCutchen autographed rookie, the 2005 Topps Chrome Update card was inserted in packs of Topps Update. The large silver sticker doesn't quite fit in as well as it does with the 2005 Bowman Sterling card. Still, an autograph is an autograph, which is enough to keep this card in demand. There are also several Refractor parallels that are also autographed.

Andrew McCutchen Rookie Cards - 2005 Topps Chrome Update Andrew McCutchen RC Autograph

Top eBay Listings

Andrew McCutchen 2005 Topps Chrome U&H UH234 Auto Rookie Card rC PSA 10 Gem Mint
$329.00

2014 Topps Turkey Red #92 Andrew McCutchen Black Printing Plate 1 1 Lot W19
$79.99

2013 Topps Update Andrew McCutchen All Star #35 True 1 1 Blank Back TOPPS VAULT
$39.99

ANDREW MCCUTCHEN 2009 BOWMAN CHROME RC #178 X FRACTOR #'D 068 250 PIRATES
$19.99

ANDREW McCUTCHEN 2010 BOWMAN CHROME GOLD REFRACTOR #'D 19 50
$14.99

2009 Bowman Chrome RC Blue Refractor #'D 047 150 Andrew McCutchen #178 Rookie SP
$19.99

Andrew McCutchen 2013 Topps Gypsy Queen Pittsburgh Pirates Blue Cabinet Crd 499
$9.99

2011 Topps Topps 60 Autograph Andrew McCutchen (T60A-AM)
$17.51

2014 TOPPS "FINEST" BLACK REFRACTORS # 24 ANDREW McCUTCHEN 27 99
$5.50

2014 Panini Donruss Game Gear Game Jersey Andrew McCutchen Pittsburgh Pirates
$6.99

ANDREW McCUTCHEN AUTO 2011 PANINI LIMITED AUTOGRAPH 249
$7.30

2009 TOPPS UPDATE PIRATE ANDREW MCCUTCHEN GOLD PARALLEL RC SGC 92 8.5
$19.99
« Previous12345

Ryan Cracknell

E-Mail Author | 
Ryan's collecting origins began with winter bike rides to the corner store, tossing a couple of quarters onto the counter and peddling home with a couple packs of O-Pee-Chee hockey in his pocket. Today, he continues to build sets, go after inserts with cool technologies, chase Montreal Expos and finish off his John Jaha master collection. Ryan can be found on Twitter @tradercracks and Google+.

Leave a Comment: