| DD-1 | Felix Hernandez - Michael Pineda |
| DD-2 | Andre Ethier - Matt Kemp |
| DD-3 | Jered Weaver - Dan Haren |
| DD-4 | Albert Pujols - Lance Berkman |
| DD-5 | Eric Hosmer - Brandon Belt |
| DD-6 | Brett Anderson - Trevor Cahill |
| DD-7 | Starlin Castro - Darwin Barney |
| DD-8 | Joey Votto - Jay Bruce |
| DD-9 | Zack Greinke - Shaun Marcum |
| DD-10 | Michael Pineda - Zach Britton |
| DD-11 | Adam Dunn - Paul Konerko |
| DD-12 | Matt Holliday - Colby Rasmus |
| DD-13 | Mike Stanton - Logan Morrison |
| DD-14 | Jose Bautista - Adam Lind |
| DD-15 | Joe DiMaggio - Derek Jeter |
| DD-16 | Eric Hosmer - Danny Duffy |
| DD-17 | Craig Kimbrel - Julio Teheran |
| DD-18 | Adrian Gonzalez - Jose Bautista |
| DD-19 | Justin Verlander - Max Scherzer |
| DD-20 | Hank Aaron - Jose Bautista |
| DD-21 | David Price - James Shields |
| DD-22 | Ricky Romero - Kyle Drabek |
| DD-23 | David Ortiz - Vladimir Guerrero |
| DD-24 | Evan Longoria - Ben Zobrist |
| DD-25 | Eric Hosmer - Freddie Freeman |
| DD-26 | Buster Posey - Brian McCann |
| DD-27 | Grady Sizemore - Shin-Soo Choo |
| DD-28 | Brandon Phillips - Howie Kendrick |
| DD-29 | Matt Kemp - Jerry Sands |
| DD-30 | Sandy Koufax - Ryan Braun |
